Best Insurance Agent in New Jersey
Top Insurance Agent Listings in New Jersey
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 268 Insurance Agent listings in New Jersey · page 1 of 6
#1Freeway Insurance of Jersey City Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Jersey City, New Jersey
- (201) 829-2005
- freeway.com
#2Freeway Insurance of Paterson Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (973) 662-7002
- freeway.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hackensack, New Jersey
- (201) 355-3252
- grahamfamilyagency.com
#4Freeway Insurance of Trenton Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Trenton, New Jersey
- (609) 224-1209
- freeway.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Phillipsburg, New Jersey
- (908) 454-8582
- coeinsonline.com
COE Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Phillipsburg, NJ. The agency provides homeowners insurance, flood insurance, personal and commercial auto insurance, small business insurance, worker’s compensation, and commercial property coverage. It also offers error...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Jersey City, New Jersey
- (201) 918-3793
- statefarm.com
Kacey Padlo - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Jersey City, NJ, located at 419 Monmouth St. It holds a rating of 5.00 based on reviews. Kacey Padlo helps customers create a Personal Price Plan to protect family, belongings, and financial...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Metuchen, New Jersey
- (732) 543-0444
- alloneinsurance.com
All One Insurance Agency LLC of Metuchen: All One Insurance Agency LLC is an Insurance Agent in Metuchen, NJ. The agency provides auto, home, commercial auto, business, and life insurance quotes for individuals, families, and business owners across New Jersey, North Carolina, Pennsylvania and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (888) 902-3026
- thesosainsurancegroup.com
The Sosa Insurance Group of West Orange: The Sosa Insurance Group is an Insurance Agent in West Orange, NJ, located at 450 Pleasant Valley Way. The agency specializes in helping New Jersey seniors navigate Medicare, offering free, no-obligation consultations to compare plans from all major carriers...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Plainfield, New Jersey
- (908) 941-9076
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- North Plainfield, New Jersey
- (908) 757-3415
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Burlington, New Jersey
- (609) 835-2422
- westjerseyinsurance.com
West Jersey Insurance Agency, Inc. is an insurance agent in Burlington, NJ. The agency provides personalized coverage for individuals, families, and businesses throughout Burlington, Camden, and Mercer counties. Their specific service offerings include auto...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Newark, New Jersey
- (973) 732-3794
- metroplus.org

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Brick, New Jersey
- (848) 232-3490
- osborninsuranceagency.com
Osborn Insurance Agency of Brick: Osborn Insurance Agency is a Insurance Agent in Brick, NJ. The firm offers auto, home, business and health insurance to individuals, families and businesses throughout New Jersey. Specializing in personalized coverage, the agency provides policies such as...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Newark, New Jersey
- (973) 372-0002
- dependableinsurance.net
Dependable Insurance Agency Inc of Newark: Dependable Insurance Agency Inc is an Insurance Agent in Newark, NJ. They provide a range of insurance services and cater to individuals and businesses seeking reliable coverage solutions. Their specialties include comprehensive insurance planning tailored to...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- West Long Branch, New Jersey
- (732) 963-4041
- statefarm.com
#16Joe Medicare

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Somerset, New Jersey
- (732) 658-2525
- joemedicare.com
Joe Medicare is an Insurance Agent in Somerset, NJ, located at 575 Easton Ave Suite 14d. The agency offers health insurance solutions including Medicare Advantage, Medicare supplement, Part D, dental plans, and senior health insurance. Services are available...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (973) 782-4343
- statefarm.com
Frantz Gaston Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Paterson, New Jersey. The agency provides a wide range of services including auto, motorcycle, homeowners, condo, renters, and life insurance, as well as Medicare supplement, supplemental...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Newark, New Jersey
- (973) 274-1000
- statefarm.com
Conrado Arroyo - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Newark, NJ, located at 360 Chestnut St. The agency serves local residents and business owners with a wide array of coverage options, including auto, motorcycle, homeowners, condo owners...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (973) 341-6810
- exclusivemi.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Atlantic City, New Jersey
- (609) 345-2203
- bloomrealtyinsurance.com
Bloom Realty & Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Atlantic City, NJ, located at 3542 Atlantic Ave. The agency operates as an independent insurance broker, representing an average of eight insurance companies to research and find the best combination of price...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Dover, New Jersey
- (973) 343-7033
- statefarm.com
Craig Stix - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Dover, NJ, located at 10 S Morris St. The agency provides auto, home, renters, motorcycle, recreational vehicle, life, and business insurance to residents and business owners in the area. The...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Clifton, New Jersey
- (973) 604-0170
- cupo.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cherry Hill, New Jersey
- (856) 424-1963
