Best Thrift Store in New Jersey
Top Thrift Store Listings in New Jersey
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 57 Thrift Store listings in New Jersey · page 1 of 2
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Paramus, New Jersey
- (201) 226-0054
- suburbanrevival.com
Suburban Revival is a thrift store in Paramus, NJ, located at 110 W Pleasant Ave. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. Suburban Revival operates as a modern vintage boutique in Maywood, NJ, curating a mix of vintage, modern, and new items for...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Point Pleasant, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0200
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Haddonfield, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0200
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Laurel, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0200
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Ewing, New Jersey
- (609) 392-2865
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hamilton, New Jersey
- (609) 281-5431
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Bergenfield, New Jersey
- (201) 385-5154
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Eatontown, New Jersey
- (732) 643-1064
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Holly, New Jersey
- (609) 518-3490
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cinnaminson, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0302
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Harrison, New Jersey
- (973) 481-4355
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Plainsboro, New Jersey
- (609) 429-4595
- notablethrift.com
Notable Thrift is a Thrift Store in Plainsboro, NJ. The shop offers a curated selection of pre‑loved clothing, shoes, books, home goods and unique treasures, welcoming shoppers who value sustainable, affordable fashion and décor. As a woman‑ and veteran‑owned...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cherry Hill, New Jersey
- (856) 662-1650
- goodwillaz.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- West Deptford, New Jersey
- (856) 489-9834
- goodwillaz.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Eatontown, New Jersey
- (732) 542-7163
- cottontailsconsignment.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Freehold, New Jersey
- (732) 462-7525
- freeholdthriftshop.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Laurel, New Jersey
- (856) 234-9335
- secondtimebooksonline.com
Second Time Books is a thrift store in Mount Laurel, New Jersey. The business operates as a brick-and-mortar bookstore, maintaining a high rating of 4.80. They specialize in history, science fiction, fantasy, and classic literature, while also offering...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Morristown, New Jersey
- (908) 766-0745
- wammc.org
Bargain Box Thrift Shop of Morristown: Bargain Box Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Morristown, New Jersey, offering gently-used, fashionable clothing and accessories for men, women, and children, along with household items, jewelry, vintage goods, home décor, toys, and seasonal merchandise. The...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Bound Brook, New Jersey
- (732) 469-2815
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hillsborough, New Jersey
- (908) 271-4095
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Collingswood, New Jersey
- (856) 833-1112
- cluttervintage.com
Clutter Vintage is a thrift store in Collingswood, NJ. The shop serves the local community by providing unusual and affordable vintage and handmade treasures, including unique and re-imagined artifacts, home décor, and furniture. This highly-rated...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Teaneck, New Jersey
- (201) 928-1868
- kay.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Vineland, New Jersey
- (856) 563-0292
- habitat.org
Habitat For Humanity Restore of Vineland: Habitat For Humanity Restore is a thrift store in Vineland, NJ, located at 601 S Delsea Dr. It holds a rating of 4.40 based on 17 reviews. The Cumberland County Habitat for Humanity ReStore sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Trenton, New Jersey
- (609) 394-4939
- estatesales.net
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Princeton, New Jersey
- (609) 924-5720
- abc7.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Franklin, New Jersey
- (201) 891-0022
- franklinlakesumc.org
Blessed Bargains Thrift Store of Franklin: Blessed Bargains Thrift Store is a thrift store in Franklin, NJ. Operated by the Franklin Lakes United Methodist Church, the shop offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, books, and unique treasures. The store provides an opportunity...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- West Deptford, New Jersey
- (856) 430-5391
- 2ndchanceboutique.org
2nd Chance Boutique is a thrift store in West Deptford, New Jersey, operating as a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting adults with varying abilities. The store provides job training, resources for independent living, and opportunities for...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- East Brunswick, New Jersey
- (732) 390-6602
- my-ebea.org
EBEA Bear Necessities Clothing Den is a thrift store in East Brunswick, NJ, located at 575 Cranbury Rd STE B2. It is operated by the East Brunswick Education Association, a local affiliate of the New Jersey Education Association and the National Education...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Marlton, New Jersey
- (856) 574-4111
- thepromenadenj.com
The Promenade at Sagemore is a thrift store in Marlton, New Jersey. This destination features a collection of unique upscale shops and dining options, earning a 4.50 rating. The center provides an open-air shopping environment characterized by beautiful...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Maple Shade, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0302
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cliffside Park, New Jersey
- (551) 323-4974
- mylocalthriftstore.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hoboken, New Jersey
- (201) 795-2174
- stmaryadvocates.org
Hoboken Thrift Store / St. Mary Advocates is a thrift store in Hoboken, NJ, located at 536 Garden St. The organization operates as a 100% volunteer-run nonprofit that accepts household and clothing donations in good condition to raise funds for health care...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Glassboro, New Jersey
- (856) 307-9175
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Marlboro, New Jersey
- (732) 243-6868
- bridgelifethrift.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Passaic, New Jersey
- passaicthrift.com
Passaic Thrift Store is a thrift store in Passaic, NJ. The shop provides high quality, brand-name clothing, shoes, and accessories at affordable prices. Serving the local community, the store maintains a 4.00 rating and focuses on delivering value through a...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Cinnaminson, New Jersey
- (856) 439-0200
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Ocean, New Jersey
- (732) 643-1064
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 762-1700
- westvillageclothing.com
West Village Clothing is a Thrift Store in West Orange, NJ. It operates as a consignment boutique specializing in casual and fun apparel and accessories for women, including some juniors. The business serves customers seeking second-hand clothing and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- North Bergen, New Jersey
- (551) 323-4974
- thriftstoredonationcenter.com
Thrift Store Donation Center of North Bergen: Thrift Store Donation Center is a thrift store in North Bergen, New Jersey. The business serves the local community by providing affordable clothing, shoes, small household items, and bric-a-brac. In addition to shopping, the center facilitates community...
