Best Ice Cream Shop in New York
Top Ice Cream Shop Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 59 Ice Cream Shop listings in New York · page 1 of 2
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Tarrytown, New York
- (914) 418-5649
- noblepies.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Oneonta, New York
- (518) 581-1200
- stewartsshops.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Niagara Falls, New York
- (800) 444-6689
- brycecanyoncountry.com
Bryce's Ice Cream is an ice cream shop in Niagara Falls, NY. The establishment holds a 4.20 rating from its customers. The business is located on Prospect Street, near the Niagara Wax Museum of History and the Civil War Veterans' Monument. It is a short walk...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Cohoes, New York
- (518) 785-0660
- guptillsicecream.gotoeat.net
Guptill's Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Cohoes, NY. The shop serves classic ice cream and soft‑serve treats in a friendly, relaxed setting, offering flavors such as indulgent chocolate cones, double scoops dipped in chocolate, and a range of menu items...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Dobbs Ferry, New York
- go-greenly.com
Go Greenly is an ice cream shop in Dobbs Ferry, NY. The business offers a variety of frozen treats, including frozen yogurt, bubble tea, and smoothies, serving the Dobbs Ferry and Scarsdale areas. They maintain a 4.50 rating from customers. The shop prepares...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Saratoga Springs, New York
- (888) 454-5946
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Babylon, New York
- (888) 454-5946
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Rome, New York
- nickydoodles.com
Nicky Doodles is an ice cream shop and American restaurant in Rome, NY. Serving the local community with a fun family experience, they offer an extensive selection of treats including 50 flavors of soft-serve ice cream, 30 flavors of hard ice cream, and 28...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Staten Island, New York
- (718) 701-6891
- sugarhouseicecream.com
Sugar House Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Staten Island, NY, located at 2003 Victory Blvd. The business offers a variety of kosher ice cream, milkshakes, smoothies, and waffle cones. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. Their menu includes...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Middletown, New York
- (909) 355-0515
- lamichoacana-usa.com
Michoacana sabor a mexico: Michoacana Sabor a México is an ice cream shop in Middletown, New York, specializing in artisanal frozen treats inspired by traditional Mexican recipes. The shop is known for its handcrafted Esquimals, milk-based pops covered in chocolate and topped with...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Sayville, New York
- sweetfrog.com
sweetFrog Premium Frozen Yogurt of Sayville is an ice cream shop in Sayville, NY. The establishment provides a customizable frozen treat experience where guests can select from various premium frozen yogurt flavors and finish their creations with a wide array...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Irondequoit, New York
- brusters.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Franklin Square, New York
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Pittsford, New York
- (585) 967-3938
- yotality.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Port Jefferson Station, New York
- (888) 454-5946
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Saratoga Springs, New York
- (802) 992-2600
- benjerry.com
Ben & Jerry's of Saratoga Springs is an ice cream shop in Saratoga Springs, NY, offering a rotating selection of super premium ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and non-dairy treats. Located at 34 Phila St, the shop serves locals and visitors with handcrafted...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ronkonkoma, New York
- (802) 992-2600
- benjerry.com
Ben & Jerry's of Ronkonkoma is a premium ice cream shop in Ronkonkoma, New York, offering a curated selection of super-premium ice creams, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and non-dairy treats. Located at 3 Hawkins Ave Unit #1104, the shop serves locals and visitors...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Gates, New York
- brusters.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Orangeburg, New York
- (845) 365-3166
- hogansdinerorangeburg.com
Hogan's Diner is an ice cream shop and family-friendly diner in Orangeburg, NY. The establishment provides excellent service and offers daily breakfast, lunch, and dinner specials to the local community. With a 4.60 rating, the diner serves a variety of menu...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Port Chester, New York
- (914) 481-5712
- bonabonaicecream.com
Bona Bona Ice Cream of Port Chester is a small-batch ice cream shop located on Westchester Avenue in Port Chester, New York. The shop specializes in chef-crafted, handcrafted desserts made in-house using high-quality ingredients, with a focus on unique and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Brooklyn, New York
- (718) 522-5211
- brooklynicecreamfactory.com
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory is an Ice Cream Shop in Brooklyn, NY, located at 14 Old Fulton St. Founded in 2001, the business handcrafts ice cream using all-natural ingredients, creating a variety of egg-free and gluten-free flavors. Signature offerings include...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- East Patchogue, New York
- kilwins.com
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge is a beloved ice cream shop in East Patchogue, New York, located at 74 E Main St. The shop specializes in handcrafted fudge, premium ice cream, caramel apples, caramel corn, brittle, and a variety of chocolate-dipped...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Massena, New York
- (315) 764-0693
- stewarts.com
Stewart's Shops of Massena: Stewart's Shops is an ice cream shop in Massena, New York, serving local customers with frozen treats and refreshments. Located at 20 Maple Street, the shop operates within the community of Massena and is situated near several key local landmarks. It is a...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- West Hempstead, New York
- (516) 538-3400
- carvel.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Smithtown, New York
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Middle Island, New York
- (631) 924-1909
- carvel.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Levittown, New York
- coldstonecreamery.com
