Michael's Dairy

Michael's Dairy is an ice cream shop in New London, CT, serving hand-scooped ice cream with over 35 flavors, along with shakes, sundaes, floats, spritzers, pints, and quarts. For more than 80 years, the shop has brought together the New London community and its visitors, becoming a cherished destination for generations of families and friends. Located at 629 Montauk Ave, it operates daily from 12pm to 9pm between April 1 and October 30. The shop is known for its long-standing tradition, warm customer service, and neighborhood charm. With a 4.70 rating and a strong reputation based on consistent reviews, it remains a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Michael’s Dairy traces its roots to 1938, when the Mitchell family owned the land now home to Mitchell College. Originally part of the Mumford Dairy, the property was acquired by the Buscetto family in 1943 and renamed Michael’s Dairy. Though it began as a milk processing business, the shop began serving ice cream in the 1950s, responding to growing demand for the treat. By the 1970s, it was the last milk processing dairy in New London, ceasing operations in that capacity. In 2006, Mitchell College purchased the property, using proceeds to support student education. The shop continues to operate as a community landmark, preserving its legacy while serving fresh, hand-scooped ice cream.

The shop sits on Montauk Ave, just a short walk from Mitchell College and the Mitchell College Library, both about 0.4 miles away. It is also located approximately 0.3 miles from the Thames Yacht Club and Burr’s Marina, and near Ocean Avenue Learning Academy, all within a half-mile radius. Its location places it at the heart of a vibrant educational and maritime neighborhood.

Michael’s Dairy stands as a deeply rooted institution in New London, known for its enduring presence, quality ice cream, and connection to local history. Its decades-long service, consistent customer experience, and strong community ties make it a standout in the city’s ice cream scene. With a loyal following and a reputation built over generations, it remains a beloved destination where tradition and flavor come together.