Old Bay Insurance Agency of Arnold

Old Bay Insurance Agency of Arnold is an independent insurance agent serving clients in Arnold, Maryland, and the surrounding areas. The agency provides personal and business insurance solutions, including auto, home, general liability, business owners, and specialized coverage for contractors, landlords, and landscaping services. With a focus on personalized service, the agency helps clients navigate insurance needs with professionalism, fair pricing, and access to financially strong carriers. Serving Greater Anne Arundel County and Queen Anne’s County, the agency has earned a 5.00 rating from its clients, reflecting strong satisfaction and trust.

The agency was founded and is led by Neal Tatterson, who brings decades of combined insurance experience to the team. As independent brokers, the agency prioritizes client needs, offering tailored coverage options without the constraints of a single carrier. Their approach emphasizes building long-term relationships, ensuring clients receive clear guidance and support through policy selection, claims, and changes. The team includes licensed agents who provide in-person and remote assistance, with services available in both English and Spanish.

Located at 133 Defense Hwy in Annapolis, the agency operates from Suite 214, situated along a major regional roadway. The location is part of a commercial corridor that serves the broader Annapolis area, making it accessible to residents and businesses across the county. While no specific nearby landmarks are listed, the address is positioned within a well-traveled section of the city’s transportation network.

Old Bay Insurance Agency has been serving the region for 30 years, a testament to its reliability and client-focused model. The agency is recognized for its commitment to transparency, affordability, and personalized attention, making it a trusted choice for individuals and small businesses in the Annapolis area. Its consistent five-star rating underscores its reputation for dependable service and client satisfaction.