Mixed Fillings Pie Shop

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a bakery in Jacksonville, FL, located at 440 W Adams St. It holds a rating of 4.90 based on customer reviews.

The business is family-owned and operated by husband-and-wife team Natasha and Curtis Burton. Chef Natasha is a Le Cordon Bleu graduate and seventh-generation Floridian, while Curtis is a fourth-generation Kansan. They create award-winning scratch-made pies using fresh seasonal ingredients and real butter for traditional, flaky crusts. The menu features sweet and savory options designed for local families and special occasions.

Customers can order pies for delivery, catering, weddings, and gatherings. The shop also offers hands-on baking classes for beginners and seasoned bakers, as well as community events. Pies are made to order, with online pre-orders accepted 24 hours in advance. The cutoff time for next-day pickup is 4 pm. Whole pies are available for walk-in purchase on a first-come, first-served basis at the Riverside Arts Market booth at 715 Riverside Ave on Saturdays from 10 am to 3 pm.

Pre-orders must be picked up between 10 am and 3 pm on the scheduled date. Cancellations or changes to pre-orders require 24 hours notice. Holiday pre-orders are paid in advance and are not refundable. Unpicked pre-orders are donated, and no credits are issued. The shop has been featured in Southern Living and Good Morning America.

The bakery sits on W Adams Street in Jacksonville, FL, just a fraction of a mile from the Duval County Courthouse and West Bay Street.

BizScoreAI gives the business a Performance score of 83 out of 100, which measures how quickly the website loads to keep visitors on the page. The Discoverability score is 75 out of 100, ensuring AI crawlers can find every page so the business can be recommended by AI assistants.