Best Pizza Place in New Jersey
Top Pizza Place Listings in New Jersey
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-41 of 41 Pizza Place listings in New Jersey · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Toms River, New Jersey
- (239) 315-3068
- visitnaplesfl.com
Naples Pizza & Restaurant of Toms River: Naples Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place in Toms River, NJ. They offer a range of classic and specialty pizzas, catering to both casual diners and those seeking a more refined dining experience. With a strong focus on quality and customer satisfaction...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Voorhees, New Jersey
- (856) 543-9151
- nostrapizzanj.com
Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery is a pizza place in Voorhees, NJ. The establishment specializes in New York style pizza and Italian fare, serving the local community with food that is prepared fresh to order. The restaurant maintains a 4.60 rating from its...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Harrison, New Jersey
- (973) 485-9200
- ahpizzharrison.com
Ah' Pizz Harrison is a Pizza Place in Harrison, NJ, located at 615 Frank E Rodgers Blvd S. The restaurant specializes in authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian fare, featuring a menu that includes pasta, meat, fish, and various appetizers. They offer on-site...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- New Milford, New Jersey
- (201) 262-4600
- bigjimsnewmilford.com
Big Jim's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in New Milford, NJ, located at 281 Main St. It is a family-owned neighborhood spot that has served the community for over 50 years. The pizzeria offers classic New Jersey-style pies, hearty pasta dishes, calzones...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Bound Brook, New Jersey
- blazepizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Egg Harbor, New Jersey
- naplespompeii.com
Naples Pizza & Restaurant of Egg Harbor: Naples Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place in Egg Harbor, NJ. The establishment maintains a 4.60 rating from its customers. The business is located on W Main St, just a short distance from the Tuckerton Borough Municipal Complex and the New Jersey State...
#7A1 Pizza
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Lyndhurst, New Jersey
- (201) 531-0066
- a1pizzanj.com
A1 Pizza is a Pizza Place in Lyndhurst, NJ, located at 600 Ridge Rd. It offers a wide variety of Italian-American cuisine, including classic pizzas, pasta dishes, sandwiches, and appetizers. Customers can order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Manville, New Jersey
- (908) 895-5164
- manvillepizzarestaurant.com
Manville Pizza is a Pizza Place in Manville, NJ, located at 31 S Main St. The restaurant holds a rating of 4.40 based on customer reviews. It offers a wide variety of pizza options, including House Favorites such as Margherita Pizza, White Pizza with Broccoli...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Somerville, New Jersey
- (908) 526-0616
- alfonsostrattoria.com
Alfonso's Trattoria is a pizza place in Somerville, NJ. Serving a loyal customer base for over 40 years, this authentic Italian restaurant and gourmet pizzeria offers a diverse menu ranging from light bites to hearty meals. The establishment was founded in...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- South Brunswick, New Jersey
- (423) 288-5265
- giuseppespizzeriacatering.com
#11Pomodoro
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Fort Lee, New Jersey
- (201) 224-0800
- pomodorobrickovenpizza.com
Pomodoro is a Pizza Place in Fort Lee, NJ, located at 795 Abbott Blvd. The restaurant specializes in gourmet Old World brick oven pizza and Italian cuisine, offering a menu that ranges from traditional favorites to elaborate creations. Customers can order...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- South Orange, New Jersey
- (973) 762-8241
- villagepizzeriaoforangeave.com
Village Pizzeria of South Orange: Village Pizzeria is a pizza place in South Orange, NJ. The establishment offers a variety of pizza options, including traditional cheese, Sicilian, pan, and specialty pies such as Meat Lovers, Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken, and Margherita. Their menu also...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Newark, New Jersey
- blazepizza.com
#14Avenue Pizza
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Bloomfield, New Jersey
- (973) 281-4741
- theavenuepizza.com
Avenue Pizza is a pizza place in Bloomfield, NJ. The establishment offers a variety of specialized pizzas, including thin and crispy options, garlic knot crust pizzas, and unique selections such as the Thai Chili Chicken, Chicken Wing, and the Bloomfield...
#15Cafe Picasso
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Somerville, New Jersey
- (908) 429-8850
- cafe-picasso.com
Cafe Picasso is a pizza place in Somerville, NJ. The restaurant provides authentic Italian cooking and a warm, friendly ambiance for its customers. The restaurant's mission is to enable guests to enjoy the authenticity of true Italian cooking. Brothers...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Bergenfield, New Jersey
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Kearny, New Jersey
- (201) 806-6805
- bellarespizzamenu.com
Bella Re's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Kearny, NJ, located at 49 Kearny Ave. The business offers online ordering for delivery and pickup. The menu features hand-tossed cheese pizza, thin and crispy crust cheese pizza, and pan cheese pizza. Specialty options...
