Best Ice Cream Shop in New Jersey
Top Ice Cream Shop Listings in New Jersey
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 56 Ice Cream Shop listings in New Jersey · page 1 of 2
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Burlington, New Jersey
- (609) 459-5242
- lexylicious.com
Lexylicious Ice Cream Cafe | New Jersey is an ice cream shop in Burlington, NJ, located at 190 Atlantic Ave. It holds a 4.70 rating based on customer reviews. The business is a woman-owned company founded by Bridget Bergin, who has been serving customers in...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Gloucester City, New Jersey
- (305) 306-3204
- azenco-outdoor.com
Cabana Water Ice Co is an Ice Cream Shop in Gloucester City, NJ. Azenco Outdoor provides premium aluminum outdoor living solutions, including motorized louvered pergolas, retractable fabric pergolas, and insulated patio covers. Their product collection...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Lodi, New Jersey
- (201) 393-4891
- ralphsices.com
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & ice cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Lodi, NJ, located at 239 Boulevard. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. Founded in 1928 by Ralph Silvestro, who began making lemon and orange ices by hand in his Staten Island...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Millville, New Jersey
- (856) 825-8263
- blinkerscustard.com
Blinker’s Custard is an ice cream shop in Millville, NJ. A well-known establishment in the area for many years, this shop serves the local community daily with a variety of treats. The business maintains a 4.50 rating based on 210 reviews. The shop provides a...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Irvington, New Jersey
- honeyandhiveicecream.com
Honey & Hive Artisanal Ice Cream of Irvington: Honey & Hive Artisanal Ice Cream is an ice cream shop in Maplewood, NJ, located at 1611 Springfield Avenue. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. The shop specializes in handcrafted, nut-free ice cream made with local fresh milk and cream. They...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Summit, New Jersey
- (908) 273-2565
- magic-fountain.placejoys.com
Magic Fountain is an ice cream shop in Summit, New Jersey. Serving locals and visitors alike, this walk-up establishment specializes in a variety of frozen treats, including ice cream, frozen yogurt, and freshly made waffle cones. The shop maintains a 4.6...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Summit, New Jersey
- zrolls.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Harrison, New Jersey
- zrolls.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ridgefield Park, New Jersey
- locations.baskinrobbins.com
Baskin-Robbins of Ridgefield Park: Baskin-Robbins is an ice cream shop in Ridgefield Park, NJ. Located at 209 Main St, this establishment serves the local community with a wide variety of flavors and frozen treats. The shop is highly rated, maintaining a 4.20 rating from customers. The shop...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- East Orange, New Jersey
- shop.hersheys.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Florham Park, New Jersey
- locations.baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Point Pleasant, New Jersey
- (732) 892-0270
- hoffmansicecreamnj.net
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Jersey City, New Jersey
- (201) 432-9458
- toricoicecream.com
Torico Ice Cream is an ice cream shop in Jersey City, NJ. The business offers a wide range of unique ice cream flavors, sorbets, sherbets, and ice cream cakes. Serving both individual customers and the broader food service industry, they provide handcrafted...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Collingswood, New Jersey
- (856) 854-8221
- water.com
Primo Water Ice is an ice cream shop in Collingswood, New Jersey. It serves a range of ice cream treats and is known for its 4.70 rating based on customer reviews. The shop is located at 28 Haddon Ave, serving the local community with a focus on quality and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Vineland, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard of Vineland: Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard is an Ice Cream Shop in Vineland, NJ. Located at 3638 E Landis Ave, the business offers Italian ice, frozen custard, and specialty creations to customers in the local area. Rita's is known for its wide variety of flavors...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Willingboro, New Jersey
- holidayscalendar.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Pennsville, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Manalapan, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Piscataway, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Roselle, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Cinnaminson, New Jersey
- ritasice.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Bound Brook, New Jersey
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Glen Rock, New Jersey
- (888) 454-5946
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Cliffside Park, New Jersey
- (888) 454-5946
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Freehold, New Jersey
- coldstonecreamery.com
Cold Stone Creamery of Freehold: Cold Stone Creamery is an ice cream shop in Freehold, New Jersey, located at 420 Mounts Corner Dr. The shop specializes in custom-made ice cream, ice cream cakes, shakes, and smoothies, all prepared fresh on a frozen granite stone using high-quality...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Marlboro, New Jersey
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- South Orange, New Jersey
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- East Windsor, New Jersey
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Atlantic City, New Jersey
- scoopsicecream.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Nutley, New Jersey
- carvel.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Secaucus, New Jersey
- (201) 984-0261
- stackcreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (973) 595-1647
- gelotti.com
