Best Thrift Store in Indiana
Top Thrift Store Listings in Indiana
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-33 of 33 Thrift Store listings in Indiana · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Shelbyville, Indiana
- (317) 524-4313
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Vincennes, Indiana
- (812) 882-5527
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Nappanee, Indiana
- (574) 773-7039
- neighborsmercantile.com
Neighbors Mercantile is a thrift store in Nappanee, IN, located at 151 E Market St. The shop serves the local community by providing a welcoming and nostalgic environment that celebrates the midwest way of living. It specializes in quality and affordable...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Muncie, Indiana
- (765) 282-0567
- platoscloset.com
Plato's Closet- Muncie is a thrift store located at 829 E McGalliard Rd in Muncie, IN. It holds a rating of 3.90 based on 0 reviews. The business buys and sells gently used clothing, shoes, and accessories for teens and young adults. Customers can shop for a...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- South Bend, Indiana
- (574) 440-1198
- kingdom-closet.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- New Albany, Indiana
- (812) 727-3061
- 812vintage.com
812 Vintage is a thrift store in New Albany, Indiana. The shop specializes in a wide variety of vintage clothing, including vintage t-shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, hoodies, and hats. Their collection features diverse items such as collegiate apparel, sports...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Gary, Indiana
- (219) 595-0652
- habitat.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Zionsville, Indiana
- (317) 344-3033
- habitat.org
Habitat for Humanity ReStore Boone County is a thrift store in Zionsville, IN, located at 10650 Andrade Drive. It operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Schererville, Indiana
- (219) 924-2446
- heartsinmotion.org
Hearts In Motion Resale Shoppe is a Thrift Store in Schererville, IN, located at 2210 US-41. The shop operates Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 4 PM and serves customers seeking gently used furniture, clothing, housewares, and toys. It also offers unique...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Warsaw, Indiana
- (574) 314-6603
- habitat.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Elkhart, Indiana
- (574) 293-0133
- hartcityfleamarket.com
Hart City Flea Market is a thrift store in Elkhart, Indiana. This large indoor destination serves the local community by providing a climate-controlled shopping experience featuring over 50,000 square feet of vendor booths. The market offers a variety of...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Plymouth, Indiana
- (574) 935-4214
- habitat.org
Habitat For Humanity of Plymouth: Habitat For Humanity is a Thrift Store in Plymouth, IN. Operating as a Habitat for Humanity ReStore, the location sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories, building materials and other household items at a fraction of retail prices...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Gary, Indiana
- (219) 923-7265
- habitat.org
Habitat for Humanity of Northwest Indiana ReStore is a thrift store in Gary, IN, located at 6114 W Ridge Rd. It operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Logansport, Indiana
- (574) 992-2311
- traderbucks.com
Trader Bucks Flea Market is a thrift store in Logansport, IN, located at 315 14th St. It holds a rating of 3.90 based on 11 reviews. The business operates large indoor markets featuring a selection of new and pre-owned items, collectibles, and gifts. Vendor...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- New Albany, Indiana
- (812) 748-5225
- mustardseedthrift.com
The Mustard Seed Thrift on Mission is a thrift store in New Albany, IN. Beyond providing retail goods, the organization serves as a mission-driven resource to connect survivors of childhood sexual abuse with counseling, education, and support services...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Jasper, Indiana
- (812) 634-2932
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hammond, Indiana
- (219) 838-7297
- humaneindiana.com
Humane Indiana PAWS Resale Plus! of Hammond is a thrift store in Hammond, IN, located at 8149 Kennedy Ave. It operates as the resale arm of Humane Indiana, a nonprofit organization that finds homes for homeless cats and dogs, offers resources to help families...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Frankfort, Indiana
- (765) 670-6099
- hopecollectiveresale.com
Hope Collective Resale Boutique is a Thrift Store in Frankfort, IN, located at 60 W Clinton St. It offers curated fashion and home goods as a social enterprise of WeCare Recovery Home. The shop operates Tuesday through Friday from 10am to 5pm and Saturday...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Greenfield, Indiana
- (317) 467-4991
- hancockhopehouse.org
Hancock Hope House Inc is a thrift store in Greenfield, IN, located at 35 E Pierson St. It operates a thrift store that supports the Hope House, a homeless shelter serving Hancock County. The organization provides a safe environment, positive support, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hobart, Indiana
- (219) 663-5266
- secondliferesale.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Greenfield, Indiana
- (317) 318-9380
- indyhabitat.org
Habitat for Humanity Greenfield ReStore is a thrift store in Greenfield, IN. It offers a wide range of products to help customers improve their homes without breaking the bank. The facility serves as a resource for the community and provides vital operational...
