McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis

Insurance Agency Indianapolis, IN
57 / 100

BizScore

How we score
41
AI Visibility
28
AI Ready
—
AI Agent ReadinessNot audited yet
77
SEO Performance
100
Freshness
98
Google Rating
AI Visibility Scores bySEOScanPRORun a free full audit

Contact Information

Location

About McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis

McClain Matthews Insurance is an insurance agency in Indianapolis, IN. Serving families and businesses throughout Marion County, the agency provides a variety of personal insurance options, including auto, home, and condo coverage. They also specialize in business insurance for various industries, such as retail, restaurants, and contractors, offering solutions like general liability and business auto. The agency maintains a 4.90 rating from its clients.

This family-owned agency has provided local insurance solutions since 1948. The team is led by owner and principal Karl Buetow, a licensed professional with over 35 years of experience in the insurance industry. As an independent agency, they work with various insurance companies to help clients explore coverage options that align with their individual goals and lifestyles.

The office is located on Hollister Drive in Indianapolis. The agency is situated about 0.4 miles from the Speedway Branch post office and is a short drive from Meadowood Park, Faculty Park, and the Speedway Public Library. Nearby educational institutions include Lew Wallace School #107 and Frank H Wheeler Elementary School.

The business maintains well-documented information online, making it easy for the community to find essential details about their services. Their digital presence is well-optimized, ensuring that their insurance solutions are clearly accessible to those searching for coverage in the region.

McClain Matthews Insurance continues to provide dedicated protection and local perspective to the Indianapolis community.

Score Summary

BizScoreAI scanned the website mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com on July 2, 2026. McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis has a BizScore of 57 out of 100. The website audit behind the SEO score ran on October 26, 2026.

  • AI Visibility41 out of 100
  • SEO77 out of 100
  • Google rating4.9 out of 5

AI visibility scan by category: AI Discovery 10 of 25 points, Structured Data 8 of 25 points, Content Readiness 22 of 30 points, AI Trust Signals 11 of 20 points.

Website audit sub-scores (out of 100): On-Page 91, Technical 94, Performance 63, Content 58.

Strengths: 6 checks passed. AI Crawler Access, AI Content Blocking, Organization Schema, Q&A Content, Meta Description, XML Sitemap.

Areas to improve: 11 checks. llms.txt (failed), FAQPage Schema (failed), Google Business Profile Link (failed), LocalBusiness Schema (failed), Third-Party Review Links (failed), Speakable Schema (warning), Hyperlocal Targeting (warning), Local Multimedia (warning), Weak Heading Structure (warning), About/Team Page (warning), Author Signals (warning).

AI engine reads

Read by AI engines 4 times in the last 30 days.

Counted from AI crawler and assistant visits to this page, identified by user agent.

See the full AI visibility report for this business

Contact McClain Matthews Insurance of Indianapolis

AI Visibility Score

How visible is this business to AI-powered search engines

41 /100
AI Discovery
40/100
Structured Data
32/100
Content Readiness
73/100
AI Trust Signals
55/100

Ways to improve this score

llms.txt Missing
FAQPage Schema Missing
Google Business Profile Link
AI Visibility Scores bySEOScanPRORun a free full audit

SEO Score

Technical SEO health and search engine optimization

77 /100
On-Page
91/100
Technical
94/100
Performance
63/100
Content
58/100

Ways to improve this score

Improve Content
Improve Performance

Local SEO Coverage

Directory presence and NAP consistency

— /100
Improve my scores

We improve your AI Visibility, SEO, and Local SEO scores as far as your current website allows.

Improve my scores

Boost This Listing

Get a gold badge, photo gallery, and more.

$199/yr
Featured
$499/yr
Featured Pro

Need Help?

Questions about this listing or your score?

Get Support

Claim This Business

Claim this listing to get your free AI SEO Score and start improving your visibility to AI search engines.

Already have an account? Sign in

How claiming works
  1. Create your free account above.
  2. Confirm your email. We send a 6-digit code to an address at your business website's domain, for example [email protected].
  3. Enter the code. The listing is yours. No business email? Add a DNS record instead, or we review the claim by hand.

Only someone who controls the business's email or domain can claim it, which keeps your listing secure.

Step-by-step guide to claiming your listing

Contact

Send a message to this business