BuFALINA

BuFALINA is a Pizza Place in Guilford, CT. The restaurant specializes in wood-fired pizza and offers a menu that includes salads featuring mixed greens, roasted local pears, candied pecans, Gorgonzola, and champagne vinaigrette, as well as roasted Castelfranco and Treviso radicchio with caramelized red onion, fontina cheese, and crispy prosciutto. Open Wednesday through Saturday from 4:00 to 8:00 PM, the establishment operates with limited dough capacity, recommending that customers call early for take-out or reservations. The business holds a rating of 4.60 based on customer reviews.

The restaurant is owned and operated by Matthew Scialabba and Melissa Pellegrino, a husband-and-wife team who lived in Italy for over five years, traveling and cooking through all twenty-one regions. Their culinary foundation was established through their first two cookbooks, The Italian Farmers’ Table and The Southern Italian Farmers’ Table, which highlighted authentic regional recipes and rural Italian life. Inspired by their time abroad and a love for wood-fired baking, they opened Bufalina in 2011 in their hometown.

Over the years, the restaurant has received an “Excellent” review from The New York Times and recognition as “Best Pizza in Connecticut” by Connecticut Magazine. The owners are currently preparing to release their third book, Lido, in March 2026, which explores Italian beach club culture and seaside dining. The restaurant provides specific guidance for takeout customers, suggesting that pizzas be ordered slightly underbaked and uncut, then finished in a home oven at 450 degrees for two to three minutes.

The 4.60 rating reflects the positive reception from customers who have reviewed the establishment. This high rating underscores the quality of the wood-fired pizzas and the authentic Italian approach to dining that the owners have cultivated since opening in 2011.

BuFALINA brings the authentic wood-fired pizza traditions of Italy to Guilford, CT, offering a dining experience grounded in the owners’ extensive travels and culinary expertise.

The restaurant sits on Boston Post Road, just a short distance from the Guilford Community Center and Olmsted Outlook.

BizScoreAI awards a perfect 100 out of 100 for Schema and Structure, ensuring that AI assistants and search engines clearly understand the business offerings. The site also achieves a strong 90 out of 100 for Performance, which keeps visitors engaged and supports better search engine rankings.