Home › Business Search › Florida › Tallahassee › Insurance Agent

Best Insurance Agents in Tallahassee, Florida

9 businesses
Filters
Business type
Location
9 listings
Clear all
Florida×Tallahassee×Insurance Agent×Clear All

Claimed listings first, then by BizScore. How we score

9Insurance Agents scored in Tallahassee
54Average BizScore
66Top BizScore
25%AI Visibility 50 or higher
72Average SEO score
4.8Average Google rating (9 rated)

Top Insurance Agents in Tallahassee

Claimed businesses are listed first. Claiming is free, and it moves your listing ahead of every unclaimed business here, even ones with a higher BizScore. Claim your business

Showing 1-9 of 9 Insurance Agents listings in Tallahassee, FL · page 1 of 1

#1Acceptance Insurance of Tallahassee

4.9 Google rating · 439 reviews

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Acceptance Insurance of Tallahassee website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility54
AI Ready55
SEO72
Freshness100
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 204-4051
  • acceptance.com
Category rank by BizScore: #2 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Oct 28, 2026

#2Alliance Insurance

4.9 Google rating

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Alliance Insurance website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility54
AI Ready7
SEO74
Freshness100
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 878-9664
  • downtownbelair.com
Category rank by BizScore: #3 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Oct 26, 2026

#3Direct Auto Insurance of Tallahassee

4.6 Google rating · 164 reviews

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
D

Score breakdown

AI Visibility49
AI Ready11
SEO77
Freshness-
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 222-5964
  • directv.com

Direct Auto Insurance of Tallahassee: Direct Auto Insurance is an insurance agent in Tallahassee, FL. The business maintains a 4.60 rating based on 164 reviews. Direct Auto Insurance is located on W Tennessee St, a short walk from the Claude Pepper Library, the Warren D. Allen Music Library, and...

Category rank by BizScore: #6 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Oct 28, 2026

#4Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services

4.9 Google rating · 1,263 reviews

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility40
AI Ready10
SEO75
Freshness60
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 412-1099
  • waterhousebrands.com
Category rank by BizScore: #4 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Oct 24, 2026

#5McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency

5.0 Google rating · 1,232 reviews

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility29
AI Ready2
SEO75
Freshness15
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 329-6996
  • music-ladder.com
Category rank by BizScore: #10 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Oct 28, 2026

#6Fuqua Insurance Agency

4.9 Google rating

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Fuqua Insurance Agency website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility23
AI Ready-
SEO77
Freshness-
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 386-2300
  • fuquainsurance.com

Fuqua Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Tallahassee, Florida, providing personalized coverage for auto, home, life, farm, business, and umbrella insurance needs. Serving individuals and families across the region, the agency specializes in tailoring...

Category rank by BizScore: #11 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Jun 29, 2026

#7Quick Insurance of Tallahassee

5.0 Google rating

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Q

Score breakdown

AI Visibility26
AI Ready-
SEO63
Freshness-
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 296-9376
  • quickbooks.intuit.com

Quick Insurance of Tallahassee: Quick Insurance is an insurance agent in Tallahassee, FL, serving individuals and small businesses with personalized coverage solutions. The company specializes in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, helping clients protect their assets and plan for...

Category rank by BizScore: #12 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#8Assurance Low-Cost Car Insurance

4.5 Google rating

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Assurance Low-Cost Car Insurance website

Score breakdown

AI Visibility7
AI Ready-
SEO62
Freshness-
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (561) 783-3303
  • assuranceinsurance.com
Category rank by BizScore: #14 of 14 Insurance Agent listings in TallahasseeScores updated Jun 7, 2026

#9Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee

4.5 Google rating · 120 reviews

View ListingVisit WebsiteCallClaim This BusinessFree. Claimed listings rank first.
Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee website
  • Insurance Agent
  • Tallahassee, Florida
  • (850) 224-6250
  • qualityinsuranceinc.com

Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee: ASQ - Excellence Through Quality offers comprehensive resources and certifications for professionals aiming to enhance their expertise in quality management. From individual memberships to corporate training, ASQ supports organizations in achieving excellence...

Is this your business? Claim your free listing →

What the Data Shows for Insurance Agents in Tallahassee

25% of the 8 insurance agents we measured in Tallahassee reach an AI Visibility score of 50 or higher. Their average AI Visibility score is 35, compared with an average SEO score of 72.

The average Google rating across 9 rated insurance agents is 4.8, and the median listing has 439 reviews.

None of the 9 insurance agents has been claimed by its owner yet.

Figures from BizScoreAI's stored scans, latest score update Oct 28, 2026. What each score measures: How We Score.

BizScoreAI compares 9 insurance agents in Tallahassee, Florida by BizScore, a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness. Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. Open any profile for its full breakdown, and claim your free listing if it is your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are insurance agents in Tallahassee ordered on BizScoreAI?

Claimed listings appear before unclaimed listings, and within each group businesses are ordered by BizScore. Claiming a listing is free, and paid plans and Featured listings do not change this order. BizScore is a measured composite of AI-search visibility, traditional SEO, local citations, local search pages and profile completeness; the How We Score page explains what each part measures.

How many insurance agents in Tallahassee, Florida does BizScoreAI track?

9 insurance agents in Tallahassee currently meet the profile-quality bar for this page, with an average BizScore of 54 and a top score of 66.

What does AI Visibility mean for a insurance agent?

It measures whether AI assistants and AI-powered search can find, read and cite the business's website: structured data, crawlability, clear entity information and content that answers questions. 25% of measured insurance agents in Tallahassee score 50 or higher.

Is being listed free?

Yes. Every insurance agent in Tallahassee is listed and scored for free, and claiming a listing is free too.