Best Pet Store in New York
Top Pet Store Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 168 Pet Store listings in New York · page 1 of 4
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- North Massapequa, New York
- (631) 842-1230
- petswarehouse.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- West Babylon, New York
- (888) 839-9638
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Woodmere, New York
- (516) 569-3647
- fidofitnessclub.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Mt. Vernon, New York
- (914) 235-0796
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Ithaca, New York
- (607) 277-3391
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Huntington Station, New York
- (631) 760-7850
- naturalhounds.com
Natural Hounds of Huntington Station is a Pet Store in Huntington Station, NY, located at 44 Gerard St. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews. The business produces fresh all-natural dog food by hand on Long Island since 2018. Real meat, organs...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- West Babylon, New York
- (631) 760-7850
- naturalhounds.com
Natural Hounds of West Babylon is a Pet Store in West Babylon, NY, located at 73 W Main St. The business produces fresh all-natural dog food by hand on Long Island using whole ingredients. Real meat, organs, and vegetables are gently cooked to create recipes...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Port Chester, New York
- (914) 908-4710
- dogtopia.com
Dogtopia of Port Chester is a pet store in Port Chester, NY. The facility provides award-winning dog daycare, overnight and weekend boarding, and spa services. Serving the local community, the center focuses on safe socialization, exercise, and education for...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Roosevelt, New York
- (516) 490-4110
- petstoryny.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Babylon, New York
- (631) 422-0213
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Clarence, New York
- (716) 565-2398
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Cheektowaga, New York
- (716) 893-2398
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Commack, New York
- (631) 543-1025
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Deer Park, New York
- (631) 992-7035
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- East Meadow, New York
- (516) 731-2592
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Farmingdale, New York
- (631) 843-1890
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Floral Park, New York
- (516) 502-1481
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Greece, New York
- (585) 227-6700
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Lake Grove, New York
- (631) 265-7010
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- North Bellmore, New York
- (516) 809-8464
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- West Seneca, New York
- (716) 825-6212
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- White Plains, New York
- (914) 461-2306
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Commack, New York
- (631) 462-1643
- stores.petco.com
Petco of Commack: Petco is a pet store in Commack, NY, located at 30 Veterans Memorial Hwy. It holds a 4.20 rating based on customer reviews. The store offers a wide selection of pet food, treats, toys, tanks, leashes, and other everyday essentials. It also carries unique...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Peekskill, New York
- (914) 528-4478
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Plattsburgh, New York
- (518) 562-8600
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Saratoga Springs, New York
- (518) 580-9374
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Utica, New York
- (315) 768-2335
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Valley Stream, New York
- (516) 561-2418
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Colonie, New York
- (518) 452-5683
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Irondequoit, New York
- (585) 467-0310
- stores.petco.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Kingston, New York
- (845) 336-0485
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Poughkeepsie, New York
- (845) 224-2076
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Binghamton, New York
- (607) 770-7318
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Schenectady, New York
- (518) 372-0300
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Glen Cove, New York
- (516) 671-9601
- getrawnutrition.com
Raw Dog Food Meat-Holistic Raw K9 Food is a Pet Store in Glen Cove, NY, located at 224 A Glen Cove Ave. It holds a rating of 5.00 based on customer reviews. The business website features RAW Nutrition, a sports nutrition brand offering premium supplements...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Lockport, New York
- (716) 434-5679
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Huntington Station, New York
- (631) 425-0913
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Lockport, New York
- (716) 434-9377
- clydesfeed.com
Clyde's Feed & Animal Center of Lockport: Clyde's Feed & Animal Center is a pet store in Lockport, NY. This family-owned and operated business provides full-service animal and garden supplies, including pet food, horse feed, wild bird supplies, and lawn and garden products. Serving the local...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Amherst, New York
- (716) 831-1350
- treats-unleashed.com
Treats Unleashed Inc is a pet store in Amherst, NY, serving local pet owners with a comprehensive selection of natural pet food, fresh-baked treats, toys, grooming services, and health supplements for dogs and cats. The store specializes in hand-selected...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Hamburg, New York
- (716) 648-2171
- clydesfeed.com
Clyde's Feed & Animal Center of Hamburg is a family-owned pet store in Hamburg, NY, serving the local community with a full range of animal and garden supplies. Since 1984, the business has provided quality feed for horses, livestock, and poultry, along with...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Buffalo, New York
- (716) 876-6663
