Best Pizza Place in New York
Top Pizza Place Listings in New York
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 54 Pizza Place listings in New York · page 1 of 2
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Lancaster, New York
- (716) 631-0222
- picassospizza.net
Picasso's Pizza is a pizza place in Lancaster, NY. Serving Western New York since 1980, they specialize in iconic Buffalo-style pizza, wings, subs, and calzones. Their menu features a variety of options including bone-in or boneless wings, chicken finger...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Staten Island, New York
- (718) 987-2422
- goodfellas.com
Goodfella's is a Pizza Place in Staten Island, NY, located at 4029 Hylan Blvd. The restaurant serves Italian food and caters to individuals and groups for special occasions, corporate events, and parties. Known for its Vodka Pizza, the business also offers...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Peekskill, New York
- amici-cafe.com
Amici’s Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place in Peekskill, NY. The business has served the area since 1993, offering hand-tossed pizzas, wings, and subs made with fresh ingredients daily. It operates as a dining spot for casual meals, takeout orders, and...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Massapequa, New York
- (800) 955-9055
- giovannispizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Dobbs Ferry, New York
- (425) 898-4106
- sparkpizzaredmond.com
Pizza & Pasta Place is a Pizza Place in Dobbs Ferry, NY. The establishment offers a variety of specialty options, including Detroit-style pizza featuring a thick, airy, caramelized cheese crust, as well as 18-inch New York Style pizzas. Their menu also...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Amherst, New York
- (716) 877-2720
- francospizza.com
Franco's Pizza of Amherst: Franco's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Amherst, NY, located at 1924 Eggert Rd. The family-owned and operated restaurant serves Buffalo and all of Western New York through five locations, including sites on Payne Ave, Kenmore Ave, Niagara Falls Blvd, and Delaware...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Great Neck, New York
- naplespompeii.com
Napoli Pizza & Restaurant of Great Neck: Napoli Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place in Great Neck, NY. The establishment maintains a 4.60 rating from its customers. Napoli Pizza & Restaurant is located on Northern Blvd, near the intersection of Great Neck Road. The business is situated a short...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Wantagh, New York
- (516) 407-3677
- belpostowantagh.com
bel posto wantagh: Bel Posto is a pizza place in Wantagh, NY. This owner-led Italian kitchen serves classic pizzas, pastas, and seafood with a focus on warm, neighborhood hospitality. The restaurant is highly regarded by guests, maintaining a 4.70 rating. The menu features a...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- North New Hyde Park, New York
- umbertosfamily.com
Umberto's Of New Hyde Park is a pizza place in North New Hyde Park, NY. The restaurant provides high-quality Italian food and Neapolitan pizza, offering services that include dine-in, take-out, and full corporate catering. Their menu features specialties such...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Depew, New York
- (716) 668-3355
- santoraspizza.com
Santora's Pizza Drive-In is a pizza place in Depew, NY. Serving Cheektowaga, Elma, Lancaster, Depew, and West Seneca, this establishment specializes in iconic Buffalo-style pizza, wings, subs, and pasta. With a 4.30 rating, they provide a variety of hearty...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- New City, New York
- (212) 582-5882
- mangia.nyc
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant of New City is a pizza place in New City, NY. The establishment provides a variety of dining and catering options, including breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a focus on fresh, farm-to-table ingredients and artisanal Italian fare...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Ossining, New York
- (914) 944-8000
- capriossining.com
Capri Pizza & Pasta of Ossining: Capri Pizza & Pasta is a Pizza Place in Ossining, NY, located at 228 S Highland Ave. This family restaurant serves Italian cuisine including signature pizzas, calzones, rolls, sandwiches, and pasta entrées to the local community and surrounding areas. It...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Gates, New York
- (585) 288-0590
- guidaspizzeria.com
Guida's Pizzeria is a pizza place in Gates, NY. Serving the greater Rochester area, this establishment offers a variety of home-style menu items including brick oven specialties, pasta dinners, and appetizers. The business has been a local fixture for over 30...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Amherst, New York
- blazepizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Clarkstown, New York
- mangia.nyc
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant of Clarkstown is a Pizza Place in Clarkstown, NY, located at 68 N Main St. It offers catering, lunch delivery, breakfast, fresh salads, sandwiches, coffee, juices, and gourmet meals for offices and events. The business holds a rating...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Massapequa, New York
- (516) 741-0379
- taglioromanpizza.com
Taglio Pizza of Massapequa is a pizza place in Massapequa, NY. The establishment specializes in authentic Italian pizza al taglio, which is served by the slice. Their menu features traditional Roman pizzas baked in rectangular blue-steel pans, alongside...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Corning, New York
- (423) 288-5265
- giuseppesitaliantogo.com
#18Miseno Pizza
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Deer Park, New York
- (631) 940-7500
- misenopizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Brentwood, New York
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Oneonta, New York
