Best Insurance Agent in New York
Top Insurance Agent Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 409 Insurance Agent listings in New York · page 1 of 9
#1Public Insurance Co Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Yonkers, New York
- (914) 303-6125
- public.com
#2Freeway Insurance of Syracuse Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Syracuse, New York
- (315) 514-0626
- freeway.com
#3Freeway Insurance of Buffalo Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Buffalo, New York
- (716) 588-0715
- freeway.com
#4New Buffalo Insurance Agency, Inc. Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Buffalo, New York
- (716) 332-1570
- newbuffaloinsurance.com
New Buffalo Insurance Agency, Inc. is an Insurance Agent in Buffalo, NY. They specialize in commercial insurance and risk management, serving individuals, families, and businesses with a range of services including home insurance, auto insurance, health...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cohoes, New York
- (518) 237-3808
- stanley1913.com
#6Quinton Insurance of Rochester Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rochester, New York
- (585) 244-9004
- quintoninsurance.com
Quinton Insurance of Rochester is an Insurance Agent in Rochester, NY. The agency provides Commercial and Business Insurance, Contractors Insurance, Property Insurance, Auto and Car Insurance, Home Insurance, and Life Insurance for clients across New York...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Yonkers, New York
- (914) 327-2954
- agentsantiago.com
#8Freeway Insurance Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 600-3571
- freeway.com
#9Toni DuBois Agency, LLC Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Buffalo, New York
- (716) 931-5200
- toniduboisagency.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Melville, New York
- (516) 799-9001
- prkinsurance.com
PRK Insurance Agency Inc is an Insurance Agent in Melville, NY. It provides personal and commercial insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses across New York. The agency offers homeowners, auto, flood, business owners, umbrella, commercial...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Yonkers, New York
- (914) 303-6125
- public.com
Public Insurance Co NY is an Insurance Agent in Yonkers, NY. The business provides insurance-related services, catering to individuals and families in the local area. With a strong online presence and over 268 reviews, the company maintains a 4.10 rating...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Olean, New York
- (716) 373-4401
- petruzziinsurance.com
Petruzzi Insurance Agency, LLC is an insurance agent in Olean, NY. The agency provides a wide range of services including auto, homeowners, and business/commercial insurance to clients throughout South Western New York and Northwest Pennsylvania. Their...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Brighton, New York
- (585) 789-6488
- twelvecornersinsurance.com
Twelve Corners Insurance Agency LLC is an Insurance Agent in Brighton, NY. The agency provides business, renters, recreational, car, and homeowners insurance in Rochester, NY, and the greater New York area. It serves customers in the Greater Rochester Area...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Lackawanna, New York
- (716) 883-1455
- deckeragency.com
The Decker Agency, Inc. is an Insurance Agent in Lackawanna, NY, located at 37 Elmwood Ave. Established in 1953, it is a full-service, independent insurance agency providing auto, home, and business insurance for clients throughout Buffalo and all of New...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- New York, New York
- (212) 233-0606
- meileefuagency.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Albany, New York
- (315) 227-3323
- trustedhealth.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Huntington Station, New York
- (631) 427-6093
- garbeassociates.com
Garbe Associates Insurance - Huntington is an insurance agent in Huntington Station, NY. The agency specializes in providing home, auto, and business insurance to residents and companies throughout Long Island and all of New York. They offer a 5.00 rating...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- New York, New York
- (212) 799-7500
- insurenyc.com
Insure NYC Brokerage Inc is an insurance agent in New York, NY. The brokerage is a team of licensed agents serving New York City and the surrounding area since 1993, offering co-op, condo, homeowners, business, and personal lines insurance, plus commercial...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Syosset, New York
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Yonkers, New York
- (914) 294-4080
- agents.allstate.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cheektowaga, New York
- (716) 836-8500
- wlosinsurance.com
Wlos Insurance Agency is a Insurance Agent in Cheektowaga, NY. The agency offers a full range of personal and commercial coverage, including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and marine policies, as well as business owners packages, commercial auto...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Syosset, New York
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Uniondale, New York
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Poughkeepsie, New York
- (845) 454-1500
- cartermgm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- North Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 883-1455
- deckeragency.com
The Decker Agency, Inc. is an insurance agent in North Tonawanda, NY. Serving Buffalo and the entirety of New York, the agency specializes in a wide variety of personal and commercial coverages, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. Their...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Syosset, New York
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rochester, New York
- (585) 427-8220
- statefarm.com
Dominic Agostini - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Rochester, NY. The agency provides a variety of coverage options including auto, motorcycle, homeowners, condo, renters, life, and pet insurance, as well as Medicare supplements and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Newburgh, New York
- (845) 564-1500
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rome, New York
- (315) 371-4225
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mount Vernon, New York
- (914) 662-8842
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rome, New York
- (315) 336-5595
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 785-8011
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- North Massapequa, New York
- (516) 798-3276
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Clifton Park, New York
- (518) 373-4111
- gtm.com
GTM Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Clifton Park, New York, serving individuals and businesses with comprehensive insurance and employee benefits solutions. The agency specializes in workers’ compensation, employee benefits, and insurance services...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rome, New York
- (315) 339-3300
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Middletown, New York
- (845) 342-4888
- joyinsurance.com
