Best Insurance Agent in Ohio
Top Insurance Agent Listings in Ohio
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-50 of 253 Insurance Agent listings in Ohio · page 1 of 6
#1DG Insurance Agency of Cincinnati Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 818-1923
- dgins-agency.com
DG Insurance Agency of Cincinnati: DG Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Cincinnati, OH, located at 3825 Edwards Rd Suite 620. The agency provides home, auto, and business insurance policies to residents throughout Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. As an independent agency, it works with...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Ashtabula, Ohio
- (440) 998-1112
- humphreyinsuranceagency.com
Humphrey Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Ashtabula, OH. The agency provides auto, home, business, RV, boat and motorcycle insurance, helping individuals, families and local businesses compare options and receive free quotes. With a 4.90 rating, the...
#3Mitchell Insurance Co Top-Rated

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 862-0519
- cheapsr22ohio.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Mentor, Ohio
- (440) 954-9500
- bosuinsurance.com
Bosu Insurance Group is an Insurance Agent in Mentor, OH. The independent full-service agency specializes in auto and home insurance bundling, life insurance, and fixed annuities for clients across Ohio, with a service area that includes Eastlake and Mentor...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Eastlake, Ohio
- (440) 954-9500
- bosuinsurance.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Alliance, Ohio
- (330) 823-9500
- hatherillinsurance.com
Hatherill Insurance Agency Inc is an insurance agent in Alliance, Ohio. The agency provides a full line of insurance products, including auto, home, life, business, and medicare supplements. Serving the local community with a 4.70 rating, the agency...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 704-6307
- ohioins.net
Four Point Insurance Agency, Inc. is a Insurance Agent in Cleveland, OH. The agency operates as an independent insurance broker, offering home, auto and business insurance coverage while shopping the entire Ohio market to secure the most competitive rates for...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 489-8383
- catanzaroinsurance.com
Catanzaro Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH. They provide flexible insurance solutions tailored to meet specific client needs, emphasizing honesty, dedication, and meaningful relationships. Serving the local community with a strong focus on...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 421-5700
- rmprice.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 762-7835
- phly.com
Philadelphia Insurance Co is a commercial insurance agent in Cincinnati, OH, specializing in Property/Casualty and Professional Liability insurance for small and mid-sized businesses across more than 120 niche markets. Serving clients throughout the United...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Lorain, Ohio
- (440) 984-3463
- lighthouseinsuranceagency.com
Lighthouse Insurance Agency of Lorain: Lighthouse Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Lorain, OH. They provide a wide range of insurance solutions including personal and commercial lines such as homeowners, auto, life/health, Medicare plans, long-term care, business property, contractors...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Toledo, Ohio
- (419) 241-5133
- knightinsurance.com
Knight Insurance Group is an Insurance Agent in Toledo, OH. The agency has served the community since 1859, tracing its roots to the Shawen Stieg & Whitaker Agency incorporated in Toledo. It offers personalized home, auto, business, life insurance, employee...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 522-6300
- ohioinsurancecenter.com
Ohio Insurance Center Agency is an Insurance Agent in Cincinnati, OH. It provides auto, SR-22, and homeowner's insurance for residents across Ohio. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews. The agency has been insuring Ohio drivers since 1974. It...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 236-8691
- isnerinsurance.com
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH. They offer a comprehensive range of personal and commercial insurance services including homeowners, auto, umbrella, and various specialized policies for ATV & powersports, motorcycles...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Coshocton, Ohio
- (740) 325-4707
- skylineinsuranceagency.com
Skyline Insurance Agency of Coshocton: Skyline Insurance Agency is a Insurance Agent in Coshocton, OH. The firm assists individuals, families, and small businesses in navigating health‑insurance options, offering guidance on Medicare plans, Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Euclid, Ohio
- (216) 331-3207
- motorsureamerica.com
Motorsure America-Ohio SR22 is an insurance agent in Euclid, OH. The agency specializes in affordable auto insurance and offers a wide range of coverage options including home, renters, commercial business, SR-22, motorcycle, and non-owner policies. The...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Circleville, Ohio
- (740) 474-2153
- cookinsuranceandtax.com
Cook Insurance & Tax Services is an Insurance Agent in Circleville, OH, located at 328 E Main St. The business provides auto, home, and business insurance for residents across Ohio. Their specific insurance offerings include auto insurance, homeowners...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Dayton, Ohio
- (937) 434-6800
- buckner.org
Buckner Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Dayton, OH. The organization maintains a 4.70 rating based on 77 reviews. Buckner operates as a faith-based nonprofit ministry dedicated to serving vulnerable children, families, and seniors both internationally and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 486-7646
- briggswilliamsinsurance.com
Briggs & Williams Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH. The agency specializes in commercial insurance and bonding for businesses and contractors throughout Central Ohio, with a specific focus on insuring the unusual. It works with a variety...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 885-9507