- statefarm.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 325-7555
- statefarm.com
Chris Sules - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in West Orange, NJ. The agency provides auto, motorcycle, home, renters, and business insurance solutions. Services include Personal Price Plan customization, collision and comprehensive coverage...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Union, New Jersey
- (908) 810-0040
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hillsborough, New Jersey
- (908) 359-1002
- statefarm.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Princeton, New Jersey
- (609) 921-7059
- statefarm.com
CJ Duran - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Princeton, NJ. The agency provides a variety of services including auto, home, life, and business insurance, as well as motorcycle, renters, condo, and pet insurance. Serving the Princeton area...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Piscataway, New Jersey
- (732) 465-0400
- statefarm.com
Chris Ciraulo - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Piscataway, NJ, located at 1056 Stelton Rd. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on 26 reviews. The agency has over 20 years of experience providing life, home, car, and business insurance...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cliffside Park, New Jersey
- (201) 514-0004
- westernsouthern.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Maplewood, New Jersey
- (973) 761-4041
- statefarm.com
Christine Coster - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Maplewood, NJ. Serving Essex County and surrounding areas including Millburn, Short Hills, West Orange, Springfield, and South Orange, the agency provides a variety of coverage options...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Sayreville, New Jersey
- (732) 238-9800
- statefarm.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 736-0494
- statefarm.com
Chris Alevras - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in West Orange, NJ, located at 595 Eagle Rock Ave. The agency offers a range of coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. Clients can create Personal Price Plans to...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Brick, New Jersey
- (732) 262-5000
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Newark, New Jersey
- (862) 346-6555
- libertymutual.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (862) 394-0184
- progressive.com
SR22 Drivers Insurance Solutions of Paterson: SR22 Drivers Insurance Solutions is an Insurance Agent in Paterson, NJ. They specialize in assisting drivers with the SR-22 form process, which proves that their car insurance meets minimum legal requirements as mandated by law. The company serves individuals...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Marlton, New Jersey
- (856) 988-8400
- statefarm.com
Chris Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Marlton, NJ. The agency provides a variety of services including auto, home, life, and renters insurance, as well as condo, motorcycle, and pet insurance. Serving clients in Marlton, Medford...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hamilton, New Jersey
- (609) 586-7474
- rueinsurance.com
Rue Insurance is an insurance agent in Hamilton, NJ. The agency provides a full range of insurance solutions, including business insurance, employee benefits, and personal insurance for clients across New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and New York. Their professional...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Westfield, New Jersey
- (908) 233-9100
- statefarm.com
Christine Cosenza - State Farm Insurance Agent is a Insurance Agent in Westfield, NJ. She provides auto, home, life, motorcycle, condo owners, renters, Medicare supplement, small‑business and pet insurance to individuals and families throughout Westfield and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Asbury Park, New Jersey
- (732) 708-6506
- jerseysenioradvisors.com
Jersey Senior Advisors is an Insurance Agent in Asbury Park, NJ, located at 1314 Spruce Ave. The firm operates as a licensed health and life insurance brokerage, offering independent guidance on Medicare, ACA plans, and life insurance. Services include New to...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- East Windsor, New Jersey
- (609) 448-0110
- allenstults.com
Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is an insurance agent in East Windsor, NJ. As a Trusted Choice independent agency, they provide a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions to families, businesses, and non-profit organizations. Their specialties include personal...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 250-4002
- browneinsuranceagency.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 678-7446
- whadleyinsurance.online
Hadley Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Orange, NJ. The agency specializes in auto insurance coverage, offering plans designed to fit various budgets with easy monthly payments. It serves drivers seeking personalized plans and low coverage options that...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hamilton, New Jersey
- (609) 587-1600
- nottinghaminsurance.com
Nottingham Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Hamilton, NJ, located at 1878 NJ-33. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on 2277 reviews. The family-owned agency serves the tri-state area with personal insurance, business insurance, and employee benefits solutions...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (551) 362-2647
- fgjagency.com
Auto One Insurance Agency: Frantz Gaston Jr State Farm Agency in Paterson, NJ offers a wide range of insurance solutions including auto, home, renters, condo, life, and business insurance. Our team is dedicated to providing clear communication and support to ensure our clients are...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Gloucester Township, New Jersey
