The Village Bake Shoppe

The Village Bake Shoppe is a catering and dessert destination in Lewiston, NY. Specializing in made-from-scratch baked goods, the shop offers wedding cakes crafted to individual design, gift baskets featuring tea breads, cookies, chocolates, and gingerbread men, and full breakfast and lunch service. They also deliver desserts via their signature Cakemobile to offices, restaurants, and events across the region. With a 4.60 rating based on customer reviews, the shop is praised for exceptional food, fast service, and consistently delicious desserts. Their clientele includes local businesses, event planners, and travelers drawn to the historic village.

Located in the heart of historic Lewiston, The Village Bake Shoppe has been serving the community since 1993, founded by mother and daughter Vicki and Tracy J. Marshall. Tracy, an award-winning pastry chef, brought her expertise from Boston College to create a legacy of original recipes and premium ingredients. After Tracy’s passing in 2001, Bridget Schroeder took over, expanding the business to its current location at 417 Center Street. In 2011, Michael Fiore and his family acquired the shop, continuing its tradition of excellence. Over the years, their desserts have been featured at high-profile events, including the grand opening of the Hard Rock Café in Niagara Falls and a custom chicken wing cake for the Anchor Bar Wing Co.

The shop sits on Center Street in Lewiston, NY, within walking distance of the scenic Niagara River waterfront, a natural border between the U.S. and Canada. Its proximity to the river and historic district contributes to its charm and accessibility for both locals and visitors.

The Village Bake Shoppe is recognized for its consistent quality, long-standing reputation, and dedication to craftsmanship. It has been nominated for multiple awards, including Best Bakery, Best Dessert Menu, and Best Wedding Cake in the Buffalo News Best of 716, reflecting its standing as a top-tier dessert destination in Western New York. The shop’s enduring success is rooted in decades of tradition, innovation, and customer loyalty.

Known for its wedding cakes and signature Cakemobile deliveries, The Village Bake Shoppe remains a beloved staple of Lewiston’s culinary scene.