Pinocchios Original Italian Ice Cream

Pinocchios Original Italian Ice Cream is a family-owned ice cream shop in Iona, FL, specializing in handcrafted Italian ice cream and gelato made with a commitment to quality and bold, unique flavors. Known for its signature creations like Sanibel Krunch and Dirty Sand Dollar, the shop offers a nostalgic yet innovative take on frozen treats, drawing on decades of tradition and international inspiration. The business serves the Iona community and surrounding areas, including nearby neighborhoods such as Alexan Solmar and Laguna Lakes, and is located just a short walk from major local landmarks. Though it currently has no reviews, the shop’s 4.70 rating reflects strong customer appreciation for its authentic, high-quality desserts.

The Pinocchio’s story began in 1980 on Sanibel Island and was revitalized in 2007 when the Puma family, Tom, Donna, and daughter Stephanie, became the fourth owners. Drawing on their time living in Arezzo, Italy, the Pumas revived the original gelato-making traditions while infusing new flavor ideas from their travels across Europe. For over 20 years, each serving has been crowned with an Animal Cracker, a signature tradition that continues to delight customers. Though the franchise model was discontinued in 2017, the family remains dedicated to crafting premium frozen confections and expanding the brand through new locations, including one in Fort Myers.

The shop is situated on Summerlin Road, just 0.2 miles from Alexan Solmar Apartments and within a short distance of LabCorp, Park Royal Hospital, and Golisano Children's Hospital of Southwest Florida. Its location places it in close proximity to key healthcare and residential areas, making it a convenient destination for locals seeking a sweet treat.

The shop is celebrated for its authentic Italian-inspired recipes, consistent quality, and deep-rooted family values. With a legacy spanning decades and a focus on craftsmanship, Pinocchio’s stands as a beloved destination for those seeking rich, memorable ice cream experiences in Southwest Florida.