Mixed Fillings Pie Shop

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a family-owned bakery in Jacksonville, Florida, located in the city’s historic Downtown District. Specializing in scratch-made sweet and savory pies, the shop crafts each dessert using fresh, seasonal ingredients and traditional techniques, with a focus on bold flavors and nostalgic comfort. Their offerings include handcrafted Southern pies, available for local families, weddings, catering, and special events. Known for their flaky, butter-based crusts and creative flavor combinations, the shop has earned a 4.90 rating from customers, reflecting strong community trust and satisfaction. They serve the Jacksonville area with a commitment to quality and authenticity, delivering handmade pies that bring people together.

The shop emphasizes creativity and connection, describing pie as more than dessert, it’s a mood. Every pie is made with intention, technique, and heart, drawing inspiration from Southern traditions while introducing unexpected twists. Mixed Fillings offers hands-on baking classes for all skill levels and hosts community gatherings, storytelling events, and seasonal pop-ups, including a regular presence at the Riverside Arts Market. The shop has been featured in national media such as Southern Living and Good Morning America and was named the top pie shop in Florida for 2021 and 2022.

Located at 440 W Adams Street, the shop sits just a short walk from the Duval County Courthouse, the Ed Austin Building, and the Office of the State Attorney, all within a quarter-mile radius. It is also near West Bay Street and West Forsyth Street, key roads in downtown Jacksonville, and a block from the Central train station, making it easily accessible for locals and visitors alike.

With a reputation built on flavor, craftsmanship, and community engagement, Mixed Fillings Pie Shop stands out as a beloved local institution in Jacksonville’s culinary scene. Their dedication to real ingredients, handmade quality, and shared moments defines their role in the city’s food culture.