Best Insurance Agency in Indiana
Top Insurance Agency Listings in Indiana
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-22 of 22 Insurance Agency listings in Indiana · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3178622200
- thegeorgegroupagency.com
The George Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. It offers a full range of personal and commercial coverage, including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and marine policies, as well as business owners packages, commercial auto...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (317) 841-9995
- rayinsurancegroup.com
Ray Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Fishers, Indiana, located at 11411 Overlook Drive. The agency specializes in car, homeowners, business, and life insurance. As an independent firm, it selects from financially strong carriers to fit...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (800) 247-1500
- nso.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Carmel, Indiana
- (281) 799-5868
- bwainsurance.com
BWC Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Carmel, IN. They offer a range of insurance services tailored to meet specific client needs with over 50 years of combined industry experience. Their expertise covers various insurance solutions for both individuals and...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3177862200
- bpinsured.com
Breneman Insurance Group is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving clients throughout Indiana and Illinois, this independent agency provides a variety of personal and business insurance solutions, including home, auto, RV, motorcycle, and condo...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3178829602
- easystreetins.com
Easy Street Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency specializes in helping seniors navigate Medicare coverage, serving clients in Indianapolis, Fishers, and Fort Wayne. Co-founders Jess and Sandra Carrasquillo have assisted thousands...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3179812046
- insuranceagencyindianapolisaog.com
Allstate Insurance Agency: AOG Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 4705 E 96th St Suite 31. Led by Denette Miller and her experienced agents, the agency provides insurance solutions for Indiana families and businesses. Their services...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (317) 363-0752
- brentturneragency.com
Brent Turner Agency is an insurance agency in Fishers, IN, serving individuals and businesses throughout the region with personalized coverage solutions. The agency specializes in auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, personal insurance, and...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3172987500
- mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com
McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis: McClain Matthews Insurance is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving families and businesses throughout Marion County, the agency provides a variety of personal insurance options, including auto, home, and condo coverage. They also specialize in...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3175816400
- libertymutual.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 4632559844
- insai.biz
Insurance Associates of Indiana is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency helps consumers save money and assists businesses in reducing risk. It offers a comprehensive suite of insurance products covering vehicles, property, and commercial...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Carmel, Indiana
- (317) 395-3877
- shieldpointinsurance.com
ShieldPoint Insurance is an insurance agency in Carmel, Indiana. The agency provides a variety of specialized services, including home, auto, life, and commercial insurance. Serving individuals, families, and business owners across Indiana, Tennessee, and...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (800) 275-8566
- firstpriorityinsurance.com
First Priority Insurance of Fishers: First Priority Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Fishers, IN. They offer a comprehensive range of personal and business insurance products including auto and homeowners insurance, specialty auto coverage, and various types of commercial insurance tailored...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Carmel, Indiana
- (317) 895-5555
- hittleinsurance.com
Hittle Insurance is an insurance agency in Carmel, Indiana. The agency provides a wide variety of personal, commercial, and life insurance products, including auto, home, business, and umbrella coverage. Serving clients across Indiana and Illinois, the agency...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3175883825
- binfordinsurance.com
Binford Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 600 E Carmel Dr #269. The agency provides personal and commercial insurance to families and businesses in Indianapolis and the surrounding area, including Fishers and Carmel. Services...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3174849195
- driveaffordable.com
Affordable Insurance Agency INC of Indianapolis: Affordable Insurance Agency INC is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. They specialize in providing low-cost auto insurance and services such as SR-50 and SR-22 filings, driver's license reinstatements, and non-owner policies. With over three decades of...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3172707800
- thealliancegroup.net
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3178626641
- vealinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- georgeinsuranceagency.com
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3174023171
- robertadamsinsurance.com
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- meharinsuranceagency.com
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3175593347
- myanchorins.com
Recently Updated Insurance Agency in Indiana
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3178622200
- thegeorgegroupagency.com
The George Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. It offers a full range of personal and commercial coverage, including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and marine policies, as well as business owners packages, commercial auto...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (317) 841-9995
- rayinsurancegroup.com
Ray Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Fishers, Indiana, located at 11411 Overlook Drive. The agency specializes in car, homeowners, business, and life insurance. As an independent firm, it selects from financially strong carriers to fit...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3178829602
- easystreetins.com
Easy Street Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency specializes in helping seniors navigate Medicare coverage, serving clients in Indianapolis, Fishers, and Fort Wayne. Co-founders Jess and Sandra Carrasquillo have assisted thousands...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3177862200
- bpinsured.com
Breneman Insurance Group is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving clients throughout Indiana and Illinois, this independent agency provides a variety of personal and business insurance solutions, including home, auto, RV, motorcycle, and condo...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3179812046
- insuranceagencyindianapolisaog.com
Allstate Insurance Agency: AOG Group is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 4705 E 96th St Suite 31. Led by Denette Miller and her experienced agents, the agency provides insurance solutions for Indiana families and businesses. Their services...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Fishers, Indiana
- (317) 363-0752
- brentturneragency.com
Brent Turner Agency is an insurance agency in Fishers, IN, serving individuals and businesses throughout the region with personalized coverage solutions. The agency specializes in auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, personal insurance, and...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 4632559844
- insai.biz
Insurance Associates of Indiana is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. The agency helps consumers save money and assists businesses in reducing risk. It offers a comprehensive suite of insurance products covering vehicles, property, and commercial...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agency
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3175883825
- binfordinsurance.com
Binford Insurance is an Insurance Agency in Indianapolis, IN, located at 600 E Carmel Dr #269. The agency provides personal and commercial insurance to families and businesses in Indianapolis and the surrounding area, including Fishers and Carmel. Services...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agencies in Indiana
22% of the 18 insurance agencies we measured in Indiana reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 37, compared with an average SEO score of 66.
The average Google rating across 17 rated insurance agencies is 4.8, and the median listing has 20 reviews.
None of the 22 insurance agencies has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 26, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agency in Indiana? BizScoreAI scores 22 Insurance Agency listings across Indiana on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Indiana Insurance Agency listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agency listing in Indiana?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agency listing in Indiana is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
