Best Insurance Agency in New York
Top Insurance Agency Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-29 of 29 Insurance Agency listings in New York · page 1 of 1
#1Plan Medicare - New York Medicare Agent Top-Rated
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 5169007877
- planmedicare.com
Plan Medicare - New York Medicare Agent is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The firm provides independent Medicare advice to individuals, families, retirees, and financial professionals across the United States. Services include free, personalized...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7187883585
- nextcenturyinsurance.com
Next Century Insurance is an insurance agency in New York, NY. The brokerage specializes in transportation insurance, providing TLC liability insurance for taxi, black car, yellow cab, green taxi, and livery vehicles. They also offer coverage for electric...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7187079616
- mkrspecialtyinsurance.com
MKR Specialty Insurance Brokerage, Inc. is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The firm provides a broad spectrum of commercial and personal insurance solutions, including Commercial Vehicle, Commercial Liability, Excess Liability, Property, Workers...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7183830306
- greenpointbroker.com
Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage of New York: Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. They offer comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individuals, families, and businesses across various states including NY, NJ, CT, PA, DE, IL, TX, UT, OH, GA, FL, and CO. Their...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2129627930
- acrisure.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2129426339
- acinsur.com
A & C Brokerage is an insurance agency in New York, NY. The agency specializes in providing TLC insurance for various commercial services, including black car, limousine, livery, green cab, and yellow taxi insurance. They also offer automobile, physical...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 9294992898
- csmithinsurancegroup.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Greenville, New York
- (877) 629-8003
- grapevilleagency.com
Grapeville Agency Associates LLC is an insurance agency in Greenville, NY, located at 4821 State Rte 81. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on 95 reviews. The agency provides auto, home, life, motorcycle, business, renters, and boat insurance to clients in...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 5164093379
- comparioninsurance.com
Robert Springer is an insurance agency in New York, NY, providing personalized coverage for auto, home, life, and umbrella insurance, as well as pet insurance and insurance consulting. Serving clients across New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, he brings...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 9146069164
- comparioninsurance.com
Shane Moran at Comparion Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. They specialize in providing personalized insurance quotes for car, home, life, and pet insurance needs. Shane Moran, a senior agent with over 15 years of experience, serves...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7186845200
- mendozaagencyinc.com
Mendoza Agency Inc of New York: Mendoza Agency Inc is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The agency serves residents and businesses in the Bronx and surrounding areas by offering a wide range of protection options. Specific policies include homeowners, auto, condo, renters, flood...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 5164093376
- comparioninsurance.com
Derek Lee at Comparion Insurance Agency is an insurance agency in New York, NY, providing personalized coverage solutions for auto, home, life, and umbrella insurance, as well as pet insurance and insurance consulting. Serving individuals and families across...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 9147850180
- comparioninsurance.com
Comparion Insurance Agency of New York: Comparion Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. They specialize in providing free quotes on auto, home, life, pet, and other types of insurance to their clients. With a rating of 4.20 based on reviews from satisfied customers, they serve...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2126839700
- gny.com
Greater New York Insurance Co is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY, located at 350 5th Ave 7th Floor. It provides tailored insurance solutions for businesses, including coverage for apartment buildings, co-ops, condos, restaurants, office buildings, hotels...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 6468142289
- rpkinsurance.com
General Liability Insurance Brooklyn is an insurance agency in New York, NY, specializing in commercial truck and auto insurance, personal insurance, homeowners insurance, and flood insurance. The agency serves individuals and businesses across New York, with...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 9293357566
- sherpabrokerage.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- (646) 600-5324
- insuranceprofessionalconsultants.com
Insurance Professional Consultants is an insurance agency in New York, NY, that serves clients across Queens with bilingual service in English and Spanish. The agency provides coverage for auto, home, and commercial insurance, along with DMV services such as...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7183558648
- newyorkchoiceinsurance.com
New York Choice Insurance Agency is an insurance agency in New York, NY, located at 30-02 Steinway St. It is an independent insurance brokerage agency that represents more than 20 top local and national insurance carriers to provide coverage for personal and...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 6466654639
- bettercoverdirect.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2129625620
- brownstoneagency.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2122532230
- thewaddleagency.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2124849888
- redbluecard.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 6467608743
- farmers.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2124933322
- goldriverinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2127252510
- krheeinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 9144587320
- usnews.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7185221200
- nyautoinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2127964373
- tyhealthinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2124521769
- agency.nationwide.com
Recently Updated Insurance Agency in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Plan Medicare - New York Medicare Agent Top-Rated
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 5169007877
- planmedicare.com
Plan Medicare - New York Medicare Agent is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The firm provides independent Medicare advice to individuals, families, retirees, and financial professionals across the United States. Services include free, personalized...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7187079616
- mkrspecialtyinsurance.com
MKR Specialty Insurance Brokerage, Inc. is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The firm provides a broad spectrum of commercial and personal insurance solutions, including Commercial Vehicle, Commercial Liability, Excess Liability, Property, Workers...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Greenville, New York
- (877) 629-8003
- grapevilleagency.com
Grapeville Agency Associates LLC is an insurance agency in Greenville, NY, located at 4821 State Rte 81. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on 95 reviews. The agency provides auto, home, life, motorcycle, business, renters, and boat insurance to clients in...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7186845200
- mendozaagencyinc.com
Mendoza Agency Inc of New York: Mendoza Agency Inc is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY. The agency serves residents and businesses in the Bronx and surrounding areas by offering a wide range of protection options. Specific policies include homeowners, auto, condo, renters, flood...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 2126839700
- gny.com
Greater New York Insurance Co is an Insurance Agency in New York, NY, located at 350 5th Ave 7th Floor. It provides tailored insurance solutions for businesses, including coverage for apartment buildings, co-ops, condos, restaurants, office buildings, hotels...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 6468142289
- rpkinsurance.com
General Liability Insurance Brooklyn is an insurance agency in New York, NY, specializing in commercial truck and auto insurance, personal insurance, homeowners insurance, and flood insurance. The agency serves individuals and businesses across New York, with...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- (646) 600-5324
- insuranceprofessionalconsultants.com
Insurance Professional Consultants is an insurance agency in New York, NY, that serves clients across Queens with bilingual service in English and Spanish. The agency provides coverage for auto, home, and commercial insurance, along with DMV services such as...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- New York, New York
- 7183558648
- newyorkchoiceinsurance.com
New York Choice Insurance Agency is an insurance agency in New York, NY, located at 30-02 Steinway St. It is an independent insurance brokerage agency that represents more than 20 top local and national insurance carriers to provide coverage for personal and...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agencies in New York
25% of the 20 insurance agencies we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 41, compared with an average SEO score of 68.
The average Google rating across 27 rated insurance agencies is 4.6, and the median listing has 95 reviews.
None of the 29 insurance agencies has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 27, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agency in New York? BizScoreAI scores 29 Insurance Agency listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Insurance Agency listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agency listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agency listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
