Cry Baby Creamery

Cry Baby Creamery is an ice cream shop in Cutler Bay, FL, located at 17389 S Dixie Hwy. It serves handcrafted ice cream, cookies, desserts, soft serve, milkshakes, and specialty treats to customers in South Florida. The business offers online ordering for pickup and catering. It holds a 4.70 rating.

Since 2021, the team has made every scoop themselves using premium dairy and real ingredients, with mix-ins baked fresh in the kitchen. The creamery opened under Fire Pit Hospitality, the same creative minds behind Lincoln’s Beard, Strange Beast, and Maxwell Bros. The name Cry Baby reflects a deliberate juxtaposition, transforming a term usually seen as negative into something joyful. The brand views a cry baby as someone who feels everything fully, especially the sweetness and excitement of good food.

Every scoop is made right in the kitchen using premium ingredients and real ingredients. The shop partners with Miami’s own Exquisito Chocolates and Per’la Coffee. Nearly all of their mix-ins are baked fresh by their pastry team, with a few classics like Oreos as an exception. Each batch is churned with intention and finished with small details that make the product unmistakably theirs. The team treats ice cream as a craft, ensuring every flavor, swirl, crunch, and ribbon is created by people who care.

The business is recognized for a positive rating from the customers who have reviewed it. This reflects the reputation for quality that comes from their commitment to making ice cream without shortcuts or weird stuff. They stand among the stronger options in their category locally, known for their craft and attention to detail.

Cry Baby Creamery brings its handcrafted, small-batch ice cream to Cutler Bay, offering a unique blend of nostalgic comfort and bold creativity for local dessert lovers.

Cry Baby Creamery sits on S Dixie Hwy in Cutler Bay, FL, just steps from South Dixie Highway. It is located about 0.1 miles from Perrine Seventh Day Adventist School and 0.2 miles from Nicklaus Children's Palmetto Bay Outpatient Center.

BizScoreAI awards the business a Discoverability score of 100 out of 100, which means AI crawlers can find every page of the website so AI assistants can recommend the business. The Technical score is 96 out of 100. The business ranks number 1 of 4 Ice Cream Shop businesses that BizScoreAI has scored in Cutler Bay.