Jersey Senior Advisors

Jersey Senior Advisors is a licensed health and life insurance brokerage in Asbury Park, New Jersey, serving individuals and families across the state with expert guidance on Medicare, ACA plans, life insurance, Part D drug plans, Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage, long-term care insurance, and supplemental coverage for dental, vision, hearing, and travel. As a family-run business with deep community roots, they provide personalized, independent advice at no cost to clients, helping them navigate complex insurance options with clarity and confidence. With a perfect 5.00 rating and a strong reputation built on trust and service, they are recognized as a dependable resource for residents in Asbury Park and surrounding areas.

The firm is led by Laura Hartley Fagan, the principal broker and CEO, who brings over two decades of experience in insurance and real estate, returning to her New Jersey heritage after a successful career in Vermont. Her daughter, Colleen Fagan, serves as broker and managing director, continuing a multi-generational commitment to client-focused service. The team emphasizes honest, client-first advice, treating each individual’s needs as if they were their own, with a focus on long-term financial security and peace of mind through tailored insurance solutions.

Located at 1314 Spruce Avenue, Jersey Senior Advisors sits just a short walk from Asbury Avenue and Kings Highway, near Wanamassa Elementary School and the Wanamassa Fire Company, approximately half a mile from Asbury Park Circle. The business is situated on a residential street within a quiet neighborhood, close to local schools and emergency services.

Known for its personalized approach, free consultations, and deep expertise in Medicare and ACA plans, Jersey Senior Advisors stands out as a trusted advisor in the Asbury Park community, helping residents make informed decisions about their health and life insurance needs with integrity and care. Their dedication to family values and long-term client relationships makes them a vital resource for seniors and families navigating insurance complexity in Monmouth County.