Goodnight Fatty

Goodnight Fatty is a Bakery in Salem, MA, located at 1 Washington Square. The shop serves as a dessert destination for locals from the Northshore and visitors exploring Salem, offering warm, fresh-out-of-the-oven cookies known as Fatties, house-made soft serve, and seasonal specialties. With a 4.80 rating based on customer reviews, the bakery is known for its rotating weekly cookie lineup, weekend breakfast items called Chubbies, and late-night dessert options. It caters to couples, families, and those seeking kid-friendly treats or a stop on a Salem itinerary.

Operating out of the historic Andrew-Safford Carriage House on the Peabody Essex Museum campus, Goodnight Fatty celebrates a decade of business with a menu that changes each weekend. The shop features three different Fatties each night, with the lineup revealed only at the time of ordering to maintain an element of mystery. Customers can follow the shop’s social media for hints about the current flavors. In addition to cookies, the menu includes house-made soft serve, with a vegan chocolate option made from coconut yogurt that is always available. The first weekend of every month, the shop also serves a vegan Fatty.

For breakfast, Goodnight Fatty offers Spicy Chubbies, described as one-handed pockets of breakfast extravaganza, available every Sunday from 8am to 2pm. These are vegan and distinct from the sweet cookies. The shop provides in-house delivery, called Drops, for Fatties across Salem and surrounding cities on select nights, and for Sunday morning Chubby Drops in Salem only. Physical and e-gift cards are available for in-store use. The business does not ship products but accepts catering inquiries for large orders and events.

Goodnight Fatty holds a positive rating from the customers who have reviewed it, reflecting its reputation as a cult-favorite dessert shop. It stands out in Salem for its unique approach to cookies, combining mystery with consistent quality over ten years. The business is recognized for its specific offerings like the rotating Fatties and the vegan options, which appeal to a diverse range of dietary preferences.

Goodnight Fatty brings its award-winning, warm cookies and unique breakfast items to the heart of Salem, making it a must-visit spot for anyone in the area looking for a distinctive dessert experience.

The bakery sits on Washington Square, just steps from the Roger Conant Statue and the Salem Witch Museum.

BizScoreAI gave the bakery a Schema and Structure score of 100 out of 100, which helps AI assistants and search engines understand what the business offers. The Technical score is 86 out of 100, ensuring the website is secure and readable for search engines.