Old Mill Restaurant of Evansville
Run a free full auditContact Information
-
Address
5031 New Harmony Rd
Evansville, IN 47720 -
Website
oldmillevansville.com
Location
About Old Mill Restaurant of Evansville
Old Mill Restaurant is a catering business in Evansville, IN, located at 5031 New Harmony Rd. It has been serving the Evansville area since 1936, offering family style dinners made from scratch. The dining room seats 400 guests, while a private party room accommodates an additional 300, making it suitable for large gatherings. The establishment offers off-site catering for both food and alcohol, and hosts wedding receptions with a private bar and dance floor.
The menu features family style dinners with a choice of fried chicken, honey roasted ham, or roast beef, served with mashed potatoes, cream gravy, green beans, sweet corn, German cole slaw, and homemade rolls. Other dinner options include a Friday catfish special, a steak special with an 8 oz ribeye, and a Sunday buffet featuring chicken or ham, homemade dumplings, dressing, vegetables, salads, and dessert. The catering menu includes Country Classic packages with sliced meats, potatoes, and relish trays, as well as entrees like roast beef, prime rib, various chicken preparations, lasagna, and manicotti. Desserts range from sheet cakes to apple and cherry cobblers. The restaurant also offers a children's menu, appetizers such as New England clam chowder and shrimp cocktail, and a selection of seafood dishes including shrimp Maui, filet of sole, and red snapper.
The restaurant sits on New Harmony Road, about a half mile from Resurrection Drive and the German Township Fire Department station. It is located roughly 0.8 miles from West Diamond Avenue and about 1.1 miles from Carpentier Creek. Cynthia Heights Elementary and Junior High is approximately 2 miles away.
Old Mill Restaurant holds a rating of 3.00 based on customer reviews. As an Evansville staple since 1936, it provides a long-standing option for family style dining and event catering in the region.
Services:
- Customs Brokerage
- Emergency Medical Services
- Full Truckload (FTL) Freight Shipping
- Intermodal Rail Services
- LTL (Less Than Truckload) Freight Shipping
- Patient Education
- Preventive Health Screenings
- Primary Care
Score Summary
BizScoreAI scanned the website merriam-webster.com on May 13, 2026. Old Mill Restaurant of Evansville has a BizScore of 56 out of 100. The website audit behind the SEO score ran on October 23, 2026.
- AI Visibility50 out of 100
- SEO61 out of 100
- Google rating3.0 out of 5
Website audit sub-scores (out of 100): On-Page 63, Technical 56, Performance 65, Content 59.
Strengths: 3 checks passed. AI-Parseable Headings, AI Crawler Access, About/Team Page.
Areas to improve: 10 checks. FAQPage Schema (failed), Organization Schema (failed), Speakable Schema (failed), BreadcrumbList (warning), AggregateRating (warning), Meta Description (warning), Q&A Content (warning), llms.txt (warning), XML Sitemap (warning), Author Signals (warning).
More Catering in Evansville, Indiana
- Marx Barbecue & CateringBizScore 64
- Old Post Office Event CenterBizScore 56
- Miller's Catering Barbecue WeddingsBizScore 53
- Bedford Collab.BizScore 50
Browse: Businesses in Evansville, IN · Catering in Indiana · Businesses in Indiana
AI engine reads
Read by AI engines 5 times in the last 30 days.
Counted from AI crawler and assistant visits to this page, identified by user agent.
See the full AI visibility report for this businessContact Old Mill Restaurant of Evansville
Ways to improve this score
Run a free full auditWe improve your AI Visibility, SEO, and Local SEO scores as far as your current website allows.
Boost This Listing
Get a gold badge, photo gallery, and more.