Best Pawn Shop in Wisconsin
Top Pawn Shop Listings in Wisconsin
Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business
Showing 1-26 of 26 Pawn Shop listings in Wisconsin · page 1 of 1
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Grafton, Wisconsin
- (262) 377-5509
- goodwill.org
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Reedsburg, Wisconsin
- (608) 495-0789
- threemountaingames.com
Three Mountain Games is a pawn shop in Reedsburg, WI. The store offers a wide range of board games, including Magic: The Gathering cards, role‑playing games such as Dungeons & Dragons, and family‑friendly titles. It also hosts regular game nights and special...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Plover, Wisconsin
- (715) 997-9559
- ewayspawn.com
E-WAYS SALES & PAWN of Stevens Point is a pawn shop in Plover, WI. The business provides a variety of services including buying, selling, and pawning items such as electronics, jewelry, tools, and collectibles. They also specialize in purchasing and selling...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- West Allis, Wisconsin
- (414) 433-4993
- paymore.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 723-8177
- circleoffriendsmission.com
Circle Of Friends is a pawn shop in Elkhorn, WI. This not-for-profit thrift store serves families in need throughout Walworth County, providing affordable, quality items to the community. As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, this volunteer-run organization has been...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 248-8494
- lakegenevaantiquemall.net
Lake Geneva Antique Mall is a pawn shop in Elkhorn, Wisconsin, offering a wide selection of antiques and vintage items that are 50 years or older. Located at 829 Williams St, the mall serves customers seeking unique furniture, glassware, jewelry, home decor...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Caledonia, Wisconsin
- (414) 327-1825
- pawnamerica.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Hartford, Wisconsin
- (414) 644-5761
- pawnamerica.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Little Chute, Wisconsin
- (920) 733-2007
- pawnamerica.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Monona, Wisconsin
- (608) 241-7006
- pawnamerica.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Superior, Wisconsin
- (715) 394-4982
- superiorshooterssupply.com
Superior Shooters Supply is a pawn shop in Superior, Wisconsin. Serving the local community and those neighboring Duluth, Minnesota, the shop provides a wide selection of new and used firearms, ammunition, and shooting accessories. The business caters to...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Hartford, Wisconsin
- (262) 457-2457
- furnishtraders.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Oconomowoc, Wisconsin
- (262) 200-2535
- barnesdiamonds.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Kenosha, Wisconsin
- (262) 653-9200
- gntjewelryandloan.com
GNT Jewelry and Loan Kenosha Pawnshop is a pawn shop in Kenosha, Wisconsin, serving residents with secure, transparent transactions for jewelry, electronics, tools, watches, shoes, and collectibles. Specializing in pawn loans, cash advances, and the purchase...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (414) 525-0820
- elkhornantiquefleamarket.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Oregon, Wisconsin
- (608) 835-3825
- maxcreekoutdoors.com
Max Creek Outdoors is a Pawn Shop in Oregon, WI. They specialize in purchasing and consigning firearms, ammunition, silencers, gun safes, and facilitating FFL transfers. Additionally, they offer an indoor gun range where visitors can use rental guns. The shop...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin
- (262) 654-4990
- superiorgoldexpress.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 724-0407
- elkhorngunbarrel.com
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin
- (262) 293-3990
- benedons.com
Benedon's Inc of Menomonee Falls: Benedon's Inc is a Pawn Shop in Menomonee Falls, WI. Specializing in Gold, Silver, Diamonds, and Music equipment, Benedon's offers wholesale jewelry prices and expert guidance for investors looking to buy or sell during the current market highs. The...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Greenfield, Wisconsin
- (414) 276-7296
- steinsjewelryandloan.com
- Pawn Shop
- Mukwonago, Wisconsin
- (262) 409-5003
- second-amendment-armament.com
- Pawn Shop
- Oregon, Wisconsin
- (608) 835-5288
- peacefulheart.net
- Pawn Shop
- Shorewood, Wisconsin
- (414) 961-0999
- shorewoodcoinshop.com
- Pawn Shop
- Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin
- (262) 583-0025
- goldprice.org
- Pawn Shop
- Watertown, Wisconsin
- (920) 245-3515
- watertowngold.com
- Pawn Shop
- Hudson, Wisconsin
- (866) 768-5047
- preferredcoinexchange.com
Recently Updated Pawn Shop in Wisconsin
Business profiles with freshly refreshed About sections.