- yuinsurancegroup.com
Jonathan Yu, State Farm Insurance Agent, offers comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, and life insurance to protect individuals and businesses in Columbus, OH.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Barberton, Ohio
- (800) 782-8332
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Berea, Ohio
- (440) 243-7793
- volaninsurance.com
Volan Insurance Agency, Inc is an Insurance Agent in Berea, OH, located at 343 W Bagley Rd #208. The firm specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance for individuals and businesses across Ohio. As an independent agency, it works with a wide...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 427-1843
- sokoleisenberg.com
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance is an insurance agent in Columbus, OH. The agency provides tailored insurance solutions and expert guidance to individuals, families, and businesses throughout Central Ohio and is licensed nationwide. They offer a variety of...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 263-9699
- jrscottinsurance.com
J. R. Scott Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio. Serving the local community, this independent agency specializes in home, auto, and business insurance. Their comprehensive range of coverage includes renters, condo, and flood insurance...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Austintown, Ohio
- (330) 423-6423
- hearthstoneinsurancegroup.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Fairfield, Ohio
- (513) 829-6252
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 621-7183
- evartstremaine.com
Evarts Tremaine of Cleveland: Evarts Tremaine is an Insurance Agent in Cleveland, OH. As an independent, specialty agency, it provides business insurance, employee benefits, and personal insurance solutions. The agency serves clients across the United States, holding licenses in all 50...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 761-1500
- ohioinsurancequote.net
Washington & Co Insurance Agency of Cleveland: Washington & Co Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Cleveland, Ohio. The agency provides a wide range of coverage options for Ohio residents, including auto, property, and commercial truck insurance. Their specialized services include SR22 insurance...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Conneaut, Ohio
- (440) 593-1191
- brechtinsurance.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Circleville, Ohio
- (740) 474-6055
- delonginsurance.com
DeLong Insurance is an insurance agent in Circleville, Ohio. As an independent insurance agency, they provide quality personal and business insurance services throughout the Circleville region and the rest of Ohio. The agency maintains a 4.50 rating and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 677-5015
- progressive.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Toledo, Ohio
- (567) 455-4202
- progressive.com
Progressive Insurance - Authorized Agent Toledo is an insurance agent in Toledo, Ohio. The agency provides a wide range of insurance products and customized coverages for individuals, families, and businesses. Their offerings include auto, motorcycle, RV, and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Euclid, Ohio
- (216) 848-0650
- armstrongstewartinsurance.com
Armstrong-Stewart Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Euclid, OH. The agency provides coverage for auto, home, renters, motorcycle, commercial auto, boat, ATV, RV, and SR-22 filings. It holds a 5.00 rating based on customer reviews. Shameka...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (888) 901-5650
- ohioinsureplan.com
Hyers & Associates Insurance is an insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio. This independent insurance brokerage provides a wide array of services to individuals, families, businesses, and employer groups across the United States. Their specialties include Medicare...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 661-8300
- lauberandwill.com
Lauber & Will Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Cincinnati, OH. The firm specializes in Home Insurance, Car Insurance, Life Insurance, Health Insurance, and Business Insurance. They serve clients throughout Ohio, including Dent, Harrison, Western Hills...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (888) 667-1212
- comparequote.com
Compare Quote Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH, located at 5959 Scarborough Blvd #4500. The agency helps residents and vehicle buyers compare auto, home, renters, condo, umbrella, and life insurance by shopping multiple A-rated carriers or...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 326-0200
- horizoninsservices.com
Horizon Insurance Services, Inc. is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH. As an independent agency, it specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance for residents and companies across Ohio. The agency works with a wide variety of top carriers to help...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cleveland, Ohio
- (216) 249-7983
- locations.acceptance.com
Acceptance Insurance of Cleveland is an Insurance Agent in Cleveland, OH, located at 3360 Warren Rd. The agency specializes in affordable auto, renters, motorcycle, and home insurance for residents in the 44111 area. It offers bilingual service and same-day...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Akron, Ohio
- (330) 346-3695
- acceptance.com
Acceptance Insurance of Akron: Acceptance Insurance is an insurance agent in Akron, Ohio. The agency provides a wide variety of coverage options, including auto, motorcycle, RV, motorhome, boat, ATV, snowmobile, and classic car insurance, as well as SR-22 auto insurance. They serve...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Defiance, Ohio
- (419) 782-7176
- grantinsurance.com
