Best Insurance Agent in Indiana
Top Insurance Agent Listings in Indiana
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 187 Insurance Agent listings in Indiana · page 1 of 4

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Speedway, Indiana
- (317) 597-7020
- freewayinsurance.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mishawaka, Indiana
- (574) 855-4837
- pilotinsuranceagency.com
Pilot Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Mishawaka, IN. They provide comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Mishawaka and the surrounding areas of Indiana. With a rating of 4.90, Pilot Insurance Agency stands out for its...
#3Freeway Insurance of Fort Wayne Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Fort Wayne, Indiana
- (260) 638-5023
- freeway.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 288-5099
- wencinsurance.com
Wenclewicz Insurance is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN. They specialize in providing a range of insurance services including auto, home, business, life, boat, and umbrella insurance. With a high rating of 4.90, Wenclewicz Insurance serves their...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 633-3036
- freeway.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (800) 723-3276
- infarmbureau.com
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance of Indianapolis: Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Indianapolis, IN. The agency offers a specific range of coverage options, including Auto, Home, Life, Renters, and Business Insurance. It also provides Farm and Crop Insurance, Financial services, and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Schererville, Indiana
- (219) 841-8011
- freewayinsurance.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Granger, Indiana
- (574) 277-5511
- higagency.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Bloomington, Indiana
- (812) 679-8779
- shineinsurance.com
Shine Insurance Agency LLC is an Insurance Agent in Bloomington, IN. The agency provides personal and business insurance solutions, including home and auto bundled coverage, life, umbrella, and high net worth individual protection. Business insurance...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Plainfield, Indiana
- gillmarine.com
Gill Insurance Advisors is an insurance agent in Plainfield, IN. The business maintains a 4.90 rating. Gill Insurance Advisors provides professional insurance services to the local community. The business is recognized for its high level of discoverability...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Connersville, Indiana
- (765) 825-8050
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Plymouth, Indiana
- (574) 355-3335
- brockeyinsurance.com
Brockey Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Plymouth, IN. The Plymouth office, located at 1300 W Jefferson St Ste A, is led by Brian Harris and offers coverage for auto, home, business, and life insurance. The agency serves customers with specific...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 634-7491
- gregoryappel.com
Gregory & Appel Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Indianapolis, IN. The firm provides risk management solutions and insurance services for businesses, employees, and individuals. Their offerings include employee benefits consulting, human resources support...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 808-7711
- connerins.com
Conner Insurance is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN. The agency provides a wide range of personal, commercial, and benefits insurance solutions to clients throughout the United States. Their specialized services include employee benefits programs...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 232-9999
- aldridge.com
Aldridge Insurance, Inc. is an insurance agent in South Bend, IN, located at 1323 N Ironwood Dr. The business holds a rating of 5.00 based on customer reviews. Aldridge has helped businesses use technology to work smarter, stay secure and prepare for what is...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- East Chicago, Indiana
- (219) 440-4446
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Merrillville, Indiana
- (888) 411-9715
- eliteinsuranceofmerrillville.com
Elite Insurance Of Merrillville is an Insurance Agent in Merrillville, IN, located at 8045 Cleveland Pl. The firm provides life insurance, burial insurance, final expense coverage, and Medicare supplements to clients in Indiana and Illinois. Their certified...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- East Chicago, Indiana
- (219) 398-1200
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Noblesville, Indiana
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Shelbyville, Indiana
- (317) 392-3922
- statefarm.com
Beth Prince - State Farm Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Shelbyville, IN. Serving the local community, this agency provides a wide range of personalized coverage options, including vehicle, property, home, and business insurance. Their offerings...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Valparaiso, Indiana
- (843) 799-2306
- rainesco.com
Raines Insurance Group is an insurance agent in Valparaiso, IN. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews. The business operates under the Raines name, which is also associated with a hospitality management organization. That organization develops...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hammond, Indiana
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com
#23Statefarm

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Beech Grove, Indiana
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (463) 800-2254
- statefarm.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Peru, Indiana
- (765) 473-9291
- statefarm.com
Christy Winter - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Peru, IN, located at 998 W Main St. The agency provides auto, home, life, renters, boat, pet, and business insurance to residents of Peru and surrounding areas including Miami County...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 465-2500
- servpro.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 875-1522
- indyselectinsurance.com
Indy Select Insurance is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, Indiana. The agency provides a wide range of personal and business insurance services to residents of Indiana and Nevada, including auto, home, life, and commercial insurance. Their specific...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 545-8711
- andpartners.com
Partners Insurance LLC is an Insurance Agent in Evansville, IN. They specialize in providing comprehensive financial advice and insurance solutions, focusing on client-centric services to ensure financial stability and growth for their clients. With a perfect...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Lebanon, Indiana
- (765) 481-2350
- statefarm.com
Cory Shafer - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Lebanon, IN. The agency provides auto, motorcycle, homeowners, condo, renters, life, Medicare supplement, supplemental health, small business, and pet insurance. It serves Boone County and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Merrillville, Indiana
- (219) 472-0822
- larsonbrokerage.com
Larson Brokerage Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Merrillville, IN. The agency provides brokerage services for personal and commercial solutions, including assistance with SR-22 filings, suspended or invalid licenses, and international licenses. It...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Hammond, Indiana
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Greenwood, Indiana
- (844) 217-0177
- reliant.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Connersville, Indiana
- (765) 825-7174
- leefamilyinsurance.com
Lee Family Insurance is an insurance agent in Connersville, Indiana. This family-owned agency provides a variety of personal and business insurance services, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. They also specialize in farm insurance for hobby...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 597-7015
- locations.freeway.com
Freeway Insurance of Indianapolis is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN. The agency serves local residents by helping them compare options and save on a wide array of coverage types. Specific products include auto, motorcycle, RV, boat, ATV, snowmobile...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Lawrence, Indiana
- (800) 444-4040
- fredloya.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 471-3132
- servpro.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 234-2464
- nmhs.net
Peterson Insurance Agency, Inc is an Insurance Agent in South Bend, IN. The agency is recognized by its 3.90 rating from 58 reviews. The business provides thorough and well-documented information to assist clients. Peterson Insurance Agency, Inc is located on...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Auburn, Indiana
- (260) 333-5350
- healthmarkets.com
HealthMarkets Insurance - Kevin McIntire is an Insurance Agent in Auburn, IN. Kevin McIntire is a licensed health insurance agent who serves individuals and families in Auburn, Indiana, and surrounding communities across Indiana, Ohio, and Michigan. He offers...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 236-2791
- treeshinsurance.com
A-Agency A Division of Treesh Insurance is an Insurance Agent in South Bend, IN, located at 4327 W Western Ave. The agency provides affordable automobile insurance for Indiana residents, serving customers in South Bend, Mishawaka, Elkhart, Michigan City...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Plainfield, Indiana
- (800) 426-4261
- andersenwindows.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Indiana
- (855) 347-3939
- progressiveagent.com
Anderson Insurance is an insurance agent in Columbus, IN. The office operates as an independent agent, a distinction the business highlights by noting that independent agents do not work for a single insurance company but instead sell policies from multiple...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Richmond, Indiana
- (765) 966-3814
- theleafsnation.com
Malhotra & Assoc. Insurance is a local insurance agent in Richmond, Indiana, serving individuals and families with personalized coverage solutions. The agency specializes in life insurance, health insurance, and retirement planning, helping clients secure...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 491-1090
- ucdavis.edu

