Best Ice Cream Shop in Indiana
Top Ice Cream Shop Listings in Indiana
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-23 of 23 Ice Cream Shop listings in Indiana · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Goshen, Indiana
- wearechief.com
Chief Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Goshen, IN. It is located at 502 W Lincoln Ave. The business holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. The website content provided belongs to Chief Nutrition, an Australian company selling snacks and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Albany, Indiana
- graeters.com
Graeter's Ice Cream of New Albany is a Ice Cream Shop in New Albany, IN. The shop crafts premium, hand‑packed ice cream and offers a full menu of flavors, gluten‑free sorbets, ice cream pies, toppings, and specialty treats. Guests can purchase gift cards...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Greenwood, Indiana
- handelsicecream.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Carmel, Indiana
- handelsicecream.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Valparaiso, Indiana
- (212) 310-6600
- centralparknyc.org
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Richmond, Indiana
- rubyscoops.com
Ruby Scoops Ice Cream & Sweets is an Ice Cream Shop in Richmond, IN. They specialize in offering 100% natural handcrafted frozen desserts and fresh cookies to their customers. Ruby Scoops has garnered a strong reputation with a rating of 4.70, reflecting the...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Portage, Indiana
- (269) 327-4057
- bellacreameryportagemi.com
Bella Creamery is an Ice Cream Shop in Portage, IN, located at 10098 Shaver Rd. The locally owned business prepares its ice cream fresh every morning on-site, offering handcrafted flavors that customers can pair with a variety of mix-ins and toppings. The...
#8Zesto
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Albany, Indiana
- (812) 944-6845
- ilovezesto.com
Zesto is an Ice Cream Shop in New Albany, IN, located at 2740 Charlestown Rd. The business serves customers with a wide variety of frozen treats and light meals, offering items to be eaten with a spoon, a straw, or a tongue, as well as take-home treats with...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Highland, Indiana
- locations.baskinrobbins.com
Baskin-Robbins of Highland: Baskin-Robbins is an ice cream shop in Highland, IN. The establishment offers a variety of flavors and treats, including specialty options like OREO® S'mores, Brookie Batter, and America's Birthday Cake. Customers can enjoy services such as dine-in...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Fishers, Indiana
- brusters.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Madison, Indiana
- scoopsicecream.com
Scoops Ice Cream Shoppe is an ice cream shop in Madison, IN. The shop offers 32 flavors of homemade ice cream, hand-crafted chocolates, hand-dipped caramel apples, and a variety of novelty candies. They also provide catering services and gift options for...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Huntington, Indiana
- kilwins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Frankfort, Indiana
- sweetpalaceuae.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Mishawaka, Indiana
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Lawrence, Indiana
- coldstonecreamery.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Terre Haute, Indiana
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Muncie, Indiana
- baskinrobbins.com
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Greenwood, Indiana
- kwalityfoods.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Highland, Indiana
- icewheelsnw.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Richmond, Indiana
- (765) 962-1173
- uranusfudgemanufacturing.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Lawrence, Indiana
- baskinrobbins.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Merrillville, Indiana
- dairyqueen.com
- Ice Cream Shop
- Munster, Indiana
- baskinrobbins.com
Recently Updated Ice Cream Shop in Indiana
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Goshen, Indiana
- wearechief.com
Chief Ice Cream is an Ice Cream Shop in Goshen, IN. It is located at 502 W Lincoln Ave. The business holds a rating of 4.80 based on customer reviews. The website content provided belongs to Chief Nutrition, an Australian company selling snacks and...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Albany, Indiana
- graeters.com
Graeter's Ice Cream of New Albany is a Ice Cream Shop in New Albany, IN. The shop crafts premium, hand‑packed ice cream and offers a full menu of flavors, gluten‑free sorbets, ice cream pies, toppings, and specialty treats. Guests can purchase gift cards...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Richmond, Indiana
- rubyscoops.com
Ruby Scoops Ice Cream & Sweets is an Ice Cream Shop in Richmond, IN. They specialize in offering 100% natural handcrafted frozen desserts and fresh cookies to their customers. Ruby Scoops has garnered a strong reputation with a rating of 4.70, reflecting the...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Portage, Indiana
- (269) 327-4057
- bellacreameryportagemi.com
Bella Creamery is an Ice Cream Shop in Portage, IN, located at 10098 Shaver Rd. The locally owned business prepares its ice cream fresh every morning on-site, offering handcrafted flavors that customers can pair with a variety of mix-ins and toppings. The...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- New Albany, Indiana
- (812) 944-6845
- ilovezesto.com
Zesto is an Ice Cream Shop in New Albany, IN, located at 2740 Charlestown Rd. The business serves customers with a wide variety of frozen treats and light meals, offering items to be eaten with a spoon, a straw, or a tongue, as well as take-home treats with...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Highland, Indiana
- locations.baskinrobbins.com
Baskin-Robbins of Highland: Baskin-Robbins is an ice cream shop in Highland, IN. The establishment offers a variety of flavors and treats, including specialty options like OREO® S'mores, Brookie Batter, and America's Birthday Cake. Customers can enjoy services such as dine-in...
Score breakdown
- Ice Cream Shop
- Madison, Indiana
- scoopsicecream.com
Scoops Ice Cream Shoppe is an ice cream shop in Madison, IN. The shop offers 32 flavors of homemade ice cream, hand-crafted chocolates, hand-dipped caramel apples, and a variety of novelty candies. They also provide catering services and gift options for...
What the Data Shows for Ice Cream Shops in Indiana
22% of the 18 ice cream shops we measured in Indiana reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 37, compared with an average SEO score of 71.
The average Google rating across 23 rated ice cream shops is 4.4, and the median listing has 971 reviews.
None of the 23 ice cream shops has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Jul 21, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best ice cream shop in Indiana? BizScoreAI scores 23 Ice Cream Shop listings across Indiana on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Indiana Ice Cream Shop listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my ice cream shop listing in Indiana?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every ice cream shop listing in Indiana is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
