Cookie Time Bakery

Cookie Time Bakery is a bakery in Arlington, MA, located at 1375 Massachusetts Ave. The shop specializes in handmade butter cookies and shortbread treats for any occasion. Owner Barbara Weniger purchased a small wholesale bakery in 1991 and expanded to open the retail store in 1997. The bakery offers a variety of finished cookies as well as custom orders, which require a minimum of one dozen per shape and two weeks’ notice. Customers can choose from shortbread cookies dipped in white or dark chocolate, or sugared cookies in red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple, or pink. The bakery also provides options for specific dietary needs, including cookies made without flour, eggs, dairy, or nuts, though the kitchen is not allergen-free. Payment is required in full at the time of ordering. The store is open Tuesday through Friday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM, with Sundays and Mondays closed.

Barbara Weniger grew up in South Dakota, learning to bake from her mother, and has no formal culinary training but relies on real ingredients, butter, and heart to craft her cookies. The business began as Lakota Cookies, a wholesale operation that grew steadily through word of mouth before the retail location opened. The team takes pride in creating a product that people love, maintaining high quality control across their extensive menu. One customer noted that despite living in Paris, France, they found no shop that could match Cookie Time for cookies, and the treats have been shared in Mexico, Taiwan, Uganda, and across the United States to rave reviews. The bakery also gained recognition for providing a birthday cake for President Obama.

The bakery holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews, reflecting the positive reception from those who have visited. This high rating underscores the consistent quality and dedication of the team to making the best cookies for their Arlington customers.

Cookie Time Bakery’s dedication to handmade butter cookies and shortbread treats makes it a beloved destination for residents in Arlington, MA.

The bakery sits on Massachusetts Avenue, just a short walk from the Arlington Heights Bus Turnaround and Mill Brook.

BizScoreAI gives the business a Content Quality score of 100 out of 100, meaning the website clearly answers customer questions so AI assistants can quote it directly. A Technical score of 97 out of 100 shows the site is secure and readable for search engines.