Regan Roth Insurance Agency

Regan Roth Insurance Agency is a family-owned and operated insurance agent in Marathon, Florida, serving residents and businesses across the Florida Keys for over 65 years. The agency specializes in providing comprehensive coverage for homes, autos, boats, jewelry, and commercial properties, with a focus on the unique risks faced by those living and operating in the Keys. Their services are tailored to individual and business needs, offering customized policies designed to address specific exposures. With a 4.90 rating based on customer feedback, the agency is known for delivering personalized, local attention and ongoing support, even after a policy is issued. They serve clients throughout the Florida Keys, with a primary office located at 8065 Overseas Hwy in Marathon.

Founded in 1954 by Carlton Regan, the agency has remained a cornerstone of the Marathon community through multiple generations. In 1958, the business moved to its original office on Plantation Key, and over the decades, it expanded with the involvement of Robert E. Regan, his wife Charlen, and later their children and grandchildren. The agency was rebranded as Regan Roth Insurance in 2019 to honor both the Regan family legacy and the contributions of Joe Roth III and Robert C. Stoky. The fourth generation is now active, with Sara M. Roth, CIC, joining in 2023 after earning degrees in risk management from Florida State University. Jennifer Miller Roth also contributes to daily operations. The team includes seasoned professionals dedicated to understanding the local environment and providing informed, clear guidance on insurance options.

Regan Roth Insurance continues to build on its reputation as a trusted, locally rooted provider with a deep understanding of the region’s weather-related and coastal risks. Their long-standing presence and consistent service reflect a commitment to reliability and community engagement. As a leader in the Florida Keys insurance industry, the agency remains deeply embedded in the lives of those it serves.