Bagel Bros Cafe

Bagel Bros Cafe is a coffee shop in Eustis, FL, specializing in hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, cedar wood baked bagels made fresh daily. The shop offers a range of breakfast sandwiches, including the Bacon Egg & Cheese and Taylor Ham Egg & Cheese, along with fresh cream cheese spreads and popular items like the Smash Sausage Egg N Cheese and Ridge Diablo. Known for its commitment to quality and authenticity, the business draws from a legacy that began in 1995 in New Jersey, rooted in family, craftsmanship, and a dedication to doing things the right way. While the shop serves the Eustis community and nearby areas, it currently has no verified reviews on Google.

The business was founded in Stirling, New Jersey, by Sam El-Hassan, who built a family-owned brand centered on tradition, community, and pride in every detail, from rolling the dough to baking the bagels over cedar wood. The brand emphasizes a daily ritual of freshness, with all bagels prepared from scratch each morning. The menu features both classic and innovative offerings, including high-protein items like the Protein Peach Tea and signature iced coffee drinks such as the Cinilla, designed to deliver flavor and energy in every sip. The brand’s philosophy is simple: “It’s not a bagel unless it’s O’Bagel.”

Located on S Bay St in Eustis, the shop sits within the heart of the city’s downtown corridor, surrounded by local activity and accessible to residents and visitors alike. Though specific nearby landmarks are not listed, the location is situated in a central, walkable area of Eustis, making it a convenient stop for morning coffee and breakfast.

Though the business currently has no customer reviews, its foundational values, authenticity, consistency, and a deep respect for the craft of bagel-making, reflect a commitment to quality that has sustained the brand since its founding. With roots in New Jersey and a growing presence in Florida, Bagel Bros Cafe continues to bring a taste of classic New York-style bagels to the Eustis community.