Craig's Cake Shop

Craig's Cake Shop is a bakery in Verona, WI, located at 604 W Verona Ave. It holds a rating of 4.70 based on customer reviews.

Founded in 2000, Craig’s Cake Shop is a commercially licensed bakery that has served the Madison area for more than 20 years. In 2018, new owners Elisa and Andy Romanowich took over to preserve the shop’s longstanding traditions while introducing modern options. The team creates custom cakes, mini cakes, cupcakes, and other desserts by hand. They are known for their signature frosting and time-tested recipes, using only buttercream frosting for all cake designs rather than fondant. The shop offers grab-and-go items such as 4-inch mini cakes, frosted cupcakes, and cake push-up pops for same-day pickup. Customers can also order custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and other celebrations, with delivery available within about one hour of the Madison area.

The bakery operates from Tuesday through Friday from 10 am to 6 pm and on Saturday from 9 am to 12 pm, remaining closed on Sundays and Mondays. Customers are asked to provide at least one week’s notice for hand-baked custom desserts. The shop also sells e-gift cards and offers pickup options for larger tiered cakes. Craig’s Cake Shop is not an allergen-free environment and uses dairy, soy, peanut butter, eggs, gluten, and coconut oil in their products.

Craig’s Cake Shop maintains a positive rating from the customers who have reviewed it.

Craig’s Cake Shop brings its hand-baked buttercream desserts to Verona, WI.

The bakery sits on W Verona Ave, just a short walk from West Verona Avenue and within half a mile of Thompson Park.

BizScoreAI gives the site a Technical score of 94 out of 100, ensuring the website is secure and easy for search engines to read. It also awards a Content Quality score of 75 out of 100, which helps the business in answers from AI assistants.