#28Funky Beez
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Vestal, New York
- (607) 205-1426
- funkybeez.com
Funky Beez is an Ice Cream Shop in Vestal, NY. The shop serves loaded hot dogs, creamy shakes, and a range of sweet treats, and the menu is organized around three main offerings: hot dogs, ice cream, and shakes and sundaes. Hot dog options include beef...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- East Islip, New York
- (631) 666-2229
- coylesicecream.com
Coyles Homemade Ice Cream of East Islip is an Ice Cream Shop in East Islip, NY, located at 509 Main St. The business serves the community with handcrafted, homemade ice cream made using time-honored recipes and locally sourced ingredients. It offers a variety...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Farmingville, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Franklin Square, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Suffern, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- West Islip, New York
- (763) 292-0718
- wondersicecream.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Troy, New York
- (518) 273-7761
- sycawaycreamery.com
Sycaway Creamery Inc is an ice cream shop and wholesale dairy distributor in Troy, NY. The business provides a wide variety of brand name products, including milk, ice cream, cheese, butter, eggs, and beverages, to a diverse service area. They serve many...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Tarrytown, New York
- (914) 366-7420
- mainstreetsweets.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- North Amityville, New York
- shop.hersheys.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ithaca, New York
- (607) 254-4636
- cornell.edu
- Ice Cream Shop
- Tarrytown, New York
- (914) 421-1300
- villagecreameryandweetshop.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Guilderland, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Pittsford, New York
- (800) 934-6267
- wegmans.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ithaca, New York
- purityicecreammco.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- New York, New York
- amorinogelato.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Orchard Park, New York
- coldstone.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Depew, New York
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- West Hempstead, New York
- (516) 481-7636
- rbakery.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Lackawanna, New York
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- North New Hyde Park, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Levittown, New York
- shop.hersheys.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Nanuet, New York
- baskinrobbins.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Eastchester, New York
- (914) 472-1400
- scoop.sh
Recently Updated Ice Cream Shop in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Cohoes, New York
- (518) 785-0660
- guptillsicecream.gotoeat.net
Guptill's Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Cohoes, NY. The shop serves classic ice cream and soft‑serve treats in a friendly, relaxed setting, offering flavors such as indulgent chocolate cones, double scoops dipped in chocolate, and a range of menu items...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Staten Island, New York
- (718) 701-6891
- sugarhouseicecream.com
Sugar House Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Staten Island, NY, located at 2003 Victory Blvd. The business offers a variety of kosher ice cream, milkshakes, smoothies, and waffle cones. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. Their menu includes...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Saratoga Springs, New York
- (802) 992-2600
- benjerry.com
Ben & Jerry's of Saratoga Springs is an ice cream shop in Saratoga Springs, NY, offering a rotating selection of super premium ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and non-dairy treats. Located at 34 Phila St, the shop serves locals and visitors with handcrafted...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Brooklyn, New York
- (718) 522-5211
- brooklynicecreamfactory.com
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory is an Ice Cream Shop in Brooklyn, NY, located at 14 Old Fulton St. Founded in 2001, the business handcrafts ice cream using all-natural ingredients, creating a variety of egg-free and gluten-free flavors. Signature offerings include...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Port Chester, New York
- (914) 481-5712
- bonabonaicecream.com
Bona Bona Ice Cream of Port Chester is a small-batch ice cream shop located on Westchester Avenue in Port Chester, New York. The shop specializes in chef-crafted, handcrafted desserts made in-house using high-quality ingredients, with a focus on unique and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Massena, New York
- (315) 764-0693
- stewarts.com
Stewart's Shops of Massena: Stewart's Shops is an ice cream shop in Massena, New York, serving local customers with frozen treats and refreshments. Located at 20 Maple Street, the shop operates within the community of Massena and is situated near several key local landmarks. It is a...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Vestal, New York
- (607) 205-1426
- funkybeez.com
Funky Beez is an Ice Cream Shop in Vestal, NY. The shop serves loaded hot dogs, creamy shakes, and a range of sweet treats, and the menu is organized around three main offerings: hot dogs, ice cream, and shakes and sundaes. Hot dog options include beef...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- East Islip, New York
- (631) 666-2229
- coylesicecream.com
Coyles Homemade Ice Cream of East Islip is an Ice Cream Shop in East Islip, NY, located at 509 Main St. The business serves the community with handcrafted, homemade ice cream made using time-honored recipes and locally sourced ingredients. It offers a variety...
What the Data Shows for Ice Cream Shops in New York
6% of the 35 ice cream shops we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 31, compared with an average SEO score of 68.
The average Google rating across 57 rated ice cream shops is 4.3, and the median listing has 462 reviews.
None of the 59 ice cream shops has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best ice cream shop in New York? BizScoreAI scores 59 Ice Cream Shop listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Ice Cream Shop listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my ice cream shop listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every ice cream shop listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