#40Help Others
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Metuchen, New Jersey
- (848) 260-8898
- helpothersmission.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Laurel, New Jersey
- (609) 605-0658
- dashconsignment.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Laurel, New Jersey
- (856) 235-1830
- creekmercantile.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Nutley, New Jersey
- (973) 667-1884
- social.nutleyfamily.org
- Thrift Store
- Wallington, New Jersey
- (973) 246-8040
- prestigiousthrift.com
- Thrift Store
- Clifton, New Jersey
- (973) 454-4083
- rannedaythrift.com
- Thrift Store
- Mount Laurel, New Jersey
- (856) 778-0010
- rancocaswoodseventsnshops.com
- Thrift Store
- Belleville, New Jersey
- (973) 337-1948
- hanamission.org
- Thrift Store
- Phillipsburg, New Jersey
- (908) 878-6887
- possabilitiesthrift.com
- Thrift Store
- Hackensack, New Jersey
- (201) 673-0160
- thrifted.com
- Thrift Store
- Fair Lawn, New Jersey
- (201) 794-4670
- goodwillnynj.org
Recently Updated Thrift Store in New Jersey
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Paramus, New Jersey
- (201) 226-0054
- suburbanrevival.com
Suburban Revival is a thrift store in Paramus, NJ, located at 110 W Pleasant Ave. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. Suburban Revival operates as a modern vintage boutique in Maywood, NJ, curating a mix of vintage, modern, and new items for...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Plainsboro, New Jersey
- (609) 429-4595
- notablethrift.com
Notable Thrift is a Thrift Store in Plainsboro, NJ. The shop offers a curated selection of pre‑loved clothing, shoes, books, home goods and unique treasures, welcoming shoppers who value sustainable, affordable fashion and décor. As a woman‑ and veteran‑owned...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Vineland, New Jersey
- (856) 563-0292
- habitat.org
Habitat For Humanity Restore of Vineland: Habitat For Humanity Restore is a thrift store in Vineland, NJ, located at 601 S Delsea Dr. It holds a rating of 4.40 based on 17 reviews. The Cumberland County Habitat for Humanity ReStore sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- East Brunswick, New Jersey
- (732) 390-6602
- my-ebea.org
EBEA Bear Necessities Clothing Den is a thrift store in East Brunswick, NJ, located at 575 Cranbury Rd STE B2. It is operated by the East Brunswick Education Association, a local affiliate of the New Jersey Education Association and the National Education...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hoboken, New Jersey
- (201) 795-2174
- stmaryadvocates.org
Hoboken Thrift Store / St. Mary Advocates is a thrift store in Hoboken, NJ, located at 536 Garden St. The organization operates as a 100% volunteer-run nonprofit that accepts household and clothing donations in good condition to raise funds for health care...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Passaic, New Jersey
- passaicthrift.com
Passaic Thrift Store is a thrift store in Passaic, NJ. The shop provides high quality, brand-name clothing, shoes, and accessories at affordable prices. Serving the local community, the store maintains a 4.00 rating and focuses on delivering value through a...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- West Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 762-1700
- westvillageclothing.com
West Village Clothing is a Thrift Store in West Orange, NJ. It operates as a consignment boutique specializing in casual and fun apparel and accessories for women, including some juniors. The business serves customers seeking second-hand clothing and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- North Bergen, New Jersey
- (551) 323-4974
- thriftstoredonationcenter.com
Thrift Store Donation Center of North Bergen: Thrift Store Donation Center is a thrift store in North Bergen, New Jersey. The business serves the local community by providing affordable clothing, shoes, small household items, and bric-a-brac. In addition to shopping, the center facilitates community...
What the Data Shows for Thrift Stores in New Jersey
40% of the 43 thrift stores we measured in New Jersey reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 43, compared with an average SEO score of 75.
The average Google rating across 56 rated thrift stores is 4.2, and the median listing has 50 reviews.
None of the 57 thrift stores has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best thrift store in New Jersey? BizScoreAI scores 57 Thrift Store listings across New Jersey on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New Jersey Thrift Store listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my thrift store listing in New Jersey?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every thrift store listing in New Jersey is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