Grant Insurance is a Insurance Agent in Defiance, OH. The agency offers personalized auto, home, farm, life, Medicare and business insurance solutions to individuals, families and businesses throughout Northwest Ohio, including Defiance, Continental and...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Coshocton, Ohio
- (740) 622-1796
- jacobsvanaman.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 440-3452
- progressive.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Athens, Ohio
- (740) 593-5573
- mathewsinsurance.com
Mathews Insurance, Inc is an insurance agent in Athens, Ohio. Serving Southeast Ohio, the agency provides a variety of personal and business insurance solutions, including home, auto, flood, and individual life coverage, as well as specialized options for...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Barberton, Ohio
- (937) 653-4660
- nmiagency.com
NMI Insurance Agency, LTD is an insurance agent in Barberton, Ohio. The agency provides a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, and personal insurance, as well as business and commercial insurance. Their services extend to specialized needs...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 871-3330
- globeagency.com
Globe Insurance Agency of Cincinnati: Globe Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Cincinnati, Ohio. This independent agency provides a wide range of insurance solutions for personal and business needs, serving clients across Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, and Tennessee. Personal insurance offerings...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (380) 203-2621
- royalservicepro.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Brunswick, Ohio
- (330) 225-2550
- healthmarkets.com
HealthMarkets Insurance - Roni Bell is an Insurance Agent in Brunswick, OH. Roni Bell helps individuals, families, and small businesses find health, Medicare, dental, vision, supplemental, and life insurance plans that fit their needs and budgets. She works...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 407-9778
- acceptance.com
Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Berea, Ohio
- (440) 356-2520
- statefarm.com

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Toledo, Ohio
- (419) 693-7458
- progressiveagent.com
Detlef Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Toledo, OH. The agency offers a wide range of personal and commercial coverage options, including auto, home, renters, condo, boat and personal watercraft, motorcycle, ATV, dirt bike, moped and scooter, snowmobile, RV...
Recently Updated Insurance Agent in Ohio
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Lorain, Ohio
- (440) 324-3447
- somersagency.com
Somers Agency LLC is an independent insurance agency in Lorain, Ohio. The agency handles auto, home, business, life, renters, and boat insurance, and it works with a range of insurance companies to compare rates and coverage for customers. It serves Lorain...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Columbus, Ohio
- (614) 267-1269
- pwlinsurance.com
Putnam White Lewis Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Columbus, OH. The agency serves businesses, individuals, and families throughout Ohio with tailored insurance solutions and risk management options. As an independent agency, it works with multiple...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Akron, Ohio
- (330) 665-1900
- akroninsurance.com
Akron Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Akron, OH, located at 1099 S Cleveland Massillon Rd. The firm is a team of professional, caring, and conscientious people with over 100 years of combined experience. They provide personal service and aim...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio
- (330) 608-6340
- eveningstarinsurance.com
Eveningstar Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Cuyahoga Falls, OH, located at 3140 Bailey Rd. This independent agency serves individuals, families, and businesses across Northeast Ohio, including Summit, Stark, and Portage counties. With over 20 years of...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 851-9700
- ohio.gov
Ohio's Best Insurance Agency LLC is an insurance agent in Cincinnati, OH, serving individuals and families with personalized coverage solutions including auto, home, life, and business insurance. The agency specializes in helping clients navigate complex...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 870-2000
- cinfin.com
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies is an insurance agent in Cincinnati, OH, located at 6200 S Gilmore Rd. The company provides personal, commercial, and life insurance products, which are sold exclusively through independent insurance agents. Founded in 1950...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 381-1919
- zimmerinsurance.com
Zimmer Insurance Agency is an Insurance Agent in Cincinnati, OH. The firm provides insurance for individuals, families, and businesses, including coverage for buildings, property, equipment, inventory, vehicles, and homes. As an independent agent, the agency...

Score breakdown
- Insurance Agent
- Cincinnati, Ohio
- (513) 741-2100
- safariinsurance.com
Safari Insurance is an Insurance Agent in Cincinnati, OH. The agency provides insurance guidance and coverage options for individuals, families, and business owners, including those in industries such as general liability, business auto, contractors...
What the Data Shows for Insurance Agents in Ohio
30% of the 172 insurance agents we measured in Ohio reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 41, compared with an average SEO score of 70, and their average citation score is 28.
The average Google rating across 233 rated insurance agents is 4.7, and the median listing has 25 reviews.
None of the 253 insurance agents has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 27, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best insurance agent in Ohio? BizScoreAI scores 253 Insurance Agent listings across Ohio on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Ohio Insurance Agent listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my insurance agent listing in Ohio?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every insurance agent listing in Ohio is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.