Run a free full auditOldest City Insurance is an insurance agent in St. Augustine, Florida. The agency specializes in providing auto, home, business, flood, RV, boat, and motorcycle insurance to local residents and business owners. With a 4.90 rating, the agency focuses on helping clients navigate the complexities of coverage while seeking ways to save time and money.
The agency has been protecting families in Florida since 1983. To provide comprehensive options, they partner with 15 top-rated insurers, including multiple companies rated "A" or better, allowing them to shop for the best rates and coverage on behalf of their clients. Their services include identifying eligible discounts for homeowners and helping business owners mitigate risks related to property damage, bodily injury, and personal injury. Additionally, they assist clients with flood insurance by identifying specific flood zones and providing alternatives to the National Flood Insurance Program.
Located on San Marco Avenue in the heart of St. Augustine, the office is situated near the Saint Johns County Public Library Main Branch and Davenport Park. The business is also a short drive from North Ponce de Leon Boulevard and May Street.
Oldest City Insurance is recognized for its commitment to providing well-documented and accessible information to help clients make informed decisions. Their reputation is built on their ability to leverage a multitude of companies to ensure quality resources and the best possible premiums for the community.
Oldest City Insurance remains a dedicated resource for personalized coverage and professional guidance for the St. Augustine community.
BizScoreAI scanned the website oldestcityinsurance.com on June 29, 2026. Oldest City Insurance has a BizScore of 59 out of 100. The website audit behind the SEO score ran on October 28, 2026.
AI visibility scan by category: AI Discovery 10 of 25 points, Structured Data 8 of 25 points, Content Readiness 12 of 30 points, AI Trust Signals 12 of 20 points.
Website audit sub-scores (out of 100): On-Page 67, Technical 96, Performance 76, Content 60.
Strengths: 6 checks passed. AI Crawler Access, AI Content Blocking, Organization Schema, Meta Description, About/Team Page, XML Sitemap.
Areas to improve: 6 checks. llms.txt (failed), FAQPage Schema (failed), Speakable Schema (warning), Q&A Content (warning), AI-Parseable Headings (warning), Author Signals (warning).
Browse: Businesses in St. Augustine, FL · Insurance Agent in Florida · Businesses in Florida
Read by AI engines 5 times in the last 30 days.
Counted from AI crawler and assistant visits to this page, identified by user agent.
See the full AI visibility report for this business