Best Thrift Store in New York
Top Thrift Store Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 72 Thrift Store listings in New York · page 1 of 2
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Sayville, New York
- (631) 589-6220
- saint-anns.org
Saint Ann's Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Sayville, NY. It holds a rating of 4.10 based on customer reviews. The shop operates in connection with Saint Ann's Episcopal Church, a vibrant and inclusive community in Sayville. The parish is guided by a mission...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Irondequoit, New York
- (888) 859-1606
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Lockport, New York
- (716) 438-7840
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cheektowaga, New York
- (716) 393-3900
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Kingston, New York
- (845) 514-2010
- rewind.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- North Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 844-8121
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Selden, New York
- (631) 736-3979
- seldens.com
Selden Thrift is a Thrift Store in Selden, NY, located at 614 Middle Country Rd. It holds a rating of 2.00 based on customer reviews. The business name is alongside the title "Seldens Designer Home Furnishings," which describes a furniture retailer operating...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- East Patchogue, New York
- (631) 803-6775
- angelsoflongisland.com
Angels of Long Island is a Thrift Store in East Patchogue, NY. Established in 2015, the charity began as a small Facebook group dedicated to assisting one family and has since grown to include thousands of members across Long Island. The organization has...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Kingston, New York
- (845) 303-0313
- freetothrift.com
Free to Thrift is a Thrift Store in Kingston, NY, located at 104 Smith Ave. The store operates Wednesday through Monday from 10 to 7, accepting donations during regular business hours from 10 to 6. Clothing donations can be placed in a bin in the parking lot...
#10LuxeSwap
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Syosset, New York
- (516) 226-1055
- luxeswap.com
LuxeSwap is a thrift store in Syosset, NY. The business operates as a premier consignment house specializing in luxury menswear, heritage tailoring, and curated designer goods. Their offerings include outerwear, footwear, and rare finds, with all items...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 218-9589
- kentoncloset.org
Ken-Ton Closet is a thrift store in Tonawanda, NY. It is a 100% volunteer-run nonprofit dedicated to strengthening the community by meeting the basic needs of children in the Village of Kenmore and Town of Tonawanda. The organization provides free clothing...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Schenectady, New York
- (518) 280-2435
- thriftyconnections.com
Thrifty Connections is a thrift store in Schenectady, NY, offering handpicked home goods, women’s apparel, books, games, puzzles, and unique gifts with a focus on conscious consumption and creative reuse. The store serves individuals drawn to experiential...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Lackawanna, New York
- (716) 675-7963
- amvets.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Orchard Park, New York
- (716) 675-7963
- amvets.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Brighton, New York
- (585) 424-3730
- amvets.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Buffalo, New York
- (716) 873-7900
- amvets.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cheektowaga, New York
- (716) 684-0210
- amvets.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- West Seneca, New York
- (716) 671-2763
- goodwillaz.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Centereach, New York
- (631) 519-2158
- stores.savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Lockport, New York
- (716) 727-0762
- bearbottomwholesale.com
Bear Bottom Wholesale is a thrift store in Lockport, NY. The shop specializes in bringing retail items to the community at prices below wholesale rates. Each week, the store receives several truckloads of estate items and continually adds new inventory to its...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Elmont, New York
- (800) 728-7825
- satruck.org
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center of Elmont: The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center is a thrift store in Elmont, NY. It provides a venue for community members to donate a wide range of items, including clothing, furniture, household goods, appliances, and automobiles, as well as financial...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Albany, New York
- (518) 438-8277
- metropolisvintage.com
Metropolis Vintage of Albany is a thrift store in Albany, New York. The business specializes in a curated selection of true vintage clothing, jewelry, and accessories. In addition to their retail offerings, they provide professional estate services, including...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Staten Island, New York
- (347) 215-2070
- nothingnewthrift.com
Nothing New Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store in Staten Island, NY. They offer a variety of second-hand items including clothing, home goods, and accessories, all aimed at providing community members with affordable options while promoting sustainability. The...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Port Chester, New York
- (800) 728-7825
- satruck.org
The Salvation Army Thrift Store Port Chester is a thrift store in Port Chester, NY. It operates as part of The Salvation Army, an organization whose donation proceeds fund Adult Rehabilitation Centers. The store accepts a wide variety of goods for resale and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Newburgh, New York
- (845) 565-8200
- newburghvintageemporium.com