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Reedsburg, Wisconsin
- (608) 495-0789
- threemountaingames.com
Three Mountain Games is a pawn shop in Reedsburg, WI. The store offers a wide range of board games, including Magic: The Gathering cards, role‑playing games such as Dungeons & Dragons, and family‑friendly titles. It also hosts regular game nights and special...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Plover, Wisconsin
- (715) 997-9559
- ewayspawn.com
E-WAYS SALES & PAWN of Stevens Point is a pawn shop in Plover, WI. The business provides a variety of services including buying, selling, and pawning items such as electronics, jewelry, tools, and collectibles. They also specialize in purchasing and selling...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 723-8177
- circleoffriendsmission.com
Circle Of Friends is a pawn shop in Elkhorn, WI. This not-for-profit thrift store serves families in need throughout Walworth County, providing affordable, quality items to the community. As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, this volunteer-run organization has been...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Elkhorn, Wisconsin
- (262) 248-8494
- lakegenevaantiquemall.net
Lake Geneva Antique Mall is a pawn shop in Elkhorn, Wisconsin, offering a wide selection of antiques and vintage items that are 50 years or older. Located at 829 Williams St, the mall serves customers seeking unique furniture, glassware, jewelry, home decor...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Superior, Wisconsin
- (715) 394-4982
- superiorshooterssupply.com
Superior Shooters Supply is a pawn shop in Superior, Wisconsin. Serving the local community and those neighboring Duluth, Minnesota, the shop provides a wide selection of new and used firearms, ammunition, and shooting accessories. The business caters to...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Kenosha, Wisconsin
- (262) 653-9200
- gntjewelryandloan.com
GNT Jewelry and Loan Kenosha Pawnshop is a pawn shop in Kenosha, Wisconsin, serving residents with secure, transparent transactions for jewelry, electronics, tools, watches, shoes, and collectibles. Specializing in pawn loans, cash advances, and the purchase...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Oregon, Wisconsin
- (608) 835-3825
- maxcreekoutdoors.com
Max Creek Outdoors is a Pawn Shop in Oregon, WI. They specialize in purchasing and consigning firearms, ammunition, silencers, gun safes, and facilitating FFL transfers. Additionally, they offer an indoor gun range where visitors can use rental guns. The shop...
Score breakdown
- Pawn Shop
- Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin
- (262) 293-3990
- benedons.com
Benedon's Inc of Menomonee Falls: Benedon's Inc is a Pawn Shop in Menomonee Falls, WI. Specializing in Gold, Silver, Diamonds, and Music equipment, Benedon's offers wholesale jewelry prices and expert guidance for investors looking to buy or sell during the current market highs. The...
What the Data Shows for Pawn Shops in Wisconsin
30% of the 20 pawn shops we measured in Wisconsin reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 39, compared with an average SEO score of 71.
The average Google rating across 26 rated pawn shops is 4.5.
None of the 26 pawn shops has been claimed by its owner yet.
Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 27, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.
Looking for the best pawn shop in Wisconsin? BizScoreAI scores 26 Pawn Shop listings across Wisconsin on online visibility, AI-search presence, reviews and profile completeness so you can compare at a glance. Open any profile for its full BizScore breakdown - and if it is your business, claim your free listing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are Wisconsin Pawn Shop listings ordered on BizScoreAI?
Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, citation presence and profile completeness.
How do I claim my pawn shop listing in Wisconsin?
Open its profile and select claim - it is free, and lets you correct details and improve your search and AI visibility.
Is being listed free?
Yes. Every pawn shop listing in Wisconsin is listed and scored for free, and claiming is free too.
