Humphrey Insurance Agency

Humphrey Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Ashtabula, OH. The agency provides auto, home, business, RV, boat and motorcycle insurance, helping individuals, families and local businesses compare options and receive free quotes. With a 4.90 rating, the team draws on decades of experience to serve customers throughout Ashtabula and the surrounding area, offering personalized coverage that fits each client’s unique needs.

Founded in 1935 by Ralph L. Humphrey and later carried forward by his son, the agency has maintained a reputation for dependable coverage and friendly, personalized service. Under the ownership of President Tony Cusati, the firm continues that tradition with a high‑quality team that includes manager Stephanie Carroll, who brings more than 30 years of industry expertise, and several agents specializing in commercial lines and other niches. The agency emphasizes attentive service, thoughtful guidance and a genuine commitment to protecting what matters most, while also supporting community initiatives such as the Ashtabula Dream Center and publishing a monthly magazine with tips and stories for local residents.

Clients benefit from clear, accurate information about policy options and discounts, reflecting the agency’s commitment to thorough, well‑documented communications. This transparency makes it easy for customers to understand their coverage and feel confident in their choices.

By blending a long‑standing local presence with a focus on reliable, easy‑to‑access information, Humphrey Insurance Agency stands out as a trusted source of comprehensive insurance solutions for the Ashtabula community.

Services:

• Auto Insurance
• Business Insurance
• Commercial Property Insurance
• Home Insurance
• Personal Insurance