Critchlow Agency

Critchlow Agency is an insurance agent in Washington, IN, serving individuals and local businesses with personalized coverage solutions. The agency specializes in auto, home, umbrella, life, Medicare supplement, and commercial insurance, offering tailored protection for personal and business assets. With a 5.00 rating based on customer reviews, the agency is recognized for its reliable, knowledgeable service and commitment to client needs. Their coverage options are designed to meet clients’ evolving requirements, whether for personal protection or business security, and they serve residents throughout the Washington area.

Monty Critchlow, the founder and lead agent, brings decades of experience to the agency, having worked in insurance and banking for over 40 years. A lifelong resident of Indiana, he was raised in Bloomington and has deep roots in Washington, where he has lived for many years with his wife Debbie and their family. He has been actively involved in the community through youth soccer coaching, the Civil War roundtable, and Junior Achievement. Since establishing The Critchlow Agency, Inc. in 2005, Monty has built a trusted name in local insurance. His team includes Stephanie Marchino, who combines her background in horticulture and banking with her family’s legacy, and Jacki Perkins, whose expertise in accounting and customer service supports the agency’s client-first approach.

Located at 9 SE 2nd Street, the agency occupies a historic building originally constructed in 1877, which once housed Washington’s fire engine and a two-cell jailhouse. The building, now a centerpiece of downtown Washington, reflects the town’s rich heritage. The agency is situated just a short walk from Meradith Park Plaza and the Daviess County Museum, and within a half-mile of the Soldier’s Monument and major roads including Southeast 5th Street and Center Street.

Critchlow Agency stands out for its well-documented presence online and a website structured for clarity and accessibility, reflecting a business that is transparent and easy to engage with. With strong community ties, decades of combined experience, and a reputation for dependable service, the agency is a trusted local authority in insurance. As a cornerstone of Washington’s downtown, Critchlow Agency remains deeply committed to protecting the people and places that matter most in the heart of Indiana.