Gelotti Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Paterson, NJ, located at 2 Union Ave. The business serves North Jersey with handcrafted ice cream, authentic Italian gelato, espresso, specialty desserts, Italian ice, yogurt, novelties, and cakes. Owned by the Sigona...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Milford, New Jersey
- baskinrobbins.com
Baskin-Robbins of New Milford: Baskin-Robbins is an ice cream shop in New Milford, NJ. The shop offers a wide variety of flavors and treats for every occasion, maintaining a 4.30 rating. Customers can enjoy various options including scoops, sundaes, beverages, cones, and specialized items...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Dover, New Jersey
- doverdairymaid.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- West Orange, New Jersey
- guerrierogelato.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Willingboro, New Jersey
- (845) 638-1375
- roccos.com
Rocco's Italian Ice of Willingboro: Rocco's Italian Ice is an ice cream shop in Willingboro, NJ. The establishment provides a variety of dining options, including gourmet pizza by the slice, appetizers, salads, pasta, seafood, veal, and quality meats. The business is a family-owned and operated...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Manville, New Jersey
- (908) 307-6002
- freshtikibar.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Brunswick, New Jersey
- thebakedbear.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Manville, New Jersey
- (908) 300-2739
- icecreamforall.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Irvington, New Jersey
- dippysippyicecream.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Secaucus, New Jersey
- (201) 267-0204
- uncledsinicecream.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Pleasantville, New Jersey
- (609) 904-5264
- mooicecream.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Plainfield, New Jersey
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Pleasantville, New Jersey
- (609) 796-2525
- jerseycowicecream.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ringwood, New Jersey
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Ridgefield Park, New Jersey
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Wyckoff, New Jersey
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Oakland, New Jersey
- (201) 337-5627
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- North Brunswick, New Jersey
- haagendazs.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- North Bergen, New Jersey
- dairyqueen.com
Recently Updated Ice Cream Shop in New Jersey
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Burlington, New Jersey
- (609) 459-5242
- lexylicious.com
Lexylicious Ice Cream Cafe | New Jersey is an ice cream shop in Burlington, NJ, located at 190 Atlantic Ave. It holds a 4.70 rating based on customer reviews. The business is a woman-owned company founded by Bridget Bergin, who has been serving customers in...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Gloucester City, New Jersey
- (305) 306-3204
- azenco-outdoor.com
Cabana Water Ice Co is an Ice Cream Shop in Gloucester City, NJ. Azenco Outdoor provides premium aluminum outdoor living solutions, including motorized louvered pergolas, retractable fabric pergolas, and insulated patio covers. Their product collection...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Lodi, New Jersey
- (201) 393-4891
- ralphsices.com
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & ice cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Lodi, NJ, located at 239 Boulevard. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. Founded in 1928 by Ralph Silvestro, who began making lemon and orange ices by hand in his Staten Island...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Irvington, New Jersey
- honeyandhiveicecream.com
Honey & Hive Artisanal Ice Cream of Irvington: Honey & Hive Artisanal Ice Cream is an ice cream shop in Maplewood, NJ, located at 1611 Springfield Avenue. It holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. The shop specializes in handcrafted, nut-free ice cream made with local fresh milk and cream. They...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Summit, New Jersey
- (908) 273-2565
- magic-fountain.placejoys.com
Magic Fountain is an ice cream shop in Summit, New Jersey. Serving locals and visitors alike, this walk-up establishment specializes in a variety of frozen treats, including ice cream, frozen yogurt, and freshly made waffle cones. The shop maintains a 4.6...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Collingswood, New Jersey
- (856) 854-8221
- water.com
Primo Water Ice is an ice cream shop in Collingswood, New Jersey. It serves a range of ice cream treats and is known for its 4.70 rating based on customer reviews. The shop is located at 28 Haddon Ave, serving the local community with a focus on quality and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Paterson, New Jersey
- (973) 595-1647
- gelotti.com
Gelotti Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Paterson, NJ, located at 2 Union Ave. The business serves North Jersey with handcrafted ice cream, authentic Italian gelato, espresso, specialty desserts, Italian ice, yogurt, novelties, and cakes. Owned by the Sigona...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Willingboro, New Jersey
- (845) 638-1375
- roccos.com
Rocco's Italian Ice of Willingboro: Rocco's Italian Ice is an ice cream shop in Willingboro, NJ. The establishment provides a variety of dining options, including gourmet pizza by the slice, appetizers, salads, pasta, seafood, veal, and quality meats. The business is a family-owned and operated...
What the Data Shows for Ice Cream Shops in New Jersey
11% of the 38 ice cream shops we measured in New Jersey reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 32, compared with an average SEO score of 70.
The average Google rating across 56 rated ice cream shops is 4.3, and the median listing has 210 reviews.
None of the 56 ice cream shops has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best ice cream shop in New Jersey? BizScoreAI scores 56 Ice Cream Shop listings across New Jersey on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New Jersey Ice Cream Shop listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my ice cream shop listing in New Jersey?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every ice cream shop listing in New Jersey is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
