Tomco Insurance Agency

Tomco Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Charleston, Illinois, serving individuals and businesses with personalized coverage solutions. As part of First Fed Insurance, the agency offers a range of insurance products including auto, home, life, and business insurance, with a long-standing commitment to customer service. Since its founding in 1977 as Clarence Miller Insurance, Tomco has built a reputation for reliability and local expertise, serving Charleston and surrounding areas for decades. The agency maintains a perfect 5.00 rating based on customer reviews, reflecting strong client satisfaction and trust.

Tomco Insurance Agency is now a part of First Fed Insurance, a subsidiary of First Federal Savings & Loan Association of Central Illinois, which operates offices in Shelbyville, Stewardson, and Charleston. The agency’s history traces back to 1994 with the founding of Killam & Englund Insurance Agency in Shelbyville, which expanded over time before becoming part of First Fed in 2017. In 2025, First Fed Insurance acquired Tomco Insurance Agency, integrating its experienced team and longstanding presence in Charleston into a broader network of service locations across Shelby County.

The agency is located on Lincoln Avenue in Charleston, just a short distance from key local landmarks. It sits about 0.1 miles from 18th Street, within walking distance of the Charleston HS Tennis Courts and the Charleston Rotary Community Aquatic Center, both within a third of a mile. The VFW Park is approximately half a mile away, and Greek Court is about 0.6 miles from the office, placing the agency near several community recreational spaces.

With decades of experience and a perfect customer rating, Tomco Insurance Agency is known for its dependable service and deep roots in the Charleston community. Its integration into First Fed Insurance strengthens its ability to offer comprehensive insurance and financial solutions to residents and businesses throughout the region. As a trusted local provider, Tomco continues to deliver personalized protection and peace of mind to the people of Charleston.