- (607) 386-4350
- mollyspizzamenu.com
Molly’s Pizza is a pizza place in Oneonta, NY. The restaurant serves the local community with a variety of options including pizza by the slice, specialty pies, and classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese pizzas. Their menu features diverse offerings such...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Penfield, New York
- camspizzeria.com
Cam's Pizzeria of Penfield: Cam's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in Penfield, NY, located at 2110 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd. It holds a rating of 4.20 based on customer reviews. The business operates as a counter-service pizzeria chain in Upstate, New York, providing New York Style pizza...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Plattsburgh, New York
- (518) 562-8586
- bazzanospizza.net
Bazzano's Pizza is a pizza place in Plattsburgh, NY. The establishment specializes in authentic Italian food, including gourmet pizzas, pasta dishes, and sub sandwiches. They offer a variety of services such as delivery, carry-out, and catering for groups...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 525-1515
- bigmackpizzany.com
Big Mack Pizza is a Pizza Place in North Tonawanda, NY, located at 452 Oliver St. The business offers online ordering for delivery or pickup and operates Thursday and Friday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. The menu features a wide variety of specialty pizzas...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Babylon, New York
- (631) 539-9797
- bellapazzapizzeria.com
Bella Pazza Pizzeria is a pizza place in Babylon, NY, specializing in handmade, wood-fired pizzas crafted with a commitment to high-quality ingredients. The restaurant serves locals and visitors throughout Babylon and surrounding areas, offering a menu...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 837-6767
- olisisny.com
Olisi's New York Style is a pizza place in Tonawanda, NY, specializing in authentic New York Style pizza made from original homemade recipes. Serving the local community and surrounding areas including Amherst, the business offers a range of hand-tossed...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Orangeburg, New York
- (718) 227-8108
- nonnaspizzaonline.com
#27Aurora
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Rye, New York
- zhospitalitygroup.com
Aurora is a Pizza Place in Rye, NY, located at 60 Purchase St. It holds a 4.30 rating based on customer reviews. Aurora is part of Z Hospitality, a restaurant group that has operated in Fairfield County and Westchester for three decades. The group manages...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Brooklyn, New York
- grimaldispizzeria.com
Grimaldi's Pizzeria of Brooklyn: Grimaldi's Pizzeria is a pizza place in Brooklyn, NY. The restaurant serves traditional coal-fired brick oven pizza and calzones using pizza-making traditions originating in Brooklyn over 100 years ago. With a 4.20 rating, this family-friendly, casual yet...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Oswego, New York
- (315) 487-2261
- camspizza.com
Cam's Pizzeria of Oswego: Cam's Pizzeria is a pizza place in Oswego, NY, serving fresh, made-to-order pies to locals and visitors alike. Located at 31 W Bridge St, the restaurant offers a range of classic and specialty pizzas, including pepperoni, cheese, and seasonal options, with...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Levittown, New York
- (516) 520-1200
- caldapizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Auburn, New York
- (315) 253-2209
- mrpizzaaubny.com
Mr. Pizza of Auburn: Mr. Pizza is a pizza place in Auburn, NY. The establishment serves the local community with an extensive menu featuring a variety of pizzas, ranging from classic pepperoni to gourmet veggie options, as well as subs, wings, salads, appetizers, and desserts...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Bay Shore, New York
- (631) 968-8181
- amorepizzabayshore.com
Amore Pizza of Bay Shore: Amore Pizza is a pizza place in Bay Shore, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services including pizza, catering, delivery, and pickup, serving the local community with flavorful Italian cuisine. With over 28 years of experience, they have earned a...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Watertown, New York
- (315) 782-9500
- bernardospizzeria.com
Bernardo's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in Watertown, NY. It serves the neighborhood with a menu of classic and gourmet pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, and Italian-American entrees. The kitchen prepares items such as cheese pizza, white pizza, pesto pizza, and...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Queens, New York
- (978) 975-3999
- manospizzeria.com
Mano's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in Queens, NY. The establishment provides a variety of food options including pizza, calzones, hot subs, steaks, burgers, wings, and pastas. Serving Methuen, Andover, and Lawrence since 1988, the restaurant offers both...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Johnson City, New York
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Spring Valley, New York
- papajohns.com
Papa Johns Pizza of Spring Valley: Papa Johns Pizza is a pizza place in Spring Valley, NY. The establishment provides pizza delivery and carryout services, specializing in menu items such as pizza, breadsticks, and wings. Customers can utilize the Papa Rewards program to earn rewards toward...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Selden, New York
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Troy, New York
- (518) 203-6029
- defaziospizza.com
DeFazio's at 216 is a pizza place in Troy, New York, specializing in wood-fired pizzas and homemade pasta. The business serves the local community and visitors with a menu featuring traditional and specialty pizzas, fresh salads, calzones, and desserts, all...
