Evarts Tremaine

Evarts Tremaine is an Insurance Agent in Cleveland, OH. As an independent, specialty agency, it provides business insurance, employee benefits, and personal insurance solutions. The agency serves clients across the United States, holding licenses in all 50 states, while maintaining a local presence in Cleveland and Ohio. Specific offerings include commercial property insurance, general liability, group health, disability, and life insurance, as well as specialty coverage for industries such as manufacturers, breweries, and dealerships. Personal lines include private client insurance, classic car coverage, yacht insurance, and valuable possessions protection. The agency holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews.

Founded in 1844 by Henry F. Brayton as the Henry F. Brayton Company, the agency has operated for over 170 years. It was one of the six founding members of the Insurance Board of Cleveland, now known as the Insurance Board of Northern Ohio. The firm’s history parallels Cleveland’s development from a frontier outpost to an industrial powerhouse, beginning with insurance for manufacturers during the Industrial Revolution. Today, the agency serves approximately 3,700 clients with a 96 percent renewal rate and an average client retention period of 14 years. Current leadership includes John J. Hannon as President and CEO, with part owners Marty Striegl, Todd Mazur, and Brian Boland. The agency offers a 24/7 client center for reporting claims, requesting policy changes, and managing accounts.

The office is located at 1111 Superior Avenue, Suite 1650. It sits on Superior Avenue, just steps from Superior Hill Park and the Settlers Landing train station. Detroit Avenue is also nearby, along with Settler's Landing Park and Canal Basin Park.

Evarts Tremaine is recognized for its long-standing reputation and positive customer feedback. Its standing as the oldest independent insurance agency in Cleveland reflects a sustained focus on risk management and personalized advice. The agency’s depth of experience in both commercial and personal lines makes it a distinct choice for those seeking tailored coverage in the region.

Services:

• Commercial Insurance
• Customized Insurance Plans
• Private Client Insurance
• Risk Management Consulting
• Specialty Business Insurance