- (856) 478-0022
- mullicahillinsurance.com
Mullica Hill Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Gloucester Township, NJ, located at 48 A N Main St. The firm specializes in helping residents of South Jersey find the right coverage at the right price, drawing on more than 35 years of experience. As an...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Pennsauken, New Jersey
- (856) 379-3074
- crespoinsuranceagency.com
Crespo Insurance Agency of Pennsauken: Crespo Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Pennsauken, NJ. The agency provides personal, life, and commercial insurance services to clients throughout New Jersey, and is also licensed to work in New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Florida. With a 4.80...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Rahway, New Jersey
- (908) 587-1600
- garysinsuranceagency.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Ridgewood, New Jersey
- (201) 652-7300
- johndominianni.com
John Dominianni - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Ridgewood, NJ. The agency provides auto, life, home, and business insurance to individuals, families, and businesses throughout New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania. The office has served...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hackettstown, New Jersey
- (908) 747-1529
- medicarewithadam.com
Medicare With Adam is an Insurance Agent in Hackettstown, NJ. The agency specializes in Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D Prescription Plans, as well as life, critical illness, long-term care, dental, vision, and ACA Get Covered NJ coverage...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Sayreville, New Jersey
- (732) 238-9800
- johnpepejr.com
John Pepe Jr. State Farm Insurance Agent of Sayreville is an Insurance Agent in Sayreville, NJ, located at 3D Parlin Dr. The agency provides a variety of insurance and financial services, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles...
Recently Updated Insurance Agent in New Jersey
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Englewood, New Jersey
- (201) 227-1800
- otterstedt.com
Otterstedt Insurance Agency of Englewood: Otterstedt Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Englewood, NJ, located at 540 Sylvan Ave. The agency provides insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses, including specialized coverage for social service organizations, both for-profit...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Metuchen, New Jersey
- (732) 548-2727
- schenckagency.com
Schenck Agency, Inc. is an Insurance Agent in Metuchen, NJ, located at 495 Main St. The agency provides personal and business insurance coverage, including life insurance, homeowners coverage, and auto insurance features such as accident forgiveness. As an...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hackettstown, New Jersey
- (908) 852-5555
- otterstedt.com
Otterstedt Insurance Agency of Hackettstown: Otterstedt Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Hackettstown, NJ, located at 313 High St #1. The agency serves families, individuals, and businesses with a focus on protection and future planning. Specific services include business insurance, human...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Freehold, New Jersey
- (732) 780-8338
- leighagency.com
Leigh Agency is an Insurance Agent in Freehold, NJ, located at 20 Court St #202. The firm provides auto, home, and business insurance coverage for families, individuals, and business owners across Monmouth, Ocean, and Middlesex counties. As an independent...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Trenton, New Jersey
- (800) 232-6600
- njm.com
NJM Insurance Group of Trenton: NJM Insurance Group is an Insurance Agent in Trenton, NJ, located at 301 Sullivan Way. The company provides auto, homeowners, renters, and business insurance through a select network of independent agents. It serves customers in Connecticut, Maryland, New...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Trenton, New Jersey
- (609) 989-0020
- statefarm.com
Teanice Wells-Ernest offers a wide range of insurance solutions to protect individuals and businesses. With State Farm, she ensures that her clients are covered with reliable and comprehensive policies.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Plainfield, New Jersey
- (908) 941-5248
- amoghassociates.net
Amogh Associates Llc is an Insurance Agent in South Plainfield, NJ, located at 904 Oak Tree Ave Suite B. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. The firm operates with the principle that it works for clients and not for the insurance companies...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Belleville, New Jersey
- (973) 759-8291
- metroplusinsurance.com
Metroplus Insurance Agency-Belleville is an Insurance Agent in Belleville, NJ, located at 338 Washington Ave. Operating as an independent agency, the business is not limited to a single insurance company and instead searches through an expansive network of...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agents in New Jersey
11% of the 171 insurance agents we measured in New Jersey reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 33, compared with an average SEO score of 70.
The average Google rating across 258 rated insurance agents is 4.6, and the median listing has 18 reviews.
None of the 268 insurance agents has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 30, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agent in New Jersey? BizScoreAI scores 268 Insurance Agent listings across New Jersey on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New Jersey Insurance Agent listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agent listing in New Jersey?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agent listing in New Jersey is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.