#39Pizzeria G
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Garden City, New York
- (516) 231-2311
- pizzeriag.com
Pizzeria G is a pizza place in Garden City, NY. The establishment provides local pizza options and offers catering menus for various needs. The restaurant maintains a 4.50 rating from its customers. The pizzeria is operated by the owner of V.I. Pizza in...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Lindenhurst, New York
- (215) 536-5076
- dominicks-pizza.com
Dominick's Pizza & Pasta is a Pizza Place in Lindenhurst, NY. The restaurant provides a variety of Italian dishes, including gourmet pizzas, pasta, subs, and entrees, serving the local community. The restaurant has been owned and operated by the Randazzo...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Uniondale, New York
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Plattsburgh, New York
- pizzapalaceny.com
Pizza Palace of Plattsburgh: Pizza Palace is a pizza place in Plattsburgh, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of pizza shop favorites, including specialty pizzas, calzones, wings, salads, and appetizers. Among the popular options are the Cheese Pizza, Palace Special Pizza, and Calzone...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Albany, New York
- (518) 437-0001
- madisonspizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Corning, New York
- atlaspizzeria.com
Atlas Brick Oven Pizzeria is a pizza place in Corning, NY, specializing in brick oven pizzas made with fresh ingredients and served in a casual, welcoming setting. The restaurant offers a full menu of handcrafted pizzas, sandwiches, and salads, with options...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Westbury, New York
- pizzahut.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Brentwood, New York
- pizzahut.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Hempstead, New York
- pizzerialarosa.com
- Pizza Place
- Levittown, New York
- rikospizza.com
- Pizza Place
- Massena, New York
- pizzahut.com
- Pizza Place
- Ogdensburg, New York
- pizzahut.com
Recently Updated Pizza Place in New York
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Peekskill, New York
- amici-cafe.com
Amici’s Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place in Peekskill, NY. The business has served the area since 1993, offering hand-tossed pizzas, wings, and subs made with fresh ingredients daily. It operates as a dining spot for casual meals, takeout orders, and...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Amherst, New York
- (716) 877-2720
- francospizza.com
Franco's Pizza of Amherst: Franco's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Amherst, NY, located at 1924 Eggert Rd. The family-owned and operated restaurant serves Buffalo and all of Western New York through five locations, including sites on Payne Ave, Kenmore Ave, Niagara Falls Blvd, and Delaware...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Ossining, New York
- (914) 944-8000
- capriossining.com
Capri Pizza & Pasta of Ossining: Capri Pizza & Pasta is a Pizza Place in Ossining, NY, located at 228 S Highland Ave. This family restaurant serves Italian cuisine including signature pizzas, calzones, rolls, sandwiches, and pasta entrées to the local community and surrounding areas. It...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Clarkstown, New York
- mangia.nyc
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant of Clarkstown is a Pizza Place in Clarkstown, NY, located at 68 N Main St. It offers catering, lunch delivery, breakfast, fresh salads, sandwiches, coffee, juices, and gourmet meals for offices and events. The business holds a rating...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Penfield, New York
- camspizzeria.com
Cam's Pizzeria of Penfield: Cam's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in Penfield, NY, located at 2110 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd. It holds a rating of 4.20 based on customer reviews. The business operates as a counter-service pizzeria chain in Upstate, New York, providing New York Style pizza...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Tonawanda, New York
- (716) 525-1515
- bigmackpizzany.com
Big Mack Pizza is a Pizza Place in North Tonawanda, NY, located at 452 Oliver St. The business offers online ordering for delivery or pickup and operates Thursday and Friday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. The menu features a wide variety of specialty pizzas...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Rye, New York
- zhospitalitygroup.com
Aurora is a Pizza Place in Rye, NY, located at 60 Purchase St. It holds a 4.30 rating based on customer reviews. Aurora is part of Z Hospitality, a restaurant group that has operated in Fairfield County and Westchester for three decades. The group manages...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Oswego, New York
- (315) 487-2261
- camspizza.com
Cam's Pizzeria of Oswego: Cam's Pizzeria is a pizza place in Oswego, NY, serving fresh, made-to-order pies to locals and visitors alike. Located at 31 W Bridge St, the restaurant offers a range of classic and specialty pizzas, including pepperoni, cheese, and seasonal options, with...
What the Data Shows for Pizza Places in New York
11% of the 47 pizza places we measured in New York reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 35, compared with an average SEO score of 71.
The average Google rating across 54 rated pizza places is 4.3.
None of the 54 pizza places has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Jul 21, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best pizza place in New York? BizScoreAI scores 54 Pizza Place listings across New York on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New York Pizza Place listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my pizza place listing in New York?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every pizza place listing in New York is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
