Big Jim's Pizzeria

Big Jim's Pizzeria is a pizza place in New Milford, NJ, serving classic New Jersey-style pies, hearty pasta dishes, and other Italian-American favorites to locals and visitors across Bergen County. Located at 281 Main St, the restaurant has been a neighborhood staple for over 50 years, known for its family-owned tradition, fresh ingredients, and friendly service. Customers can enjoy pizza by the slice or order online for pickup or delivery, with options including cheese, Sicilian, calzones, stromboli, and a variety of appetizers like garlic knots, chicken fingers, and zucchini sticks. The pizzeria serves areas including Oradell, Dumont, Haworth, River Edge, Paramus, and Tenafly, with a customer rating of 3.70 based on reviews.

For over five decades, Big Jim's Pizzeria has built its reputation on consistent quality and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests frequently praise the freshness of each order and the simplicity and soulfulness of the plain cheese pie, a longtime favorite. The menu features handcrafted items made to order, with special requests like an extra crispy crust accommodated upon request. The restaurant remains a trusted choice for families, students, and locals who value dependable, homemade-style food in a familiar setting.

The pizzeria sits on Main Street in New Milford, about a quarter mile from Bertram F Gibbs Elementary School and New Milford High School, and just under a half mile from Madison Avenue and River Road. It is located approximately 0.6 miles from Van Buskirk Island County Park and 0.5 miles from the Hackensack River, making it accessible to residents across the region.

Big Jim's Pizzeria stands as a longstanding fixture in the community, recognized for its enduring presence and consistent delivery of classic, homemade Italian-American fare. With a loyal following and a menu rooted in tradition, it remains a go-to destination for those seeking reliable, flavorful pizza and comfort food in New Milford.