Run a free full auditGoodfella's is a Pizza Place in Staten Island, NY, located at 4029 Hylan Blvd. The restaurant serves Italian food and caters to individuals and groups for special occasions, corporate events, and parties. Known for its Vodka Pizza, the business also offers fresh-baked garlic knots, pork shank ossobuco, and classic Italian dishes such as chicken parmigiana, eggplant rollatini, and fresh Caesar salad. It holds a 4.60 rating from its customers.
The original Goodfella's was established in 1992 at 1718 Hylan Blvd. The founder developed the Vodka Pizza in the first year of business, a creation that won the honor of being voted America's Best Pizza at the New York City International Hotel and Restaurant show. The restaurant has since won the World's Best Pizza title several times at the International Pizza Expo and has been featured on various TV stations, newspapers, and magazines. The kitchen uses fresh mozzarella, imported San Marzano tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, and gourmet sauces cooked from scratch, preparing artisan pizzas in a real wood-fired brick oven.
Goodfella's provides catering packages for birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and weddings. It offers a private event space for celebrations and meetings, as well as dine-in reservations for solo diners or romantic dates. Lunch specials served Monday through Friday from 12:00 PM to 3:00 PM include a Caesar salad or house salad and a fountain soda. The menu features appetizers like jumbo shrimp cocktail, fried calamari, buffalo wings, bruschetta, and smoked burrata. Salads include house salad, baby arugula, and strawberry mesclun. Soups include lobster bisque and minestrone.
The beverage list includes draft beers such as Heineken, Peroni, Blue Moon, Sam Adams, Yuengling, and Stella Artois. Bottled beers include Corona, Modelo, and Miller Light. Wine selections feature Cabernet Sauvignon, Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Noir, and Merlot from various regions including California, Italy, and New Zealand.
Goodfella's brings its award-winning brick oven pizza and Italian dining experience to Staten Island, offering a historic tradition of quality food and service to the local community.
The restaurant sits on Hylan Boulevard, just a short walk from Postal Plaza and the FDNY Battalion 23/Engine 162/Ladder 82 fire station.
BizScoreAI awarded the business a Content Quality score of 100 out of 100, meaning the website clearly answers customer questions and provides content that AI assistants can quote directly. The business also received a Technical score of 92 out of 100.
BizScoreAI scanned the website goodfellas.com on July 18, 2026. Goodfella's has a BizScore of 68 out of 100.
AI visibility scan by category: AI Discovery 10 of 25 points, Structured Data 0 of 25 points, Content Readiness 24 of 30 points, AI Trust Signals 17 of 20 points.
Website audit sub-scores (out of 100): On-Page 84, Technical 92, Performance 67, Content 89.
Strengths: 10 checks passed. AI Crawler Access, AI Content Blocking, Google Business Profile Link, LocalBusiness Schema, Local Multimedia, Q&A Content, AI-Parseable Headings, Meta Description, About/Team Page, XML Sitemap.
Areas to improve: 7 checks. llms.txt (failed), FAQPage Schema (failed), Third-Party Review Links (failed), Organization Schema (warning), Speakable Schema (warning), Hyperlocal Targeting (warning), Author Signals (warning).
Browse: Businesses in Staten Island, NY · Pizza Place in New York · Businesses in New York
Read by AI engines 7 times in the last 30 days.
Counted from AI crawler and assistant visits to this page, identified by user agent.
See the full AI visibility report for this business