Joy Insurance is an insurance agent in Middletown, NY. The agency provides a wide range of personal and business insurance services to clients throughout Middletown and all of New York. Their specialties include auto, homeowners, motorcycle, and business...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mount Vernon, New York
- (914) 665-9433
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mt. Vernon, New York
- (914) 665-9433
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Oneonta, New York
- (607) 432-2022
- onegroup.com
OneGroup of Oneonta: OneGroup is an Insurance Agent in Oneonta, NY, located at 17 Watkins Ave Apartment 1. The firm provides insurance, risk management, employee benefits, and strategic human resources consulting to individuals, businesses, and organizations. Services include...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 221-2886
- geico.com
Mark Smith - GEICO Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Watertown, NY. They offer a wide range of insurance products including car, motorcycle, ATV, RV, boat, and more. Additionally, they provide property insurance such as homeowners, renters, and condo...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Shirley, New York
- (631) 337-3625
- abcmedicareplansbroker.com
ABC Medicare Plans Broker is an Insurance Agent in Shirley, NY. They specialize in helping individuals understand and navigate their Medicare options, including Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplements, and Part D plans. Diane Andree, the...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rochester, New York
- (585) 571-7006
- agent.travelers.com
The Belmont Agency Insurance of Rochester: The Belmont Agency Insurance is a trusted insurance agent in Rochester, New York, serving individuals and businesses with comprehensive coverage solutions. Specializing in home, auto, renters, condo, landlord, boat and yacht, umbrella, jewelry and valuable...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Plattsburgh, New York
- (518) 561-7000
- northerninsuring.com
Northern Insuring Agency, Inc is an insurance agent in Plattsburgh, NY. As the largest locally-owned, independent insurance agency in Northern New York, they provide a variety of services including home, auto, life, health, and business insurance, as well as...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mamaroneck, New York
- (888) 327-6335
- farmers.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- New York, New York
- (718) 865-8458
- kellyqu.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 832-3670
- klhudsoninsurance.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Poughkeepsie, New York
- (845) 454-2493
- marshallsterling.com
Marshall + Sterling Insurance: Locks, Keys and More is a locksmith in El Paso, TX. The company provides mobile locksmith services for homes, businesses, and vehicles in El Paso and surrounding areas, handling lockouts, lost keys, and lock installations and repairs. It holds a rating of...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mt. Vernon, New York
- (914) 662-8842
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Amsterdam, New York
- (518) 843-1253
- kinowskiagency.com
Kinowski Agency Inc is an insurance agent in Amsterdam, NY, located at 478 Locust Ave. The agency provides a variety of insurance types, including auto, home, commercial, life, and umbrella coverage. Specialized offerings include boat/watercraft, classic car...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Dobbs Ferry, New York
- (845) 231-3479
- firstcitizens.com
Recently Updated Insurance Agent in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- East Meadow, New York
- (516) 222-2242
- skinneragency.com
Skinner Agency of East Meadow is an insurance agent in East Meadow, NY. The agency provides various personal and commercial insurance coverages, including auto, homeowners, individual life, ATV, boat and watercraft, and business insurance. They serve clients...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Spring Valley, New York
- (845) 426-0868
- edouardinsurance.com
Edouard Insurance Agency Inc is an Insurance Agent in Spring Valley, NY. This independent agency provides auto, taxi, livery, commercial auto, truck, and trucking insurance to clients in Spring Valley and throughout the state of New York. As an independent...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Tarrytown, New York
- (914) 631-7628
- reyinsurance.com
Rey Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Tarrytown, NY, located at 219 N Broadway. The agency offers personal and business insurance options, including auto, home, renters, and umbrella coverage. It serves neighbors in Sleepy Hollow, Tarrytown, and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Central Islip, New York
- (631) 581-0100
- lighthouseinsurance.com
Lighthouse Insurance - Islip of Central Islip is an insurance agent in Central Islip, NY. The agency serves New Yorkers and offers personalized quotes across personal and commercial lines, including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and personal...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Elmira, New York
- (607) 734-8799
- wallininsurance.com
Wallin Insurance Agency Inc. is an Insurance Agent in Elmira, NY. As an independent New York State insurance agency, it specializes in both personal and commercial lines. The agency serves clients in Elmira and the surrounding area, offering solutions for a...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- North Amityville, New York
- (631) 841-0270
- eatoninsurance.com
Eaton Insurance is an Insurance Agent in North Amityville, NY. It offers quality insurance programs for Business and Personal Lines from top insurance companies worldwide. The agency serves discerning clients, whether they are starting out or seasoned...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Oneonta, New York
- (607) 432-7296
- hughsonbenson.com
Hughson & Benson Associates - Oneonta Office is an insurance agent in Oneonta, NY. The agency writes auto, homeowners, renters, life, and business insurance, along with snowmobile, ATV, and RV policies and coverage for antique and classic cars. Its commercial...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Bronx, New York
- (718) 532-6000
- almedainsurance.com
Almeda Insurance is an insurance agent in Bronx, NY, located at 1687 Jerome Ave. The business provides personal and business insurance, income tax preparation, and driver's education services, and holds a 4.60 rating based on customer reviews. Almeda...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agents in New York
25% of the 273 insurance agents we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 38, compared with an average SEO score of 72, and their average citation score is 40.
The average Google rating across 399 rated insurance agents is 4.7, and the median listing has 17 reviews.
None of the 409 insurance agents has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agent in New York? BizScoreAI scores 409 Insurance Agent listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Insurance Agent listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agent listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agent listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.