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Gary, Indiana
- (724) 863-9999
- brickhousetap.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Valparaiso, Indiana
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com
Sam Allie - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Valparaiso, IN, located at 3809 Calumet Ave. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews. The agency serves customers in Valparaiso and Kouts, IN, as well as Lake and Cook Counties, IL...
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Portage, Indiana
- (219) 762-7979
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 901-1234
- locations.acceptance.com
Acceptance Insurance of Evansville is an insurance agent in Evansville, Indiana. The agency provides a wide variety of coverage options, including auto insurance, renters insurance, motorcycle insurance, and SR-22 insurance. They serve the local community...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 231-1500
- michianavillage.org

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 350-1598
- wenc-insurance.com
Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group offers a wide range of insurance solutions including auto, home, business, life, and umbrella coverage. Located in Indianapolis, IN, they are committed to providing top-notch service and support.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 334-3743
- steffeyins.com
Steffey Insurance Agency of Indianapolis: Steffey Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN. The agency provides an extensive range of coverage options, including home, auto, flood, business, real estate, landlord, construction, transportation, surety bonds, life, and health...
Recently Updated Insurance Agent in Indiana
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Vincennes, Indiana
- (812) 882-3600
- burkhart-presidio.com
Burkhart Insurance Agency: Boulder City Air Conditioning is an HVAC company in Boulder City, NV, located at 119 Forest Ln. It holds a 5.00 rating based on customer reviews. The business is owned by Modern Air Conditioning & Heating LLC, which has 15 years of experience in the industry...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Greenwood, Indiana
- catalystinsurancegroup.com
Catalyst Insurance Group is an Insurance Agent in Greenwood, IN. It serves small businesses and individuals with affordable employee health benefits, specializing in MEC plans, HealthShare memberships, and direct primary care alternatives to traditional...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Dyer, Indiana
- (219) 865-6660
- joelovasko.com
Joe Lovasko - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Dyer, IN, located at 1107 Sheffield Ave. It holds a rating of 5.00 based on customer reviews. Joe Lovasko helps clients create Personal Price Plans to customize coverage for families...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Logansport, Indiana
- (574) 722-3545
- markhetz.com
Mark Hetz - State Farm Insurance Agent is an Insurance Agent in Logansport, IN. The office serves families and businesses with personalized insurance plans, offering coverage for auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, and health...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Evansville, Indiana
- (812) 916-6450
- geico.com
Daniel Edwards - GEICO Insurance Agent is an insurance agent in Evansville, IN. The business is located at 244 N Burkhardt Rd, Evansville, IN. It is independently owned and operated by EDWARDS INSURANCE SERVICES, LLC. Daniel Edwards serves as the local GEICO...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Merrillville, Indiana
- (219) 769-2387
- waltercookinsurance.com
Walter Cook Insurance Agency Inc is an Insurance Agent in Merrillville, IN, located at 7199 Broadway. The agency provides personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, home, life, business, and annuities coverage. Specific offerings include...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Indianapolis, Indiana
- (317) 856-4550
- killionindustries.com
Killion & Hall Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN, serving individuals and businesses with tailored coverage solutions including auto, home, life, and commercial insurance. The agency specializes in helping clients navigate complex...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Washington, Indiana
- (812) 254-7770
- terrikelso.com
Terri Kelso Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Washington, IN, located at 1211 S Meridian St. The agency offers life, auto, home, Medicare supplements, health, and business insurance. Owner Terri Kelso brings over thirty years of insurance and financial...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agents in Indiana
29% of the 143 insurance agents we measured in Indiana reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 40, compared with an average SEO score of 71.
The average Google rating across 184 rated insurance agents is 4.6, and the median listing has 26 reviews.
None of the 187 insurance agents has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 29, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agent in Indiana? BizScoreAI scores 187 Insurance Agent listings across Indiana on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Indiana Insurance Agent listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agent listing in Indiana?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agent listing in Indiana is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.