Newburgh Vintage Emporium Ware-House is a thrift store in Newburgh, NY. The business serves collectors, decorators, and treasure hunters by providing antiques, vintage clothing, furniture, collectibles, and one-of-a-kind finds. The establishment holds a 4.60...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Newburgh, New York
- (845) 562-5200
- newburghvintageemporium.com
Newburgh Vintage Emporium is a thrift store in Newburgh, NY. The business serves collectors, decorators, treasure hunters, and curious explorers by offering antiques, vintage clothing, furniture, collectibles, and one-of-a-kind finds. The flagship location...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Plattsburgh, New York
- (518) 563-7750
- seattleantiquesmarket.com
Antique & Variety Mall is a thrift store in Plattsburgh, NY, located at 12 Margaret St. The store serves residents and visitors seeking unique, affordable items, offering a diverse selection of secondhand goods including vintage clothing, household...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Amherst, New York
- (716) 580-3400
- platoscloset.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Albany, New York
- (518) 275-6638
- habitat.org
Habitat ReStore in the Capital District is a Thrift Store in Albany, NY, located at 71 Fuller Rd. It holds a rating of 4.20 based on customer reviews. The store operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Port Washington, New York
- (516) 883-9777
- pwtwinpines.com
Twin Pines Charitable Community Thrift Shop of Port Washington: Twin Pines Charitable Community Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Port Washington, NY, serving the north shore of Nassau County with a mission rooted in sustainability, community support, and inclusive employment. Operating as a 501(c)3 nonprofit since 1972...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Bay Shore, New York
- (631) 666-6207
- hiddentreasuresthrifting.com
Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop of Bay Shore: Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Bay Shore, New York, located at 1601 5th Ave. It holds a rating of 3.90. The shop carries pre-loved clothing, accessories, and home goods, along with antique items and one-of-a-kind vintage pieces. Its stock...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cortland, New York
- (607) 543-4010
- www2.cortland.edu
Cortland ReUse is a thrift store in Cortland, NY. The business is part of an academic community dedicated to diverse learning experiences, where students grow as engaged citizens through outstanding teaching, scholarship, and service. The institution offers...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 844-8121
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- New Rochelle, New York
- (914) 637-7600
- consignitonmainllc.com
Consign It on Main is a thrift store in New Rochelle, NY, located at 543 Main St. The business holds a 4.10 rating based on 562 reviews. This family-operated business has served the community for over ten years. It occupies a 3,800-plus-square-foot space in...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Beacon, New York
- (845) 202-0094
- beaconfleamarket.com
Beacon Flea Market is a thrift store in Beacon, NY. This seasonal outdoor market specializes in vintage, antiques, thrift, collectibles, and handmade items. Operating from April through November, the market serves the local community and visitors looking for...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mamaroneck, New York
- (914) 698-0300
- saintthomasmmrk.org
St Thomas Church Thrift Shop of Mamaroneck: St Thomas Church Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Mamaroneck, NY. The shop is part of the St. Thomas Episcopal Church community, which has served the area as a vital force since its incorporation in 1817. The shop maintains a 4.60 rating. As the oldest...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 782-8440
- watertownurbanmission.org
Watertown Urban Mission is a Thrift Store in Watertown, NY, located at 247 Factory St. The organization improves the standard of living in Jefferson County and surrounding areas by providing essential services to individuals and families facing poverty, food...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Auburn, New York
- (315) 406-0097
- regenerations2.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
- (631) 676-4579
- optionscl.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Medford, New York
- (631) 924-3082
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Garden City, New York
- (516) 489-1661
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Amherst, New York
- (716) 833-2391
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Commack, New York
- (631) 462-1268
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hicksville, New York
- (516) 452-9075
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Lackawanna, New York
- (716) 827-6550
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Orchard Park, New York
- (716) 827-6550
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Central Islip, New York
- (516) 858-1755
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Stony Brook, New York
- (631) 519-2158
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Oneonta, New York
- (607) 267-6447
- firstumc-oneonta.org
Helping Hands Thrift Shop is a nonprofit thrift store in Oneonta, New York, operated by the First United Methodist Church. It serves individuals and families in need by offering gently used clothing, household goods, and furniture at affordable prices, with a...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Yorktown Heights, New York
- (914) 743-1314
- yorktownloveinaction.com
Yorktown Love In Action - GIANT Thrift Shop & Donation Center is a thrift store in Yorktown Heights, NY. As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, they serve the Westchester and Putnam county communities by assisting individuals and families facing unforeseen...
