Tingley Insurance Agency

Tingley Insurance Agency is an insurance agent in Effingham, IL, serving individuals and businesses with comprehensive coverage solutions. The agency specializes in auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, health insurance, commercial insurance, farm insurance, trucking insurance, watercraft and boat insurance, ATV and motorcycle insurance, and surety bonds. As a family-owned business with over 20 years of experience, Tingley Insurance Agency provides personalized service to clients throughout Effingham County and the surrounding areas. The agency emphasizes competitive pricing and free estimates, helping customers secure the best rates for their chosen policies.

Located at 217 W Jefferson Ave in Effingham, IL, Tingley Insurance Agency operates from a storefront on a primary commercial corridor in the city’s downtown area. The agency is led by Chris Tingley, who oversees a team of licensed agents committed to responsive, competent, and customer-focused service. As an independent agency, Tingley Insurance Agency works with multiple insurance providers to offer clients a range of options, ensuring tailored coverage that meets individual needs. Their service offerings include both personal and commercial insurance, with an emphasis on long-term protection and financial security.

The agency has built a reputation for reliability and personalized attention, supported by a strong commitment to customer service and decades of local experience. Though no reviews are currently listed, the business continues to serve the Effingham community with trusted insurance solutions across multiple lines of coverage. Tingley Insurance Agency remains a consistent presence in the area, helping residents and businesses safeguard their assets with expertise and care.