Andy's Frozen Custard of Cape Girardeau

Andy's Frozen Custard of Cape Girardeau is an ice cream shop in Cape Girardeau, Missouri, serving fresh, made-to-order frozen custard with a wide array of custom toppings and signature creations. Known for its indulgent concrete mixes, like the BootDaddy, Triple Chocolate, and Ooey Gooey Concrete, each treat is crafted using either vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and loaded with premium ingredients such as Oreo®, Heath® Bar, and fresh fruit. The shop welcomes customers of all ages, offering a fun, nostalgic experience rooted in decades of tradition. Located at 809 N Kingshighway St, it serves the local community and visitors throughout Cape Girardeau and surrounding areas. With a 4.70 rating and strong customer feedback, it stands out for its quality, consistency, and friendly service.

The shop is part of a national chain founded in 1986 in Osage Beach, Missouri, with a legacy built on using only fresh ingredients and a commitment to exceptional customer experience. The original vision was led by John and Carol Kuntz, whose son Andy and his wife Dana carried the brand forward, expanding it across 14 states. Andy’s Frozen Custard emphasizes a culture of employee care and community connection, with each location reflecting a fun, welcoming environment. The chain’s loyalty program rewards customers with free treats and discounts, reinforcing its reputation for consistent, enjoyable service.

Situated on N Kingshighway St, the shop is about a quarter-mile from Choctaw Park and less than a half-mile from both Arena Park and the Cape Girardeau Public Library. It lies just over a third of a mile from Broadway Street and is within a seven-minute walk of Notre Dame High School, making it a convenient stop for students, families, and local residents.

Andy’s Frozen Custard of Cape Girardeau is recognized for delivering a premium frozen custard experience that blends tradition with modern indulgence. Its high rating and loyal customer base reflect a reputation for quality, consistency, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes it a local favorite. In a city known for its community spirit, the shop stands out as a sweet, reliable destination where everyone can enjoy a moment of fun.