Otterstedt Insurance Agency

Otterstedt Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Hackettstown, NJ, located at 313 High St #1. The agency serves families, individuals, and businesses with a focus on protection and future planning. Specific services include business insurance, human resources outsourcing through partner AlphaStaff, and coverage for social service organizations. The team provides workers compensation and health benefits solutions, along with 401k and section 125 cafeteria plan administration. Agents Kassandra, Pete Laudenbauk, and Carla are noted for their knowledge, patience, and ability to help clients save money. The agency is recognized as a Trusted Choice Agent and holds a rating of 4.00 based on customer reviews.

Founded in 1919 by Fred H. Otterstedt, the agency has a 100-year history of service. In 1955, Joe Parisi Sr. purchased the company from Mr. Otterstedt and, with his wife Lucille and son Joe Parisi Jr., built it into a leading tri-state area agency. Current President Bob Casazza continues this tradition. The agency distinguishes itself by helping clients make informed decisions rather than simply selling insurance. It has been recognized as one of the Top 50 Insurance Agencies in the country. The team leverages its standing to access the best insurance companies in the nation, aiming to provide competitive rates and tailored policies.

The agency offers comprehensive human resources services through a partnership with AlphaStaff. This includes a Human Resource Outsourcing and Professional Employer Organization program designed to help employers attract talent, ensure compliance with state, federal, and local regulations, and manage worksite safety. The service covers personnel relations management, OSHA PEO programs, and EEOC claims handling. For social service organizations, whether for-profit or not-for-profit, the agency provides customized insurance programs that address unique exposures and risk.

The agency’s standing in the industry gives it access to the best insurance companies in the country, enabling it to secure competitive prices and policies tailored to client needs. The experience and passion of every Otterstedt professional give clients insight into their current and future insurance needs.

Otterstedt Insurance Agency combines a century of experience with personalized service to help residents and businesses in Hackettstown, NJ, achieve peace of mind through informed insurance decisions.

The agency sits on High Street, just a short walk from Saint Mary's Parochial School and the Hackettstown Fire Department. It is also located near Main Street and Bowers Brook.

BizScoreAI gives the business a performance score of 86 out of 100, which measures how quickly the website loads to keep visitors engaged and aid search rankings. It also awards an authority score of 75 out of 100.