Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Erie, PA, serving residents and businesses with personal and commercial insurance solutions. The agency offers auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, life and health insurance, and financial and investment guidance. With nearly 70 years of operation since its founding in 1955, it has grown from a side venture of a high school teacher into a multi-office agency focused on tailored coverage and client relationships. It maintains a strong presence in Erie and surrounding communities, providing personalized service through a network of top-rated insurance carriers.

The agency traces its origins to 1955, when founder Chuck Pfeffer began assisting local families with insurance needs while working as a history teacher and track coach. His client-focused approach led to the formal establishment of the agency. After decades of growth, Chuck’s son Doug Pfeffer took over the business, later hiring Alan Hilling, who joined in 1990 and became owner in 2018. Under Alan’s leadership, the agency continues to serve the Erie area with a commitment to community, relationships, and better service.

Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance is located at 332 Holland St in Erie, PA, just a short distance from several notable landmarks. The agency sits about 0.1 miles from the UPMC Outpatient Center, Nate Levy Park, Erie Insurance Park, Brewster House, and Kennedy Row Houses. It is also approximately 0.2 miles from the ExpERIEnce Childrens Museum.

The agency is known for its long-standing presence in the community, its independent brokerage model, and its focus on personalized service. It has built a reputation for helping clients secure tailored coverage through relationships with top-rated carriers, offering comprehensive solutions across personal and business insurance needs.