Seibert Insurance Agency

Seibert Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agent in Tampa, FL, serving both individual and commercial clients. The agency provides personal, business, and life insurance coverage, including policies for personal cars, homes, rental properties, business autos, business property, and business liability. It also offers specialized commercial products such as Employment Practices Liability Insurance, which protects companies, directors, officers, and employees against claims related to discrimination, sexual harassment, wrongful termination, and breach of employment contracts. The agency has served the Tampa community since 1971, holding a perfect 5.00 rating from its customers.

The team consists of professionals with more than 150 years of combined experience, advising over 10,000 individuals and 1,000 businesses. Karyn Seibert Roeling, who joined the agency in 2005, serves as President and holds the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter designation. She is an active member of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, currently serving as Chair Elect. The leadership team includes Candice Brantley, COO, and Natalie Serpe, Operations Analyst, alongside commercial insurance consultants Maria Shaw and Hunter Blair. The agency was founded by Keith Seibert, who began his career at Nationwide Insurance and became a top 10 commercial agent for the carrier before retiring in 2012. The agency’s approach emphasizes integrity, quality, and responsiveness, with agents taking time to learn specific client needs and walk through coverage options without pressure.

Located at 5121 Ehrlich Road, Suite 111, the office sits on Ehrlich Road, about a quarter-mile from Ben Hill Middle School and Country Place Fire Department Station 42. It is also within a mile of Claywell Elementary School, Country Lake Park, and Avista Park.

Seibert Insurance Agency stands out in Tampa for its long-standing local presence and high customer satisfaction. The agency’s reputation is built on decades of experience and a focus on tailored insurance solutions for families and businesses in the region.

Services:

• Business Owners Policy
• Commercial Insurance
• General Liability
• Personal Insurance
• Workers Compensation