#18Bennys Pizza
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Woodbridge, New Jersey
- (845) 687-4243
- bennyspizzany.com
Bennys Pizza is a Pizza Place in Woodbridge, NJ. The establishment provides a variety of dining options including pizza, paninis, salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, entrees, and wraps. Serving the local community for over 25 years, this restaurant maintains a...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Scotch Plains, New Jersey
- (216) 631-4149
- nunziospizza.net
Nunzio's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Scotch Plains, NJ, located at 2387 Mountain Ave. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The business website identifies Nunzio’s Pizzeria as a family-owned and operated establishment in Cleveland, Ohio, headed...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- South Plainfield, New Jersey
- (571) 248-6290
- tonysnewyorkpizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Irvington, New Jersey
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- East Windsor, New Jersey
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Willingboro, New Jersey
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Paramus, New Jersey
- afpizza.com
Anthony Francos is a pizza place in Paramus, NJ. The establishment specializes in authentic New York-style pizza and a variety of classic and modern Italian dishes. Serving customers throughout Northern New Jersey, they provide services including dine-in...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- East Orange, New Jersey
- papajohns.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Cinnaminson, New Jersey
- (856) 829-0036
- bellisimospizza.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Nutley, New Jersey
- mammamia-pizza.dk
Mamma Mia’s Pizzeria is a pizza place in Nutley, NJ. The establishment holds a 4.50 rating from customers. The menu features a wide variety of specialty pizzas, ranging from simple options like the Bambino for children to complex, premium selections. Notable...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Jersey City, New Jersey
- (201) 356-9348
- razzanj.com
Razza Pizza restaurant is a Pizza Place in Jersey City, NJ. The establishment is dedicated to making and serving artisanal pizzas from a woodburning oven, earning a 4.50 rating. Their menu features traditional and inspired pizzas, small plates, beer, wine...
#29Pizzanada
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Bloomfield, New Jersey
- (973) 900-8668
- pizzanadas.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- West Long Branch, New Jersey
- lupopizzeria.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Moorestown, New Jersey
- carolloslittleitaly.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Edison, New Jersey
- (732) 248-2484
- njfrancospizzaedison.com
#33Slice House
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Toms River, New Jersey
- (732) 279-3541
- slicehousetr.com
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Morristown, New Jersey
- coniglios.com
Coniglio's Old Fashioned is a pizza place in Morristown, NJ. The establishment offers online ordering and catering services to the local community. The restaurant is led by Nino Coniglio, a Brooklyn-born pizza maker and restaurateur. A ten-time World Pizza...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Willingboro, New Jersey
- (609) 835-9111
- vincenzoswillingboro.com
- Pizza Place
- Carteret, New Jersey
- piezonepizza.com
- Pizza Place
- Montclair, New Jersey
- tegliapizzabar.com
- Pizza Place
- Piscataway, New Jersey
- amecipizzaandpasta.com
- Pizza Place
- Metuchen, New Jersey
- (973) 227-3007
- woodstacknj.com
Recently Updated Pizza Place in New Jersey
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Harrison, New Jersey
- (973) 485-9200
- ahpizzharrison.com
Ah' Pizz Harrison is a Pizza Place in Harrison, NJ, located at 615 Frank E Rodgers Blvd S. The restaurant specializes in authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian fare, featuring a menu that includes pasta, meat, fish, and various appetizers. They offer on-site...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- New Milford, New Jersey
- (201) 262-4600
- bigjimsnewmilford.com
Big Jim's Pizzeria is a Pizza Place in New Milford, NJ, located at 281 Main St. It is a family-owned neighborhood spot that has served the community for over 50 years. The pizzeria offers classic New Jersey-style pies, hearty pasta dishes, calzones...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Lyndhurst, New Jersey
- (201) 531-0066
- a1pizzanj.com
A1 Pizza is a Pizza Place in Lyndhurst, NJ, located at 600 Ridge Rd. It offers a wide variety of Italian-American cuisine, including classic pizzas, pasta dishes, sandwiches, and appetizers. Customers can order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Manville, New Jersey
- (908) 895-5164
- manvillepizzarestaurant.com
Manville Pizza is a Pizza Place in Manville, NJ, located at 31 S Main St. The restaurant holds a rating of 4.40 based on customer reviews. It offers a wide variety of pizza options, including House Favorites such as Margherita Pizza, White Pizza with Broccoli...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Fort Lee, New Jersey
- (201) 224-0800
- pomodorobrickovenpizza.com
Pomodoro is a Pizza Place in Fort Lee, NJ, located at 795 Abbott Blvd. The restaurant specializes in gourmet Old World brick oven pizza and Italian cuisine, offering a menu that ranges from traditional favorites to elaborate creations. Customers can order...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Kearny, New Jersey
- (201) 806-6805
- bellarespizzamenu.com
Bella Re's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Kearny, NJ, located at 49 Kearny Ave. The business offers online ordering for delivery and pickup. The menu features hand-tossed cheese pizza, thin and crispy crust cheese pizza, and pan cheese pizza. Specialty options...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Woodbridge, New Jersey
- (845) 687-4243
- bennyspizzany.com
Bennys Pizza is a Pizza Place in Woodbridge, NJ. The establishment provides a variety of dining options including pizza, paninis, salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, entrees, and wraps. Serving the local community for over 25 years, this restaurant maintains a...
Score breakdown
- Pizza Place
- Scotch Plains, New Jersey
- (216) 631-4149
- nunziospizza.net
Nunzio's Pizza is a Pizza Place in Scotch Plains, NJ, located at 2387 Mountain Ave. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The business website identifies Nunzio’s Pizzeria as a family-owned and operated establishment in Cleveland, Ohio, headed...
What the Data Shows for Pizza Places in New Jersey
6% of the 35 pizza places we measured in New Jersey reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 32, compared with an average SEO score of 68.
The average Google rating across 41 rated pizza places is 4.3.
None of the 41 pizza places has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 27, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best pizza place in New Jersey? BizScoreAI scores 41 Pizza Place listings across New Jersey on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are New Jersey Pizza Place listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my pizza place listing in New Jersey?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every pizza place listing in New Jersey is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
