Best Thrift Store in Wisconsin
Top Thrift Store Listings in Wisconsin
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-29 of 29 Thrift Store listings in Wisconsin · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Greendale, Wisconsin
- (414) 304-1262
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Hartford, Wisconsin
- (262) 832-3220
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- New Berlin, Wisconsin
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Stevens Point, Wisconsin
- (715) 204-1604
- antiqueup.com
Antique Up is a Thrift Store in Stevens Point, WI. They feature over 100 vendor booths across their locations in Stevens Point and Kimberly, offering a wide range of items including antiques, knick-knacks, custom signs, woodworking pieces, natural goods...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Green Bay, Wisconsin
- (920) 544-5849
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Green Bay is a Thrift Store in Green Bay, WI, located at 2269 True Ln. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The shop is part of AbleLight, a national organization providing life-changing services for adults with...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menasha, Wisconsin
- (920) 725-7467
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Menasha is a thrift store in Menasha, WI. The shop offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and other donated goods, with all proceeds directed to support AbleLight’s programs for adults with intellectual and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Wausau, Wisconsin
- (715) 845-1878
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Wausau is a thrift store in Wausau, WI, located at 1300 W Campus Dr. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on 11 reviews. The shop is part of AbleLight, a national organization that provides life-changing services for people with...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Plover, Wisconsin
- (715) 544-6637
- goodwillncw.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menasha, Wisconsin
- (920) 731-7834
- communityclothescloset.org
Community Clothes Closet Inc is a thrift store in Menasha, WI, located at 1465 Opportunity Way # B. The organization provides free clothing, outerwear, footwear, accessories, towels, and bedding to people in need across Northeastern Wisconsin and beyond...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Monona, Wisconsin
- (608) 661-2813
- habitatdane.org
Habitat ReStore - East is a Thrift Store in Monona, WI, located at 4207 Monona Dr. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The store is part of Habitat for Humanity of Dane County, a nonprofit that builds affordable housing and supports...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Rice Lake, Wisconsin
- (715) 651-1388
- courtjthrifts.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Franklin, Wisconsin
- (414) 304-1262
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin
- (262) 554-8522
- goodwillnynj.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Milwaukee, Wisconsin
- (414) 465-8197
- plume.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 245-6294
- calvarycommunity.net
Clothing Outreach Center is a thrift store in Elkhorn, WI. The center provides free clothes to people of all ages who are on public assistance programs such as Forward, Quest, or Medicaid. They also accept written referrals and vouchers from local churches...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Weston, Wisconsin
- (715) 848-5042
- habitatwausau.org
Habitat for Humanity of Wausau, Inc. is a Thrift Store in Weston, WI. Located at 1810 Schofield Ave, the ReStore sells new and gently used items for the home, including construction supplies, wood furniture, appliances, and tools. Proceeds from the ReStore...
#17Simply Savvy
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Middleton, Wisconsin
- (608) 819-8933
- simplysavvyconsign.com
Simply Savvy is a thrift store in Middleton, WI, operating as a consignment shop that recirculates pre-owned furniture, home decor, housewares, rugs, lighting, and clothing. Shoppers can browse by category, including women's and men's clothing, accessories...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Eau Claire, Wisconsin
- (715) 835-8500
- savers.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menomonie, Wisconsin
- barbalynnsvintage.com
BarbaLynn's Vintage is a thrift store in Menomonie, Wisconsin, offering curated vintage clothing, accessories, and antiques. The store specializes in sustainable fashion, providing affordable, unique finds for customers who value style and environmental...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- La Crosse, Wisconsin
- (608) 452-4707
- harvestlanetreasures.com
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Fitchburg, Wisconsin
- (608) 709-1275
- giveshelter.org
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Port Washington, Wisconsin
- (262) 268-6953
- hiddentreasureresaleshop.com
Hidden Treasure Resale Shop is a thrift store in Port Washington, WI. The shop provides quality and affordable merchandise to local families, offering a rotating selection of clothing, jewelry, household goods, decor, toys, and books. The business maintains a...
- Thrift Store
- Middleton, Wisconsin
- (608) 833-1633
- regalfind.com
- Thrift Store
- Milwaukee, Wisconsin
- (414) 273-1797
- retique.com
- Thrift Store
- Marshfield, Wisconsin
- (715) 387-1300
- goodwillnynj.org
- Thrift Store
- Cedarburg, Wisconsin
- (262) 377-5509
- goodwillnynj.org
- Thrift Store
- Oak Creek, Wisconsin
- (414) 563-0134
- goodwillnynj.org
- Thrift Store
- Brookfield, Wisconsin
- (262) 784-2650
- brookfieldwi.clothesmentor.com
- Thrift Store
- Mequon, Wisconsin
- (262) 236-9083
- showcaseconsigndesign.com
Recently Updated Thrift Store in Wisconsin
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Wausau, Wisconsin
- (715) 845-1878
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Wausau is a thrift store in Wausau, WI, located at 1300 W Campus Dr. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on 11 reviews. The shop is part of AbleLight, a national organization that provides life-changing services for people with...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Green Bay, Wisconsin
- (920) 544-5849
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Green Bay is a Thrift Store in Green Bay, WI, located at 2269 True Ln. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The shop is part of AbleLight, a national organization providing life-changing services for adults with...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menasha, Wisconsin
- (920) 725-7467
- ablelight.org
AbleLight Thrift Shop of Menasha is a thrift store in Menasha, WI. The shop offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and other donated goods, with all proceeds directed to support AbleLight’s programs for adults with intellectual and...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menasha, Wisconsin
- (920) 731-7834
- communityclothescloset.org
Community Clothes Closet Inc is a thrift store in Menasha, WI, located at 1465 Opportunity Way # B. The organization provides free clothing, outerwear, footwear, accessories, towels, and bedding to people in need across Northeastern Wisconsin and beyond...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Monona, Wisconsin
- (608) 661-2813
- habitatdane.org
Habitat ReStore - East is a Thrift Store in Monona, WI, located at 4207 Monona Dr. It holds a rating of 4.30 based on customer reviews. The store is part of Habitat for Humanity of Dane County, a nonprofit that builds affordable housing and supports...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Weston, Wisconsin
- (715) 848-5042
- habitatwausau.org
Habitat for Humanity of Wausau, Inc. is a Thrift Store in Weston, WI. Located at 1810 Schofield Ave, the ReStore sells new and gently used items for the home, including construction supplies, wood furniture, appliances, and tools. Proceeds from the ReStore...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Middleton, Wisconsin
- (608) 819-8933
- simplysavvyconsign.com
Simply Savvy is a thrift store in Middleton, WI, operating as a consignment shop that recirculates pre-owned furniture, home decor, housewares, rugs, lighting, and clothing. Shoppers can browse by category, including women's and men's clothing, accessories...
Score breakdown
- Thrift Store
- Menomonie, Wisconsin
- barbalynnsvintage.com
BarbaLynn's Vintage is a thrift store in Menomonie, Wisconsin, offering curated vintage clothing, accessories, and antiques. The store specializes in sustainable fashion, providing affordable, unique finds for customers who value style and environmental...
What the Data Shows for Thrift Stores in Wisconsin
18% of the 22 thrift stores we measured in Wisconsin reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 36, compared with an average SEO score of 73.
The average Google rating across 29 rated thrift stores is 4.3.
None of the 29 thrift stores has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 12, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best thrift store in Wisconsin? BizScoreAI scores 29 Thrift Store listings across Wisconsin on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Wisconsin Thrift Store listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my thrift store listing in Wisconsin?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every thrift store listing in Wisconsin is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