Recently Updated Thrift Store in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Selden, New York
- (631) 736-3979
- seldens.com
Selden Thrift is a Thrift Store in Selden, NY, located at 614 Middle Country Rd. It holds a rating of 2.00 based on customer reviews. The business name is alongside the title "Seldens Designer Home Furnishings," which describes a furniture retailer operating...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Kingston, New York
- (845) 303-0313
- freetothrift.com
Free to Thrift is a Thrift Store in Kingston, NY, located at 104 Smith Ave. The store operates Wednesday through Monday from 10 to 7, accepting donations during regular business hours from 10 to 6. Clothing donations can be placed in a bin in the parking lot...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 218-9589
- kentoncloset.org
Ken-Ton Closet is a thrift store in Tonawanda, NY. It is a 100% volunteer-run nonprofit dedicated to strengthening the community by meeting the basic needs of children in the Village of Kenmore and Town of Tonawanda. The organization provides free clothing...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Albany, New York
- (518) 275-6638
- habitat.org
Habitat ReStore in the Capital District is a Thrift Store in Albany, NY, located at 71 Fuller Rd. It holds a rating of 4.20 based on customer reviews. The store operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Bay Shore, New York
- (631) 666-6207
- hiddentreasuresthrifting.com
Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop of Bay Shore: Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Bay Shore, New York, located at 1601 5th Ave. It holds a rating of 3.90. The shop carries pre-loved clothing, accessories, and home goods, along with antique items and one-of-a-kind vintage pieces. Its stock...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cortland, New York
- (607) 543-4010
- www2.cortland.edu
Cortland ReUse is a thrift store in Cortland, NY. The business is part of an academic community dedicated to diverse learning experiences, where students grow as engaged citizens through outstanding teaching, scholarship, and service. The institution offers...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- New Rochelle, New York
- (914) 637-7600
- consignitonmainllc.com
Consign It on Main is a thrift store in New Rochelle, NY, located at 543 Main St. The business holds a 4.10 rating based on 562 reviews. This family-operated business has served the community for over ten years. It occupies a 3,800-plus-square-foot space in...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 782-8440
- watertownurbanmission.org
Watertown Urban Mission is a Thrift Store in Watertown, NY, located at 247 Factory St. The organization improves the standard of living in Jefferson County and surrounding areas by providing essential services to individuals and families facing poverty, food...
What the Data Shows for Thrift Stores in New York
43% of the 54 thrift stores we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 40, compared with an average SEO score of 72.
The average Google rating across 70 rated thrift stores is 4.2, and the median listing has 188 reviews.
None of the 72 thrift stores has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 27, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best thrift store in New York? BizScoreAI scores 72 Thrift Store listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Thrift Store listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my thrift store listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every thrift store listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