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Utica, New York
- (315) 768-4488
- petsmart.com
Pet Supplies Plus of Utica: Pet Supplies Plus is a pet store in Utica, NY. The business provides a variety of quality pet products, food, and accessories for numerous animals, including dogs, cats, fish, birds, reptiles, small pets, and farm or backyard animals. Beyond retail supplies...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Long Beach, New York
- (516) 670-0470
- treatapp.co
Treat Your Pet is a pet supply store in Long Beach, New York, dedicated to supporting shelter dogs through innovative community engagement. The business offers pet supplies while operating a unique app-based initiative that connects users with real dogs in...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Elmont, New York
- (516) 350-9197
- dovesworld.com
DovesWorld.com is a pet store in Elmont, NY, located at 260 Elmont Rd. Founded by Mark Elie, the business operates as an online dove shop that breeds and hand-raises Ringneck Doves in backyard aviaries. The birds are raised as pets and companions rather than...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Troy, New York
- (518) 283-4027
- healthypetcenters.com
Healthy Pet Center of Troy: Healthy Pet Center is a Pet Store in Troy, NY. The shop provides a full range of pet supplies, including healthy dog and cat foods, treats, supplements, toys, beds, grooming supplies, crates, carriers, as well as small‑animal foods, bedding, bird seed and...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Glen Cove, New York
- (516) 403-2368
- petsmart.com
PetSmart of Glen Cove is a Pet Store in Glen Cove, NY, located at 121 School St. The store provides essential pet supplies, including food and treats from top brands, and offers services such as grooming, training, and adoptions. Customers can also utilize...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Huntington, New York
- (631) 549-0845
- petco.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Amsterdam, New York
- (518) 842-2652
- petsmart.com
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 291-9715
- avalonexotics.com
Avalon Exotics is a Pet Store in Tonawanda, NY, located at 70 Webster St. The business specializes in non-traditional pets, offering a selection of reptiles, amphibians, and arachnids for customers in North Tonawanda and the wider Buffalo area. Avalon Exotics...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Syracuse, New York
- (315) 446-6320
- petsmart.com
Recently Updated Pet Store in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Nanuet, New York
- (845) 620-1301
- petsmart.com
PetSmart of Nanuet: PetSmart is a Pet Store in Nanuet, NY, located at 155 NY-59. The store provides essential pet supplies, including food and treats from top brands, and offers a range of specialized services such as grooming, training, adoptions, veterinary care, and curbside...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Queens, New York
- (718) 706-8100
- wespawpets.com
Wespaw Pets is a Pet Store in Queens, NY, located at 44-05 Queens Blvd. It serves pet owners with a vast selection of products for dogs, cats, birds, and small animals, including nutritious food, fun toys, and daily essentials. The store offers local...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Dobbs Ferry, New York
- (646) 226-1998
- westchesterpuppies.com
Westchester Puppies & Kittens of Dobbs Ferry is a pet store in Dobbs Ferry, NY, located at 26 S Central Ave. It holds a rating of 3.00 based on customer reviews. The business specializes in the sale of puppies and kittens, aiming to help customers select the...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Jamestown, New York
- (716) 296-0512
- runnings.com
Runnings of Jamestown: Runnings is a Pet Store in Jamestown, NY, located at 720 Fairmount Ave. The store serves customers with a wide array of products for home, farm, and outdoor needs, including pet and animal supplies, automotive items, sporting goods, and lawn and garden...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Oneida, New York
- (315) 363-0860
- tractorsupply.com
Tractor Supply Co. of Oneida is a Pet Store in Oneida, NY, located at 401 Upper Lenox Ave. The business serves residents and agriculturalists with a wide selection of products for livestock, pets, gardening, and lawn care. Inventory includes farm supplies...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Glen Cove, New York
- (516) 676-5913
- coveanimalrescue.org
Cove Animal Rescue is a Pet Store in Glen Cove, NY, located at 40 Shore Rd. The organization rescues, rehabilitates, and rehomes dogs and cats, providing training, socialization, and medical treatment to help animals transition to loving forever homes. It...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Scarsdale, New York
- (914) 725-3022
- choicepet.com
Choice Pet - Scarsdale is a Pet Store in Scarsdale, NY, located at 1 Palmer Ave. It holds a rating of 4.60 based on customer reviews. The store serves local pet families with a focus on holistic, organic, raw, and natural foods, treats, and chews, alongside a...
Score breakdown
- Pet Store
- Hicksville, New York
- (516) 396-9310
- catdiggitydog.com
Cat Diggity Dog Salon - Groomer, Grooming is a Pet Store in Hicksville, NY, located at 37 Woodbury Rd. The business offers dog and cat grooming services, including full grooming packages that feature haircuts, baths, nail cuts, ear cleaning, and cologne...
What the Data Shows for Pet Stores in New York
48% of the 84 pet stores we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 43, compared with an average SEO score of 76.
The average Google rating across 164 rated pet stores is 4.4, and the median listing has 1,946 reviews.
None of the 168 pet stores has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 26, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best pet store in New York? BizScoreAI scores 168 Pet Store listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Pet Store listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my pet store listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every pet store listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
