Yesterday's Treasures

Yesterday's Treasures is a thrift store in Fenton, Michigan, specializing in antiques, vintage items, and collectibles. Owned and operated by mother-daughter team Sue Olson and Stacy Mielcarek, the store offers knowledgeable service and a diverse selection of merchandise including jewelry, furniture, china, pottery, glassware, lighting, and architectural hardware. Customers come from afar to shop, drawn by the store’s steady turnover of inventory and curated collections. The store has served the community since 1998 and maintains a strong reputation, reflected in its 4.40 rating and positive customer reviews.

The store emphasizes personal expertise, with Sue and Stacy providing insight into the history and value of items such as antique jewelry and architectural details. They feature a rotating selection of vintage and antique goods, including rare pieces like brass doorknobs and stained glass, with new arrivals regularly added. The store’s approach centers on community engagement, offering a welcoming space where customers can explore unique finds and learn about their origins.

Located on South Leroy Street in downtown Fenton, Yesterday's Treasures sits just a short walk from Fenton City Hall, the Fenton City Police Department, the A. J. Phillips Museum, the Fenton Post Office, and the Stainless Steel Butterfly public artwork. These landmarks are within a few hundred meters, placing the store in the heart of the city’s historic district.

The store is known for its authentic, well-curated inventory and long-standing presence in the community, making it a trusted destination for collectors and shoppers seeking distinctive vintage and antique items. Its enduring appeal reflects deep roots in Fenton’s cultural and commercial life.