Best of Little Italy

Best of Little Italy is a catering and deli service in Monroe, New York, serving families and event planners with authentic Italian specialties, including house-made mozzarella, sausages, and a wide selection of imported meats, cheeses, and prepared foods. The business offers full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings, with a dedicated gluten-free menu and daily kitchen preparations of pasta, ravioli, and fresh bread. Located at 785 NY-17M, it serves Monroe and surrounding areas in Orange County, known for its consistently high-quality offerings and friendly, family-oriented service. With a 4.50 rating based on customer reviews, patrons frequently praise the welcoming staff, exceptional customer service, and the nostalgic charm of a classic deli experience.

The business is family-owned and operated by the Scalia family, with Vito Scalia and his sons representing a second generation of caterers. They source the finest ingredients directly from Italy and other global regions, ensuring freshness and authenticity. Daily deliveries of hot bread, pastries, and cheese arrive at the Monroe location, where staff prepare traditional recipes in-house. The deli emphasizes personal service, treating every guest like family, and maintains a strong reputation for quality, consistency, and hospitality. Their catering services are designed to simplify event planning, offering customizable menus and reliable delivery or pickup.

Situated on NY-17M, the business is located just a short drive from the Monroe Post Office and Crane Park; Mill Ponds, and less than a quarter-mile from Schunnemunk Road. It lies approximately 0.3 miles from the Ramapo River and is near the intersection with State Highway 17M, making it easily accessible from nearby communities.

Best of Little Italy stands out for its long-standing reputation, deeply rooted in the Monroe community, and its commitment to quality, authenticity, and personal service. The business is consistently recognized for its high customer satisfaction, with reviews highlighting its warm staff, delicious food, and reliable service. Its well-documented presence online and clean, functional website reflect a business that is both trusted and accessible.

As a cornerstone of Monroe’s dining scene, Best of Little Italy continues to deliver the same beloved Italian flavors and family warmth that have made it a local favorite for years.