#22Attic Window
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Muncie, Indiana
- (765) 282-0997
- atticwindow.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Logansport, Indiana
- (574) 739-0107
- emmauschurchjacksonville.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- La Porte, Indiana
- (219) 326-5933
- coachmanantiques.com
- Thrift Store
- Portage, Indiana
- (219) 764-3375
- portageresaleshop.com
- Thrift Store
- Fort Wayne, Indiana
- (260) 744-1958
- careers.renew.com
- Thrift Store
- Franklin, Indiana
- (317) 736-4353
- salvagesistersantiquemarket.com
- Thrift Store
- Richmond, Indiana
- (765) 966-0066
- abilitiesrichmond.com
- Thrift Store
- Plainfield, Indiana
- (317) 837-7070
- kidsgoround.net
- Thrift Store
- Peru, Indiana
- (765) 472-1902
- harvestingcapabilities.org
- Thrift Store
- Fishers, Indiana
- (317) 288-8028
- fishersin.clothesmentor.com
- Thrift Store
- Muncie, Indiana
- (317) 524-4313
- goodwill.org
- Thrift Store
- Washington, Indiana
- (812) 254-1971
- goodwill.org
Recently Updated Thrift Store in Indiana
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Nappanee, Indiana
- (574) 773-7039
- neighborsmercantile.com
Neighbors Mercantile is a thrift store in Nappanee, IN, located at 151 E Market St. The shop serves the local community by providing a welcoming and nostalgic environment that celebrates the midwest way of living. It specializes in quality and affordable...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Zionsville, Indiana
- (317) 344-3033
- habitat.org
Habitat for Humanity ReStore Boone County is a thrift store in Zionsville, IN, located at 10650 Andrade Drive. It operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Gary, Indiana
- (219) 923-7265
- habitat.org
Habitat for Humanity of Northwest Indiana ReStore is a thrift store in Gary, IN, located at 6114 W Ridge Rd. It operates as a nonprofit home improvement store and donation center that sells new and gently used furniture, appliances, home accessories, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Logansport, Indiana
- (574) 992-2311
- traderbucks.com
Trader Bucks Flea Market is a thrift store in Logansport, IN, located at 315 14th St. It holds a rating of 3.90 based on 11 reviews. The business operates large indoor markets featuring a selection of new and pre-owned items, collectibles, and gifts. Vendor...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hammond, Indiana
- (219) 838-7297
- humaneindiana.com
Humane Indiana PAWS Resale Plus! of Hammond is a thrift store in Hammond, IN, located at 8149 Kennedy Ave. It operates as the resale arm of Humane Indiana, a nonprofit organization that finds homes for homeless cats and dogs, offers resources to help families...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Frankfort, Indiana
- (765) 670-6099
- hopecollectiveresale.com
Hope Collective Resale Boutique is a Thrift Store in Frankfort, IN, located at 60 W Clinton St. It offers curated fashion and home goods as a social enterprise of WeCare Recovery Home. The shop operates Tuesday through Friday from 10am to 5pm and Saturday...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Greenfield, Indiana
- (317) 467-4991
- hancockhopehouse.org
Hancock Hope House Inc is a thrift store in Greenfield, IN, located at 35 E Pierson St. It operates a thrift store that supports the Hope House, a homeless shelter serving Hancock County. The organization provides a safe environment, positive support, and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Greenfield, Indiana
- (317) 318-9380
- indyhabitat.org
Habitat for Humanity Greenfield ReStore is a thrift store in Greenfield, IN. It offers a wide range of products to help customers improve their homes without breaking the bank. The facility serves as a resource for the community and provides vital operational...
What the Data Shows for Thrift Stores in Indiana
13% of the 24 thrift stores we measured in Indiana reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 37, compared with an average SEO score of 70.
The average Google rating across 33 rated thrift stores is 4.4.
None of the 33 thrift stores has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best thrift store in Indiana? BizScoreAI scores 33 Thrift Store listings across Indiana on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Indiana Thrift Store listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my thrift store listing in Indiana?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every thrift store listing in Indiana is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
